EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Open Access · CC BY 4.0

Robotic Assisted Hernia Repair in Four Nordic Countries - Status and Challenges

Frederik Helgstrand, Göran Rietz, Björn Törnqvist, Jan Roland Lambrecht, Robin Gaupset, Tero Rautio, Jaana Vironen

Journal of Abdominal Wall Surgery · 27.06.2024 · 3

DOI: 10.3389/jaws.2024.13224 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Abdominal Wall Surgery, online erschienen am 27.06.2024. Verfasst von Frederik Helgstrand und 6 weiteren Autor:innen. Beteiligte Einrichtung: Zealand University Hospital, Køge, Denmark. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 7-mal zitiert (Crossref) und nennt 18 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).

AbstractSchlagwörterBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Hernias are prevalent medical condi$ons affec$ng millions of individuals globally. The life$me risk for men to undergo an inguinal hernia repair is 27%, while for women it is 3% (1). One out of ten pa$ents will develop an incisional hernia afer previous surgery, 1 out of 20 persons have an umbilical hernia and up to 50% of all pa$ents with a stoma will develop a parastomal hernia. Consequently, hernia repairs are among the most commonly performed surgical procedures worldwide and even minor improvements can significantly impact healthcare (2). Tradi$onally, hernia repair surgery has been conducted using open or laparoscopic techniques. However, recent registry and single centres studies showed that robo$cally assisted hernia repair has emerged as a promising alterna$ve, providing benefits such as improved precision, reduced invasiveness, and beier outcomes in terms of less pain, less wound complica$ons and shorter length of stay (3)(4)(5). Therefore, the integra$on of robo$c hernia surgery presents a significant opportunity to improve surgical prac$ce and pa$ent experience. Regardless of how promising the tools are, ac$ve surveillance is necessary, and the already established hernia registers such as the Danish and Swedish hernia registers provide the fundament to do so.In the Nordic countries, the adop$on of robo$c hernia surgery is increasing, albeit more slowly compared to other na$ons. Several challenges persist in the implementa$on of robo$cally assisted hernia repair procedures (6).To address these challenges a self-organized group of hernia experts from four Nordic countries decided to convene and discuss the future of robo$c hernia surgery from a clinical perspec$ve. The aim of the mee$ngs was to review the current literature and discuss the poten$al benefits, challenges, and considera$ons associated with the adop$on of robo$c hernia surgery in their countries.Methods: This paper was developed through three in-person round table discussions, each las$ng 2-3 hours. Various aspects of robo$c hernia surgery were discussed, and the literature was reviewed to validate the statements. The group included dedicated hernia surgeons from Denmark, Finland, Norway, and Sweden that all co-authored this paper. All surgeons had more than 15 year's experience with hernia surgery and 2-7 year's experience in robo$c hernia surgery. All surgeons use a Da Vinci system from Intui$ve in daily prac$ce.Present status of robo0c hernia surgery in Denmark, Finland, Norway, and Sweden Currently robo$cally assisted hernia surgery cons$tutes less than 5% of all hernia repairs in the Nordic countries. However, the number of procedures increases as addi$onal robo$c plalorms are installed. More than 120 plalorms are currently in place in the Nordic countries. In Denmark nearly all public hospitals now have at least one robo$c plalorm, although none are dedicated solely to hernias. In contrast, other Nordic countries have uneven distribu$on of these plalorms. Helsinki University Hospital uniquely has a robo$c system en$rely dedicated to hernia surgery, which has significantly transformed their prac$ce. Early unpublished data from the centre shows that since the robo$c program´s incep$on two years ago the rate of minimally invasive major ventral hernia surgery increased from 25% to 75%. Their data supports that all pa$ents undergoing laparoscopic hernia repairs and over 50 % of those undergoing open hernia repairs could benefit from robo$cally assisted hernia repair techniques. Hence, there is a great poten$al for progress.Minimal Invasiveness: Similar to conven$onal laparoscopic hernia surgery, robo$c systems facilitate small incisions, resul$ng in less $ssue trauma and reduced risk of complica$ons such as infec$on and pain.The Robo$c plalorms provide surgeons with greater precision and dexterity compared to tradi$onal laparoscopic techniques. This allows more accurate dissec$on and suturing,which is par$cularly advantageous in complex hernia repairs. Moreover, the free angula$on of the instruments and ability to operate minimally invasively in confined anatomical spaces, enable mesh placement outside the abdominal cavity to avoid adhesions and making it feasible to treat pa$ents with very complex hernias that previously required extensive open surgery.Improved Pa$ent Outcomes: Although some studies show no significant differences, data from the Nordic countries indicate that robo$cally assisted hernia surgery for ventral hernia reduces postopera$ve pain, shortens hospital stay, and accelerates recovery $me and ul$mately improves pa$ent sa$sfac$on and quality of life compared to open and laparoscopic approaches; (3,5,(7)(8)(9)(10)(11). Robo$c inguinal hernia repair outcomes are excellent and comparable with the tradi$onal laparoscopic methods (12,13).Surgeon Ergonomics: This ofen-overlooked issue is vital as re$rement age for surgeons rises. Robo$c surgery offers improved visualiza$on, beier ergonomics and instrument control, robo$c surgery reducing surgeon fa$gue and musculoskeletal strain, thereby enhancing the overall surgical performance (14,15).Training and Educa$on: Integra$ng robo$c technology into hernia surgery provides op$mal training opportuni$es for the next genera$on of surgeons. Robo$c plalorms elevate surgical simula$ons, facilitate on-site supervision, and offer objec$ve evalua$on of a surgeon's development. Op$ons like instant video assessment, remote guidance and re-evalua$on support con$nuous improvement in advanced surgical procedures. Future