EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Open Access · CC BY 4.0

Rethinking sustainable urban planning in the Global South: six paradigm shifts for the next decade

Abdulaziz I. Almulhim

Frontiers in Sustainable Cities · 30.10.2026 · 8

DOI: 10.3389/frsc.2026.2014131 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Frontiers in Sustainable Cities, online erschienen am 30.10.2026. Verfasst von Abdulaziz I. Almulhim. Die Arbeit nennt 59 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Cities across the Global South are entering a decisive decade for sustainable development.Rapid urbanization and intensifying climate change are placing growing pressure on urban sustainability, increasing environmental risks while challenging cities' social, economic, and infrastructural systems (Almulhim & Cobbinah, 2026;UN-Habitat, 2024). These pressures are unfolding alongside widening socio-spatial inequalities, infrastructure and resource constraints, and profound technological and economic change, with climate impacts often falling disproportionately on vulnerable and marginalized urban populations (UN-Habitat, 2024).Climate-induced migration adds another layer of complexity, as environmental stress can accelerate rural-to-urban mobility, placing additional pressure on infrastructure, services, and informal and peri-urban development in receiving cities (Almulhim et al., 2024). These pressures do not occur independently. They interact within increasingly complex urban systems, where decisions about land use, housing, mobility, infrastructure, ecosystems, and public services can generate consequences far beyond the sectors in which they originate. The significance of these interactions also extends beyond city boundaries, as urban growth increasingly shapes land cover, hydrological systems, climate, biogeochemical processes, and habitats at broader scales (Espey et al., 2024).Although the term Global South encompasses highly diverse urban contexts and should not imply a single development trajectory, the nature and intensity of urban challenges vary considerably across regions, from rapid urban expansion and informality to housing pressures, climate vulnerability, displacement, and resource scarcity (United Nations, 2026). Nevertheless, many cities across Africa, Asia, Latin America, and the Middle East face a common challenge: the pace and complexity of urban change increasingly exceed the capacity of conventional planning institutions and instruments to respond effectively. This mismatch between inherited planning approaches and contemporary urban realities has long been recognized, particularly in relation to informality, inequality, rapid urbanization, and the assumptions underpinning planning theory and practice (Watson, 2009). A decade of expanded urban policy commitments has not resolved this challenge. The United Nations (2026), in its assessment of progress in implementing the New Urban Agenda, reports that implementation continues to lag behind the growing scale and complexity of urban challenges. A recent study further shows that sustainable development outcomes remain highly uneven across space and that socioeconomic progress can coexist with environmental deterioration, reinforcing the need for planning approaches that address trade-offs across multiple dimensions of urban sustainability (Guo et al., 2026).The challenge, however, is not a lack of ideas. Sustainable urban planning now draws on a rapidly expanding repertoire of approaches, including resilience planning, nature-based solutions, participatory governance, smart-city technologies, integrated infrastructure, and data-driven decision-making. Yet the translation of these approaches into sustained urban transformation remains uneven. Climate adaptation, for example, depends on institutional capacity, meaningful participation, and the ability to address the needs of poor and vulnerable communities (Chu et al., 2016). Similarly, recent research on nature-based solutions highlights governance, financial feasibility, social acceptance, and context-specific approaches as critical conditions for effective urban planning and implementation (Mirsafa et al., 2025). Informality further complicates this transition because formal and informal institutions, economic activities, and socio-ecological processes are deeply interdependent rather than functioning as separate urban systems (Eakin et al., 2025).The central question for the coming decade is therefore no longer simply what cities should do to become more sustainable, but how planning itself must change to enable sustainable urban transitions under conditions of complexity, uncertainty, informality, and inequality. This Grand Challenge argues that incremental improvements to conventional planning will not be sufficient.It identifies six interrelated paradigm shifts: from sectoral planning to systems thinking; from static plans to adaptive and resilient planning; from formal planning to inclusive urbanism; from growthcentered planning to well-being and equity; from engineering-dominated solutions to ecological urbanism; and, ultimately, from planning as control to planning as continuous learning.Conventional urban planning has played an essential role in organizing land use, guiding infrastructure investment, regulating development, and articulating long-term visions for cities.The challenge is therefore not that conventional planning has become irrelevant, but that many of its underlying assumptions are increasingly insufficient for the conditions under which cities in the Global South are evolving. Planning instruments have often been built around expectations of relatively predictable urban growth, effective formal institutions, clearly defined administrative responsibilities, reliable data, and development that can be managed through formal regulatory systems. In many rapidly urbanizing contexts, however, urban change unfolds through a more complex combination of formal and informal processes, uneven institutional capacity, infrastructure deficits, resource constraints, and increasingly uncertain climatic and socioeconomic conditions. This mismatch is increasingly visible at the implementation level. The United Nations (2026), in its assessment of progress in implementing the New Urban Agenda, reports that despite the wider adoption of national urban and housing policies, implementation has not kept pace with the growing scale and complexity of urban challenges. Persistent gaps between national policy frameworks and municipal planning instruments, limited local capacity, fragmented institutional mandates, weak monitoring systems, and inadequate financing