A Study on the Supreme Court’s 2026 Ruling on Deductibles in Automobile Insurance : Deductibles as a Commons
Korean Insurance Law Association · 28.02.2026 · 20 (1) · 3-44
DOI: 10.36248/kdps.2026.20.1.003 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Korean Insurance Law Association, online erschienen am 28.02.2026. Verfasst von Jun Kyo Lee.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Because the majority of traffic accidents involve mutual fault between the parties, the ability of an insured to recover the full amount of the deductible from the opposing insurer would, in effect, signify the disappearance of the deductible system itself. Such an argument recalls the logic of the Tragedy of the Commons. The deductible system, designed as a policy mechanism to protect the collective interests of the insurance pool by imposing a portion of responsibility on accident-causing parties, functions as a shared resource. If those subject to deductibles actively seek to reclaim them, the system becomes ineffective, inevitably leading to an inequitable outcome in which the resulting costs are dispersed among the entire group of insureds. In January 2026, the Supreme Court of Korea rejected lower court decisions that had denied any reimbursement of deductibles and, relying on the doctrine of insurer subrogation, held that at least a portion of the deductible may be recoverable from the opposing liability insurer. This article quantitatively analyzes how the economic interests between insurers and insureds change when applying the Supreme Court’s criteria as compared to the current compensation practice standards. It further examines whether the resulting quantitative differences can be rationally justified in light of the purpose and objectives of the deductible system. Based on this analysis, the article concludes that maintaining the existing compensation practice standards, rather than adopting the Supreme Court’s criteria, is more consistent with the operational objectives of the deductible system. Moreover, the current standards are found to be faithful to the textual interpretation of insurance policy provisions while remaining aligned with the underlying rationale of insurer subrogation. By contrast, the Supreme Court’s approach is criticized for failing to reasonably or fairly reflect the purpose of insurer subrogation in terms of interest coordination and risk distribution among insurers, insureds, and third parties, and therefore warrants reconsideration.
Zitieren
APA
Lee, J. K. (2026). A Study on the Supreme Court’s 2026 Ruling on Deductibles in Automobile Insurance : Deductibles as a Commons. Korean Insurance Law Association, 20(1), 3-44. https://doi.org/10.36248/kdps.2026.20.1.003
Vancouver
Lee JK. A Study on the Supreme Court’s 2026 Ruling on Deductibles in Automobile Insurance : Deductibles as a Commons. Korean Insurance Law Association. 2026;20(1):3-44. doi:10.36248/kdps.2026.20.1.003
BibTeX
@article{Lee2026,
author = {Lee, Jun Kyo},
title = {A Study on the Supreme Court’s 2026 Ruling on Deductibles in Automobile Insurance : Deductibles as a Commons},
journal = {Korean Insurance Law Association},
year = {2026},
volume = {20},
number = {1},
pages = {3--44},
doi = {10.36248/kdps.2026.20.1.003}
}
EUVIMED