plalorms are likely to integrate ar$ficial intelligence and enhanced imaging, futher suppor$ng surgical decision making and facilitate more precise and safer surgeries (16).Cost:The ini$al investment and ongoing maintenance costs associated with robo$c systems are substan$al, raising concerns about cost-effec$veness and resource alloca$on within healthcare systems. Typically, the focus is on the direct costs to hospitals rather than the total treatment cost.In Nordic countries, the reimbursement systems incen$vize day-care surgeries, shorter hospital stays, and beier outcomes. This encourages standardiza$on, enhanced recovery protocols, minimally invasive treatments, and improved outcomes. Introducing robo$c systems has the poten$al for even beier results, but requires upfront investments at the start of the pa$ent pathways to realize benefits in subsequent stages, including faster returns to work.These investments are usually covered by the hospitals and the departments execu$ng the surgeries within their semi-fixed budget. Although there may be a poten$al overall economic gain over $me, theini$al costs and prevailing silo mentality ofen dominate decision-making.Nordic healthcare systems are known for their innova$on and pa$ent-focused care, financed by taxes and managed by poli$cians. While here is a awareness of value for money, decisions are also influenced by public opinions and lobbying from pa$ent organiza$ons (17). High volume condi$ons like hernias do not have strong pa$ent organiza$on representa$on, despite significantly impac$ng health and quality of life. Small improvements in the treatment of hernia pa$ents could greatly benefit healthcare and societal finances. Instead, investments in new healthcare technologies are typically directed towards treatments that garner poli$cal aien$on. Moreover, the mul$ple stakeholders, each with their own independent budget, make it difficult to determine the total cost of pa$ent therapy. This complexity inhibits investments that only benefit other stakeholders. Ofen, pre-and post-surgery sick leave and recovery are not considered, even though they are crucial cost drivers. In many other surgical procedures such as treatment for colo-rectal cancer, robo$c plalorms have replaced conven$onal laparoscopic techniques with limited evidence of improved pa$ent outcomes (18). In hernia surgery, robo$c plalorms empower surgeons to transform open surgery to minimally invasive surgery and therefore have a huge poten$al of both economically and pa$ent benefits. With many robo$c systems already in place in Nordic countries and more on the way, poten$al economic savings could easily be capitalized, especially with high u$liza$on and targeted use.Training and accredita$on: Robo$cally assisted surgery requires specialized training for surgeons and opera$ng room staff to ensure safe and effec$ve use. Establishing standardized training programs and creden$aling processes is essen$al for maintaining high-quality care and pa$ent safety, but also to exploit the tool's poten$al. The author group predicts that robo$c plalorms will replace tradi$onal laparoscopic and many open surgical procedures for the next genera$on of surgeons. Therefore, robo$c training programs should already be established for trainees, and it is assumed that such programs will be an essen$al recruitment criteria in the future.Collabora$on between academic ins$tu$ons, professional socie$es, and industry partners is crucial for developing comprehensive training programs for surgeons and surgical teams, ensuring proficiency in robo$c-assisted techniques and adherence to best prac$ces.Ensuring equitable access to robo$c hernia surgery across the Nordic countries and include remote and underserved regions, is vital to avoid exacerba$ng dispari$es in healthcare delivery and outcomes.Meetings where surgeons from di1erent countries to discussed and debated the current opportunities and obstacles were an e1ective method to get an understanding of the present state of robotic hernia surgery in four countries with similar healthcare systems. The Surgeons all agreed that robo$c hernia surgery holds promise for improving pa$ent care and that the Nordic countries have poten$al to lead its development. However, limita$ons and hurdles need addressing. Con$nued investment in clinical research and pa$ent quality of care improvement ini$a$ves are necessary to generate robust evidence on the safety, efficacy, and cost benefits of robo$c hernia surgery to guide clinical decision-making and healthcare policy development. The already exis$ng na$onal registers could become key in providing essen$al data. Furthermore, clear regulatory guidelines and reimbursement policies are needed to govern the use of robo$c technology in hernia surgery. Issues such as pa$ent eligibility criteria, procedural volume requirements, and reimbursement rates must be addressed to ensure sustainable adop$on and equitable access. Un$l recently only one robo$c company were available. Fortunately, several other companies are now entering the market and hopefully more will come, to ensure more compe$$on, more development, lower costs for consumers and more benefits for the pa$ents. Based on the current literature and experience, the group is convinced that robo$c plalorms will supplement conven$onal laparoscopy and improve surgery in the future. For safe and sustainable adop$on of robo$c hernia surgery, the healthcare ins$tu$ons and policymakers are encouraged to priori$ze investment in robo$c surgical infrastructure, including acquisi$on of robo$c systems, training facili$es and ongoing technical support. Collabora$on and knowledge exchange between healthcare professionals, industry stakeholders, and pa$ent advocacy groups can foster innova$on, promote best prac$ces, and address shared challenges.We believe integra$ng robo$cally assisted hernia surgery will improve pa$ent experience and quality of surgical care. However, achieving these benefits requires addressing challenges related to cost, training, access, regula$on, and long-term evalua$on. Through innova$on and collabora$on, priori$zing pa$ent-centred care and developing exis$ng na$onal hernia registries, the Nordic countries can posi$on themselves at the forefront of robo$c hernia surgery, benefi$ng both pa$ents and healthcare systems.

