A Legal Study on Practical Issues Arising from the Application of the Out-of-Pocket Maximum System to Indemnity Medical Insurance
Korean Insurance Law Association · 30.06.2026 · 20 (2) · 45-95
DOI: 10.36248/kdps.2026.20.2.045 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Korean Insurance Law Association, online erschienen am 30.06.2026. Verfasst von Chan Il Yeom.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The Out-of-Pocket Maximum System is a public health insurance scheme designed to alleviate the excessive medical expense burden borne by subscribers of the National Health Insurance system. In its relationship with private indemnity health insurance, commonly referred to as indemnity medical insurance, various legal disputes have arisen concerning the interpretation of insurance policy terms and conditions. In particular, whether reimbursements paid ex post under the Out-of-Pocket Maximum System should be deducted when calculating indemnity medical insurance benefits has long constituted a significant practical and legal issue. Recent court decisions, however, have largely clarified that reimbursements under the Out-of-Pocket Maximum System are deductible under the interpretation of policy provisions regardless of the timing of enrollment in indemnity medical insurance. Consequently, current practice generally applies such deductions when calculating insurance benefits irrespective of the policyholder’s enrollment period. Although the legal controversy concerning the applicability of the Out-of-Pocket Maximum System to indemnity medical insurance has thus been substantially resolved, insufficient attention has been paid to the various legal issues that continue to arise in the practical process of calculating and paying insurance benefits after the application of the system. Examples include issues concerning the scope and legality of personal information disclosure in verifying the insured’s National Health Insurance premium payments; the possibility of changes in estimated reimbursement amounts resulting from fluctuations in income decile classifications; the treatment of cases in which coverage is converted, or may be converted, from National Health Insurance to workers’ compensation insurance or automobile insurance; the exclusion of certain medical expenses from calculation due to deductibles or waiting-period provisions under indemnity medical insurance policies; problems arising when an insured fails to return amounts corresponding to actual reimbursements after receiving insurance benefits calculated on the basis of estimated reimbursement amounts pursuant to a reimbursement agreement; the succession of such repayment obligations as inheritance liabilities upon the death of the insured; and the set-off of unreturned insurance benefits against other insurance claims. These issues frequently arise in practice. Most importantly, such legal complications may result in discrepancies between the actual reimbursement amount under the Out-of-Pocket Maximum System and the amount deducted in advance or subsequently recovered by the insurer. This article reviews the appellate-level judicial precedents concerning disputes that have arisen between indemnity medical insurance and the Out-of-Pocket Maximum System. On the premise that the system is now broadly applied in indemnity medical insurance practice, it examines the principal legal issues arising in the insurance benefit payment process by categorizing them according to their respective types. Furthermore, the article proposes several reasonable institutional reforms aimed at addressing these issues and thereby contributing to the prevention and mitigation of related disputes.
Zitieren
APA
Yeom, C. I. (2026). A Legal Study on Practical Issues Arising from the Application of the Out-of-Pocket Maximum System to Indemnity Medical Insurance. Korean Insurance Law Association, 20(2), 45-95. https://doi.org/10.36248/kdps.2026.20.2.045
Vancouver
Yeom CI. A Legal Study on Practical Issues Arising from the Application of the Out-of-Pocket Maximum System to Indemnity Medical Insurance. Korean Insurance Law Association. 2026;20(2):45-95. doi:10.36248/kdps.2026.20.2.045
BibTeX
@article{Yeom2026,
author = {Yeom, Chan Il},
title = {A Legal Study on Practical Issues Arising from the Application of the Out-of-Pocket Maximum System to Indemnity Medical Insurance},
journal = {Korean Insurance Law Association},
year = {2026},
volume = {20},
number = {2},
pages = {45--95},
doi = {10.36248/kdps.2026.20.2.045}
}
EUVIMED