EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

Religious Studies Expertise: Problems and Perspectives

A.K. Pogasiy

Pushkin Leningrad State University Journal · 2026 · 1 · 158-175

DOI: 10.35231/18186653_2026_1_158 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Pushkin Leningrad State University Journal, 2026. Verfasst von A.K. Pogasiy.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Introduction

The article addresses key issues in the functioning of the institution of religious studies expertise in the Russian Federation, which manifest both at the methodological level and in law-enforcement practice. Content. Religious studies expertise (more broadly – complex religious-psychological-linguistic expertise) is intended to serve as a tool of administrative and judicial authorities in shaping internal policy in the field of state–confessional relations. For this tool to operate effectively, it requires precise “fine-tuning” as well as sufficient qualifications of the relevant specialists. The article analyzes the problems related to the difficulties of conducting and applying such expertise in various situations. Special attention is given to the analysis of court cases concerning the recognition of the activities of certain religious organizations as extremist – in particular, the cases against Jehovah’s Witnesses1, which have become the most illustrative in the context of using religious-studies expert opinions in courts. Based on the review of judicial rulings and expert documents, methodological deficiencies are identified, including ambiguity in the conceptual framework used, substitution of scientific descriptions of religious phenomena with evaluative judgments, and inconsistency between expert conclusions and the principles of scientific objectivity. An important place in the study is occupied by the 2021 clarifications of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, which are aimed at improving the quality of judicial expertise and limiting the arbitrary use of expert opinions not based on scientifically verifiable data. Despite the positive nature of these clarifications, the analysis shows that institutional problems remain significant: there are no unified standards for training experts in religious studies, no system of professional accreditation, and expert findings are often used by courts to legitimize decisions that are predetermined.

Conclusions

The article proposes directions for reforming the institution of religious studies expertise, including the necessity of developing unified methodological standards, increasing transparency of the expert process, introducing mechanisms for independent scientific review, and creating an institutional framework that ensures a balance between the scientific autonomy of experts and the requirements of the legal system.

Zitieren

APA

Pogasiy, A. (2026). Religious Studies Expertise: Problems and Perspectives. Pushkin Leningrad State University Journal, 1, 158-175. https://doi.org/10.35231/18186653_2026_1_158

Vancouver

Pogasiy A. Religious Studies Expertise: Problems and Perspectives. Pushkin Leningrad State University Journal. 2026;1:158-175. doi:10.35231/18186653_2026_1_158

BibTeX
@article{Pogasiy2026,
  author = {Pogasiy, A.K.},
  title = {Religious Studies Expertise: Problems and Perspectives},
  journal = {Pushkin Leningrad State University Journal},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {1},
  pages = {158--175},
  doi = {10.35231/18186653_2026_1_158}
}
Kostenlos starten →