Schlagwörter

Stichwörter der Autor:innen

Nordicherniaoutcomeroboticstatement

Autor:innen und Institutionen

  • Zealand University Hospital, Køge, Denmark.
  • Stockholm South General Hospital, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden.
  • Danderyds Hospital, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden.
  • Sykehuset Innlandet Hospital Trust, Hamar, Norway.
  • Akershus University Hospital, Nordbyhagen, Norway.
  • Oulu University Hospital, Oulu Medical Research Center, Oulu, Finland.

Zitieren

APA

Helgstrand, F., Rietz, G., Törnqvist, B., Lambrecht, J. R., Gaupset, R., Rautio, T., & Vironen, J. (2024). Robotic Assisted Hernia Repair in Four Nordic Countries - Status and Challenges. Journal of Abdominal Wall Surgery, 3. https://doi.org/10.3389/jaws.2024.13224

Vancouver

Helgstrand F, Rietz G, Törnqvist B, Lambrecht JR, Gaupset R, Rautio T, et al. Robotic Assisted Hernia Repair in Four Nordic Countries - Status and Challenges. Journal of Abdominal Wall Surgery. 2024;3. doi:10.3389/jaws.2024.13224

BibTeX
@article{Helgstrand2024,
  author = {Helgstrand, Frederik and Rietz, Göran and Törnqvist, Björn and Lambrecht, Jan Roland and Gaupset, Robin and Rautio, Tero and Vironen, Jaana},
  title = {Robotic Assisted Hernia Repair in Four Nordic Countries - Status and Challenges},
  journal = {Journal of Abdominal Wall Surgery},
  year = {2024},
  volume = {3},
  doi = {10.3389/jaws.2024.13224}
}
Kostenlos starten →