Figurative-semantic and compositional-dramaturgical features of the interpretation of the cycle in D. Bortniansky’s and A. Vedel’s sacred concertos
Aspects of Historical Musicology · 29.06.2026 · 43 (43) · 173-189
DOI: 10.34064/khnum2-43.07 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Aspects of Historical Musicology, online erschienen am 29.06.2026. Verfasst von Vitalii Karas. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Statement of the problem. The article deals with Ukrainian musical Classicism, which encompasses the creative heritage of composers of the second half of the 18th century. The main attention is paid to creative achievements in the field of sacred music, primarily in the genre of choral concert, which at this time underwent intensive development, and in the work of individual composers an individual authorial intonation arises. Ukrainian sacred music of ancient stages was directly influenced by the poetics of liturgical texts, permeated with transcendental ideas, as evidenced by numerous works that have survived to our time. Despite the general trends, in the creative heritage of authors of sacred music one can find specific features that indicate individual priorities, which can be identified in comparative studies. Such studies are extremely important, since the sacred music of Ukrainian composers of the Classicism era is usually studied as a holistic phenomenon, beyond the specifics of individual manifestations. The object of this study is the individual specifics of the interpretation of cycles in choral concertos of the two most prominent representatives of Ukrainian music of the second half of the 18th century – Dmytro Bortniansky and Artemii Vedel. Recent research and publications. A fairly significant number of scientific publications have been devoted to the work of Bortniansky and Vedel, and recently there has been an emphasis on the study of Vedel’s work, which can be observed in the example of numerous scientific studies by Ukrainian scholars (Husarchuk, 2017; Tylyk, 2013; Kutasevych, 2015; Lysenko, 2022). The scientific study of Bortniansky’s spiritual heritage is not so active; we can mention two publications of a collection of his “35 concertos for mixed choir”, based on the lifetime edition (Kuzma, 2016) and based on the edition of Tchaikovsky (in Ukrainian transliteration) by the famous Ukrainian choral conductor, artistic director of the National Honored Academic Chapel of Ukraine “Dumka” Yevhen Savchuk (Bortniansky, 2020), as well as separate scientific works by Ukrainian choirmasters (Tsmur, 2013; Kuzma, 2018; Shpak, 2025), which primarily concern performance aspects. Objectives, methods, and novelty of the research. The purpose of the study is to consider the individual specificity of the interpretation of the concert cycle in D. Bortniansky’s and A. Vedel’s sacred concertos. Concertos No. 32 by Bortniansky and No 3 by Vedel, which have similar figurative and emotional content, were chosen as the material for the analysis. The novelty of the article lies in an attempt to compare the approaches of both composers to understanding the concert cycle. The work is based on the principles of comparative analysis, which makes it possible to determine the individual specificity of the creative method of each composer in the interpretation of concert cycles. Conclusion. A comparison of the Concertos showed that the figurative and emotional similarity of both works did not affect the interpretation of the cycle, which underwent individual manifestations. In Bortniansky’s Concerto No. 32, the restrained drama of the first three movements, written in slow tempos, is compensated by the choral fugue, which is the finale of the concerto cycle and contrasts with the initial movements in tempo-dynamic features and in texture material. In Vedel’s Concerto No 3, all three movements unfold in slow tempos, as a result of which restrained-sad moods dominate, and contrasting juxtapositions of material are absent. Concertos written in a similar manner are not characteristic of Bortniansky’s work, while such model is prevailing in Vedel’s.
Zitieren
APA
Karas, V. (2026). Figurative-semantic and compositional-dramaturgical features of the interpretation of the cycle in D. Bortniansky’s and A. Vedel’s sacred concertos. Aspects of Historical Musicology, 43(43), 173-189. https://doi.org/10.34064/khnum2-43.07
Vancouver
Karas V. Figurative-semantic and compositional-dramaturgical features of the interpretation of the cycle in D. Bortniansky’s and A. Vedel’s sacred concertos. Aspects of Historical Musicology. 2026;43(43):173-189. doi:10.34064/khnum2-43.07
BibTeX
@article{Karas2026,
author = {Karas, Vitalii},
title = {Figurative-semantic and compositional-dramaturgical features of the interpretation of the cycle in D. Bortniansky’s and A. Vedel’s sacred concertos},
journal = {Aspects of Historical Musicology},
year = {2026},
volume = {43},
number = {43},
pages = {173--189},
doi = {10.34064/khnum2-43.07}
}
EUVIMED