F. Mendelssohn’s Sonatas for Two Pianos: formation of the genre, and performers’ dialogue
Problems of Interaction Between Arts, Pedagogy and the Theory and Practice of Education · 30.12.2025 · 77 (77) · 61-77
DOI: 10.34064/khnum1-77.04 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Problems of Interaction Between Arts, Pedagogy and the Theory and Practice of Education, online erschienen am 30.12.2025. Verfasst von Alina Martianova. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Statement of the problem. Piano duets in Felix Mendelssohn’s oeuvre have long remained overshadowed by his symphonic, chamber, and solo piano works. Early Sonatas for two pianos (MWV S 1, S 2) and other four-hand compositions reveal stylistic traits that later defined the composer’s musical thinking. Despite their artistic value and technical demands, these works have received limited scholarly attention and minimal performance exposure, particularly in contemporary Ukrainian concert practice. Recent studies of Mendelssohn’s output focus predominantly on symphonic, chamber, and solo piano compositions, as well as “Lieder ohne Worte” (Todd, 2004; Walshaw, 2017). Research on piano concertos (Veremiova, 2012) situates them within the context of Romantic Gesamtkunstwerk. Studies of piano ensembles highlight their expressive potential: I. Polska (1995) analyzes “Andante with Variations” op 83a and “Allegro brillante” op. 92, emphasizing “Innigkeit” and “Innerlichkeit” within the German Romantic four-hand tradition, while I. Sediuk (2017) underscores ensemble dialogue, orchestral thinking, and concert-oriented performance practices. Nevertheless, original early Sonatas for two pianos remain largely unexplored, with existing literature addressing mainly biographical or editorial aspects (Prosseda, 2015; Todd, 2004). Objectives, methods, and novelty of the research. The purpose of the article is to outline the stylistic features of Mendelssohn’s Sonatas for two pianos in the context of the genre’s development and to identify the principles of performers’ dialogue as a criterion for their contemporary interpretation. At the first time, the research offers an intonation-dramaturgical analysis of the Sonatas and justifies their contemporary performance interpretations, focusing on the formation of a “performers’ dialogue” as an essential aspect of ensemble interaction. The study uses the first complete recordings of the works by Roberto Prosseda and Alessandra Ammara (Decca, 2015) as practical material. A multidisciplinary approach integrates the following methods: genre analysis to identify typological features of early two-piano sonatas; stylistic analysis to trace compositional individuality and the interplay of Classical and Romantic elements; structural-functional analysis to examine form, polyphony, and ensemble interaction; performance analysis to evaluate technical and ensemble demands; comparative-interpretative analysis to comparre modern performances with historical and theoretical models. Research results. The D Major Sonata MWV S 1 exemplifies classical clarity, transparent texture, and gallant dance-inspired thematicism, while revealing the individual traits of Mendelssohn’s style: polyphonic density, dialogic interplay, and symphonic thinking. The G Minor Sonata MWV S 2 presents a more dramatic single-movement sonata form, combining classical formal logic with romantic imagery contrasts and symphonized textures. Contemporary interpretations of the Sonatas by Prosseda and Ammara demonstrate the concert-level potential of these works, highlighting equality of ensemble parts, structural coherence, and dramaturgical logic without excessive romanticization, while underscoring stylistic differences between the two sonatas. Conclusion. These early sonatas are not mere student exercises but the works that evidence Mendelssohn’s early composer maturity and his contribution to the development of the two-piano sonata genre. Engagement with these works illuminates the historical transition from amateur to professional performance practice within this unique genre.
Zitieren
APA
Martianova, A. (2025). F. Mendelssohn’s Sonatas for Two Pianos: formation of the genre, and performers’ dialogue. Problems of Interaction Between Arts, Pedagogy and the Theory and Practice of Education, 77(77), 61-77. https://doi.org/10.34064/khnum1-77.04
Vancouver
Martianova A. F. Mendelssohn’s Sonatas for Two Pianos: formation of the genre, and performers’ dialogue. Problems of Interaction Between Arts, Pedagogy and the Theory and Practice of Education. 2025;77(77):61-77. doi:10.34064/khnum1-77.04
BibTeX
@article{Martianova2025,
author = {Martianova, Alina},
title = {F. Mendelssohn’s Sonatas for Two Pianos: formation of the genre, and performers’ dialogue},
journal = {Problems of Interaction Between Arts, Pedagogy and the Theory and Practice of Education},
year = {2025},
volume = {77},
number = {77},
pages = {61--77},
doi = {10.34064/khnum1-77.04}
}
EUVIMED