위법비용의 손금성에 관한 판례 Reconstructing the Case Law on the Deductibility of Illegal Business Expenses : A Legislative Propos법리의 재구성과 입법론적 검토
THE KOREAN TAX ASSOCIATION · 30.09.2026 · 43 (3) · 215-245
DOI: 10.35850/kjtr.43.3.07 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift THE KOREAN TAX ASSOCIATION, online erschienen am 30.09.2026. Verfasst von Nanhee Hong.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This study reconstructs the Korean Supreme Court’s case law on the deductibility of illegal business expenses under Article 19(2) of the Corporate Tax Act into an ex ante predictable analytical framework, and proposes corresponding legislative reforms. The Corporate Tax Act treats “ordinariness” and “direct relevance to revenue” as alternative requirements for deductibility, leaving open the possibility that illegal expenses may be deductible. However, the Supreme Court has denied such deductions through the concept of “normative ordinariness,” and the conventional approach of classifying these precedents ex post into cases granting or denying deductions fails to explain why similar cases reach opposite conclusions. This study reconstructs the Court’s decision-making sequence into a three-step framework:(1) whether the payment itself satisfies the elements of a criminal offense;(2) if not, whether the expenditure compensates for harm already incurred;and (3) if neither, whether it distorts a counterparty’s judgment through an intermediary position, non-disclosure of interest, and probable influence on the decision. Applied to nine landmark precedents, this framework precisely matches the Court’s actual holdings, suggesting that “normative ordinariness” follows a consistent but never codified standard. A comparative review of the United States, Germany, and Japan reveals three distinct limitations -an unregulated gap for private-sector kickbacks in Japan, a crime- contingent codification unable to reach new types of expenditure in Germany, and a residual, unpredictable judicial doctrine outside the codified domain in the United States. Building on these insights, this study proposes a hybrid model combining exhaustive enumeration for consideration-based crimes with a factor-based general clause for judgment-distorting expenditures, together with a concrete draft amendment introducing Article 21-3 of the Corporate Tax Act.
Zitieren
APA
Hong, N. (2026). 위법비용의 손금성에 관한 판례 Reconstructing the Case Law on the Deductibility of Illegal Business Expenses : A Legislative Propos법리의 재구성과 입법론적 검토. THE KOREAN TAX ASSOCIATION, 43(3), 215-245. https://doi.org/10.35850/kjtr.43.3.07
Vancouver
Hong N. 위법비용의 손금성에 관한 판례 Reconstructing the Case Law on the Deductibility of Illegal Business Expenses : A Legislative Propos법리의 재구성과 입법론적 검토. THE KOREAN TAX ASSOCIATION. 2026;43(3):215-245. doi:10.35850/kjtr.43.3.07
BibTeX
@article{Hong2026,
author = {Hong, Nanhee},
title = {위법비용의 손금성에 관한 판례 Reconstructing the Case Law on the Deductibility of Illegal Business Expenses : A Legislative Propos법리의 재구성과 입법론적 검토},
journal = {THE KOREAN TAX ASSOCIATION},
year = {2026},
volume = {43},
number = {3},
pages = {215--245},
doi = {10.35850/kjtr.43.3.07}
}
EUVIMED