Authentication through the Declarant’s In-Court Testimony: A Requirement for Hearsay Exceptions in Korean Criminal Procedure
The Korean Association of Criminal Procedure Law · 31.03.2026 · 18 (1) · 91-164
DOI: 10.34222/kdps.2026.18.1.3 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift The Korean Association of Criminal Procedure Law, online erschienen am 31.03.2026. Verfasst von Woongjae Kim.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Since its enactment, the Korean Criminal Procedure Act has required, as a core requirement for admitting hearsay documents into evidence, authentication through the declarant’s in-court testimony. Traditionally, this requirement has often been characterized as a uniquely Korean rule, unprecedented in comparative law—one that cannot be rationally explained within the framework of the hearsay rule. Such assessments, however, are unpersuasive. Properly understood, this requirement consists of two elements: (1) the appearance of the declarant in court and his or her examination as a witness, and (2) proof of the existence of the original statement through the declarant’s in-court testimony. Legislative approaches that recognize an exception to the hearsay rule when these elements are satisfied are widely found in common-law jurisdictions that have adopted the hearsay rule, particularly in the regulation of prior statements of witnesses. Accordingly, the Korean requirement cannot be regarded as unprecedented from a comparative perspective. Moreover, recognizing an exception to the hearsay rule under these conditions is grounded in the premise that the reliability risks inherent in hearsay evidence can be sufficiently neutralized through “retrospective testability”—i.e., the opportunity to test the reliability of the statement ex post by requiring the declarant to appear in court and submit to cross-examination regarding the prior statement. From this standpoint, the rule can be rationally explained within the theoretical framework of the hearsay rule. Likewise, limiting the methods for proving the existence of the original statement to the declarant’s in-court testimony or other objective means—such as video recordings—serves to ensure the effectiveness of this ex post testing of the declarant and can therefore also be justified within hearsay theory. In this sense, the relevant provisions of Korean law are fully consistent with the theoretical foundations of the hearsay rule. They should be understood as one variation among the many legislative models governing prior statements of witnesses in jurisdictions that recognize the hearsay rule.
Zitieren
APA
Kim, W. (2026). Authentication through the Declarant’s In-Court Testimony: A Requirement for Hearsay Exceptions in Korean Criminal Procedure. The Korean Association of Criminal Procedure Law, 18(1), 91-164. https://doi.org/10.34222/kdps.2026.18.1.3
Vancouver
Kim W. Authentication through the Declarant’s In-Court Testimony: A Requirement for Hearsay Exceptions in Korean Criminal Procedure. The Korean Association of Criminal Procedure Law. 2026;18(1):91-164. doi:10.34222/kdps.2026.18.1.3
BibTeX
@article{Kim2026,
author = {Kim, Woongjae},
title = {Authentication through the Declarant’s In-Court Testimony: A Requirement for Hearsay Exceptions in Korean Criminal Procedure},
journal = {The Korean Association of Criminal Procedure Law},
year = {2026},
volume = {18},
number = {1},
pages = {91--164},
doi = {10.34222/kdps.2026.18.1.3}
}
EUVIMED