A Legal Analysis of Deductible Clauses and the Scope of Insurer Subrogation in Automobile Collision Coverage - A Critical Analysis of the Supreme Court of Korea’s Decision of January 29, 2026, Case No. 2022Da287284
Korean Insurance Law Association · 30.06.2026 · 20 (2) · 199-239
DOI: 10.36248/kdps.2026.20.2.199 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Korean Insurance Law Association, online erschienen am 30.06.2026. Verfasst von Gyu Seong Cho.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This article examines the treatment of deductibles under automobile own-damage coverage following the Supreme Court of Korea’s decision of January 29, 2026, Case No. 2022Da287284. The cases arose from automobile accidents involving comparative fault. After their own-damage insurers paid the covered losses less the agreed deductibles, the insureds sought to recover the deducted amounts from the other drivers’ liability insurers. The dispute raised two questions: whether the deductible constitutes uncompensated loss protected by the proviso to Article 682(1) of the Korean Commercial Act, and whether the insured retains a direct claim against the liable third party. The Supreme Court did not treat the entire deductible as recoverable loss. Under the first-payment method, however, it allowed the insured to recover the portion corresponding to the third party’s share of liability. The Court reached a different conclusion under the cross-settlement method, where the third party’s insurer had already paid the amount attributable to that party. The judgment addresses a genuine concern. A liable third party should not benefit merely because the injured party used first-party insurance. Its reasoning, however, leaves a doctrinal gap. The deductible limits the own-damage insurer’s contractual payment obligation and identifies the part of the risk retained by the insured. Once the insurer deducts the agreed amount and pays the balance, it has ordinarily performed that obligation. The Court nevertheless treated part of the same deductible as loss remaining with the insured against the third party. It did not fully explain the legal basis for that distinction or why the order of claims handling should affect the scope of the insured’s claim. German and American law offer a different framework. German law first determines the Kasko insurer’s contractual obligation, including the deductible, and then uses the Quotenvorrecht to allocate third-party recoveries. Several U.S. jurisdictions also preserve the deductible as a contractual allocation of risk while regulating the distribution of subrogation recoveries through case law or supervisory rules. The details vary, but both systems separate the insurer’s contractual obligation from the later allocation of recoveries. This article argues for the same distinction under Korean law. The own-damage insurer should conduct the recovery process and refund the portion attributable to the insured under a predetermined allocation rule. The insurer may exercise statutory subrogation for the benefits it paid and, with appropriate authority from the insured, pursue the deductible portion in the same proceeding. The insured’s direct claim should remain available when the insurer fails to pursue recovery. Standard policy terms should state the insurer’s recovery authority, the order in which recovered funds are allocated, the amount and timing of any refund, and the duty to notify the insured. This arrangement would preserve the contractual function of the deductible without allowing a liable third party to reduce its responsibility because the injured party used own-damage coverage.
Zitieren
APA
Cho, G. S. (2026). A Legal Analysis of Deductible Clauses and the Scope of Insurer Subrogation in Automobile Collision Coverage - A Critical Analysis of the Supreme Court of Korea’s Decision of January 29, 2026, Case No. 2022Da287284. Korean Insurance Law Association, 20(2), 199-239. https://doi.org/10.36248/kdps.2026.20.2.199
Vancouver
Cho GS. A Legal Analysis of Deductible Clauses and the Scope of Insurer Subrogation in Automobile Collision Coverage - A Critical Analysis of the Supreme Court of Korea’s Decision of January 29, 2026, Case No. 2022Da287284. Korean Insurance Law Association. 2026;20(2):199-239. doi:10.36248/kdps.2026.20.2.199
BibTeX
@article{Cho2026,
author = {Cho, Gyu Seong},
title = {A Legal Analysis of Deductible Clauses and the Scope of Insurer Subrogation in Automobile Collision Coverage - A Critical Analysis of the Supreme Court of Korea’s Decision of January 29, 2026, Case No. 2022Da287284},
journal = {Korean Insurance Law Association},
year = {2026},
volume = {20},
number = {2},
pages = {199--239},
doi = {10.36248/kdps.2026.20.2.199}
}
EUVIMED