The Pre-Truth of the Place (Rather than “The Lie of the Land”): Representations of Bengal in the Writings of Early European Travellers
Représentations dans le monde anglophone · 2024
DOI: 10.35562/rma.1085 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Représentations dans le monde anglophone, 2024. Verfasst von Saugata Bhaduri.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This article argues that the concept of ‘pre‑truth’—or what lies before a regime of ‘Truth’ (or ‘Lies’) about a certain subject sets in—can help one take on the vagaries of ‘post‑truth’ that later peril that subject. In the colonial context, for instance, one can see that the ‘lie of the land’ (in both senses of the word ‘lie’) that emerges out of colonial mapping, is often preceded by prior accounts of the yet to be colonized territory, producing a pre-colonial body of ‘pre‑truth of the place’, whose subsequent appropriation lays bare the manipulation that Truth or Post-Truth regimes undertake. This article looks at writings of ‘early modern’ European travellers to Bengal, prior to Europe’s ‘polycolonial’ contact with the area: both as ‘extra-colonials’ i.e. late 13th to early 16th century travellers from European countries (primarily Italy) which did not have colonies in Bengal—‘pre-colonials’—i.e. the first Portuguese, Dutch, English, and French travellers from the early 16th to the mid‑17th centuries, who visited Bengal prior to their respective countries having colonies there. The article, in studying the writings of eight such travellers, notes a gradual accretion of pre‑truth about Bengal, and identifies ten themes that emerge from the same. It further argues that these ten themes can form the template for a toolkit with which Bengalis can resist the identitarian polarization and fundamentalisms triggered by post-truth and fake news on both sides of their borders today. This is all the more because this toolkit is derived from the pre‑truth imagination of Bengal by Europeans, rather than Bengalis themselves, as it is only from the other’s provisionally true (or pre‑true) perspective that one can deflate one’s self-same identitarian post‑truths.
Zitieren
APA
Bhaduri, S. (2024). The Pre-Truth of the Place (Rather than “The Lie of the Land”): Representations of Bengal in the Writings of Early European Travellers. Représentations dans le monde anglophone. https://doi.org/10.35562/rma.1085
Vancouver
Bhaduri S. The Pre-Truth of the Place (Rather than “The Lie of the Land”): Representations of Bengal in the Writings of Early European Travellers. Représentations dans le monde anglophone. 2024. doi:10.35562/rma.1085
BibTeX
@article{Bhaduri2024,
author = {Bhaduri, Saugata},
title = {The Pre-Truth of the Place (Rather than “The Lie of the Land”): Representations of Bengal in the Writings of Early European Travellers},
journal = {Représentations dans le monde anglophone},
year = {2024},
doi = {10.35562/rma.1085}
}
EUVIMED