The logic of probability and choice in the analysis of tonal harmony
Problems of Interaction Between Arts, Pedagogy and the Theory and Practice of Education · 26.03.2026 · 78 (78) · 9-33
DOI: 10.34064/khnum1-78.01 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Problems of Interaction Between Arts, Pedagogy and the Theory and Practice of Education, online erschienen am 26.03.2026. Verfasst von Artem Lіakhovych. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Statement of the problem. Tonal harmony has been exhaustively considered within the framework of structural analysis. There is also a huge body of research devoted to various semantic interpretations of certain musical works. However, the semantic analysis of harmony has not yet received theoretical foundations that would claim methodological generalization. This problem determines the relevance of this study, which is associated with an important scientific task: the development of a methodology for the semantic analysis of tonal harmony. Recent research and publications. The basis of this study is our article «Regeneration properties of the tonal system» (Liakhovych, 2012). Tonal harmony is traditionally considered within the framework of structural analysis without the involvement of semiotics. As an exception in Ukrainian musicology, one can point to the classical works of T. Kravtsov (1984), I. Piaskovskyi (1973; 2009) and the textbook of V. Moskalenko (2013). I. Kokhanyk in her works (2002, 2002, 2017, 2020) pays special attention to the category of style, which includes the semantic analysis of music. In English-speaking musicology, the scientific tradition of semantic analysis of harmony was initiated by the classical work of D. Cooke (1959). Currently, the leading figure in this field is Professor Ph. Schlenker (New York University) who proposed a new theory of musical semantics with the category of “virtual sources” in tonal space, which is directly related to the semantics of harmony (Schlenker, 2017, 2019, 2022). Among other works, the approach of L. Zbikowski (2012) in his work “Music, Language and What’s in Between” is interesting. Objectives, methods, and novelty of the research. The purpose of the study is to outline a methodology for the semantic analysis of tonal harmony that, on the one hand, would not ignore the fundamental barrier separating music from speech, and on the other hand, would not consider its presence as evidence of formalism. The study is based on a set of scientific approaches necessary to reveal the issues of a specific topic: the systemic approach combines the methods of contextual, functional, structural and hermeneutic analysis. At the same time, the methodology in the article appears not only as a tool, but also as a priority goal: the scientific novelty of the study lies in the proposal of our own version of the methodology of semantic analysis. The method proposed here is based on the identification of its own regularities of the harmonic structure without shifting the emphasis to their artistic interpretation, that is, to descriptiveness. Research result. Tonal harmony is a musical model of the hierarchy of subjective probability, where authentic attraction is the coordinate of necessity, and real harmonization is the coordinate of the author’s choice. Thus, tonal harmony is also a model of the relationship between necessity and choice. Conclusion. The structure of the tonal system, consisting of many subsystems, determined the main phenomenon of harmony: probability and its violation are components of one system. Any musical text can be imagined as a conflicting unity of potential and realization. Any music is a conflict of its author with the structure, paradoxically embedded in the structure itself. It is this conflict that is the prime mover of music. Thus, the tonal system appears as a logical code of the world in which man exists. This code allowed
Zitieren
APA
Lіakhovych, A. (2026). The logic of probability and choice in the analysis of tonal harmony. Problems of Interaction Between Arts, Pedagogy and the Theory and Practice of Education, 78(78), 9-33. https://doi.org/10.34064/khnum1-78.01
Vancouver
Lіakhovych A. The logic of probability and choice in the analysis of tonal harmony. Problems of Interaction Between Arts, Pedagogy and the Theory and Practice of Education. 2026;78(78):9-33. doi:10.34064/khnum1-78.01
BibTeX
@article{Lakhovych2026,
author = {Lіakhovych, Artem},
title = {The logic of probability and choice in the analysis of tonal harmony},
journal = {Problems of Interaction Between Arts, Pedagogy and the Theory and Practice of Education},
year = {2026},
volume = {78},
number = {78},
pages = {9--33},
doi = {10.34064/khnum1-78.01}
}
EUVIMED