When most patients do well: the case for the patient acceptable symptom state alongside mean differences in surgical patient-reported outcomes
Journal of Abdominal Wall Surgery · 12.11.2026 · 5
DOI: 10.3389/jaws.2026.17292 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Abdominal Wall Surgery, online erschienen am 12.11.2026. Verfasst von Jacob Rosenberg und 3 weiteren Autor:innen. Die Arbeit nennt 10 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) in benign procedures such as hernia repair are logical and important [1]. However, interpreting the clinical relevance of PROM scores remains a major methodological challenge, and there is no universally accepted approach to determining when differences in PROM scores are clinically meaningful [2]. Registry infrastructure now enables us to report PROM scores for cohorts of thousands of patients using digital infrastructure for data collection [3]. While this provides considerable statistical power, the choice of reporting strategy can markedly influence the interpretation of the results. In large samples, even a small between-group difference in mean PROM scores may reach statistical significance despite limited clinical relevance. This problem is particularly evident when most patients report perfect outcomes with the highest possible PROM scores, while a smaller group experiences persistent symptoms of varying severity. In this situation, the mean score is dominated by the large group with excellent outcomes, so clinically meaningful differences among patients with ongoing symptoms translate into only marginal changes in the overall average. The result is a pronounced ceiling effect, where mean differences are difficult to interpret despite statistical significance. In this common situation, we argue that the Patient Acceptable Symptom State (PASS) is a more interpretable and useful outcome than the difference in means, and we illustrate the point with adjusted data from a large linked survey and registry study of incisional hernia repair.Rather than focusing on small differences in mean PROM scores, PASS focuses on the number of patients who have reached an outcome they consider acceptable. Originally introduced in rheumatology [4,5] and now widely used in orthopedic surgery [6], the concept defines the PROM threshold above which patients consider their state satisfactory: the level at which a patient would say, "I feel well enough." It reframes the analysis from "how many points apart are the groups?" to "what proportion of patients are in an acceptable state?" The summary statistic becomes the proportion achieving PASS, and the between-group contrast becomes a difference in proportions: figures that any clinician, patient, or policymaker can grasp at once. Importantly, the threshold is anchored to patients' own judgment rather than to an arbitrary statistical cut.The difference between the two approaches can be illustrated using adjusted data from patients undergoing incisional hernia repair (unpublished data from the AFTERHERNIA Project [7]). We compared patients with small hernia defects (0-2 cm) with those with larger defects (6-10 cm). We used the Abdominal Hernia-Q (AHQ) [8] as a PROM. Two AHQbased outcomes were examined: the AHQ sum score (16-64 points) and the AHQ physical impact score (6-24 points). The AHQ physical impact score reflects the physical impact subscale within the overall AHQ sum score. Higher scores indicate better outcomes for both measures. For this illustrative example, patients scoring below the 75th percentile of the respective AHQ score distributions were classified as not achieving PASS, corresponding to an AHQ sum score
Zitieren
APA
Rosenberg, J., Reistrup, H., Gram-Hanssen, A., & Baker, J. J. (2026). When most patients do well: the case for the patient acceptable symptom state alongside mean differences in surgical patient-reported outcomes. Journal of Abdominal Wall Surgery, 5. https://doi.org/10.3389/jaws.2026.17292
Vancouver
Rosenberg J, Reistrup H, Gram-Hanssen A, Baker JJ. When most patients do well: the case for the patient acceptable symptom state alongside mean differences in surgical patient-reported outcomes. Journal of Abdominal Wall Surgery. 2026;5. doi:10.3389/jaws.2026.17292
BibTeX
@article{Rosenberg2026,
author = {Rosenberg, Jacob and Reistrup, Hugin and Gram-Hanssen, Anders and Baker, Jason Joe},
title = {When most patients do well: the case for the patient acceptable symptom state alongside mean differences in surgical patient-reported outcomes},
journal = {Journal of Abdominal Wall Surgery},
year = {2026},
volume = {5},
doi = {10.3389/jaws.2026.17292}
}
EUVIMED