continue to constrain implementation. These broader constraints are also evident in rapidly urbanizing Saudi cities, where population growth, environmental pressures, implementation limitations, and mismatches between national priorities and local urban conditions have challenged planning practice (Almulhim & Cobbinah, 2024). These conditions reinforce the need for context-sensitive planning approaches in the Global South, particularly given the limitations of uncritically transferring planning knowledge and models developed in substantially different socioeconomic and institutional contexts (Verdini et al., 2025).A second limitation lies in the fragmented treatment of problems that are systemically interconnected. Land-use decisions influence mobility and infrastructure demand; housing conditions shape exposure to climate hazards; water, energy, ecosystems, and public health interact across administrative and sectoral boundaries. Yet institutions responsible for these systems often operate through separate mandates, budgets, datasets, and planning cycles. The United Nations (2026) similarly identifies fragmented institutional mandates and weak coordination across levels of government as persistent barriers to translating urban policy into spatially coordinated investment and implementation. Evidence from urban climate governance illustrates how fragmented institutional arrangements can constrain integrated responses even where climate risks are recognized (Pazhuhan, 2023). Similar problems appear in adaptation finance: analysis of projects in the Global South found limited attention to uncertainty and relatively weak mechanisms for generating transformative effects across sectors (Forino et al., 2022).Climate change further exposes the limits of planning based predominantly on stable baselines and anticipated trajectories. Increasing climatic variability, compound risks, migration, economic disruption, and rapid technological change make urban futures progressively harder to predict. This does not eliminate the need for long-term plans; rather, it changes what long-term planning must be capable of doing. Earlier work on cities in the Global South already argued that climate adaptation requires governance approaches able to connect different spatial and temporal scales, accommodate multiple forms of knowledge, and integrate formal and informal responses (Birkmann et al., 2010). More recent research similarly emphasizes that adaptive governance must be interpreted through the particular institutional and social conditions of the Global South rather than transferred uncritically from elsewhere (Yasmin et al., 2019). These limitations should therefore not be understood as isolated failures of individual plans or institutions. Collectively, they point to a deeper mismatch between a planning paradigm designed largely around sectoral organization, predictability, formality, and control, and urban realities increasingly characterized by interdependence, uncertainty, informality, and rapid change.The task ahead is not to abandon established planning instruments, but to reposition them within a broader paradigm capable of integrating systems, adapting to uncertainty, recognizing diverse forms of urbanism and knowledge, prioritizing equity and ecological processes, and learning continuously from implementation. Figure 1 conceptualizes this transition through six interrelated paradigm shifts that, taken together, provide a framework for rethinking sustainable urban planning in the Global South. Six paradigm shifts for rethinking sustainable urban planning in the Global South. The framework does not imply the wholesale replacement of conventional planning approaches. Rather, it represents a reorientation of planning toward more systemic, adaptive, inclusive, equitable, ecological, and learning-based approaches capable of responding to increasingly complex and uncertain urban conditions.The limitations outlined above suggest that the challenge is not simply to improve individual planning instruments, but to reconsider some of the principles through which urban planning understands and responds to change. The six shifts presented below are neither mutually exclusive nor intended as universal prescriptions for the highly diverse cities of the Global South. Rather, they identify complementary directions through which planning can become more capable of engaging with interdependence, uncertainty, informality, inequality, ecological limits, and institutional change. Their value lies not in replacing established planning practices wholesale, but in expanding the ways in which urban problems are framed, decisions are made, and implementation is evaluated. Overall, the six shifts provide an integrated, Global South-focused perspective for framing the interconnected challenges that sustainable urban planning must address over the next decade and for linking these challenges to the research priorities outlined in Section 4.Urban sustainability is inherently multidimensional and multiscalar, meaning that interventions that generate benefits in one dimension or at one spatial scale may produce different outcomes or trade-offs in others (Seto et al., 2017). Urban sustainability challenges rarely conform to the administrative and sectoral boundaries through which cities are planned. Decisions about land use influence mobility, infrastructure demand, housing, ecological conditions, and exposure to environmental risks, while water, energy, transport, and other infrastructure systems depend on one another. Sustainable urban systems are therefore increasingly understood through the interactions among social actors, institutions, ecological processes, and interconnected infrastructures rather than through individual sectors alone (Ramaswami et al., 2012). A housing decision, for example, may alter travel demand, energy consumption, emissions, environmental exposure, and ultimately patterns of inequality. This need for integration is also reflected in the United Nations (2026) assessment of the New Urban Agenda, which emphasizes more coordinated approaches across the social, economic, and environmental dimensions of sustainable urban development.A systems perspective requires planning to focus on the relationships, dependencies, trade-offs, and feedbacks between these domains. The planning unit should therefore increasingly become the urban system rather than the individual sector. Concepts such as urban metabolism, infrastructure interdependencies, cross-sector dependencies, and water-energy-land relationships can help reveal how interventions in one domain generate consequences elsewhere and support more integrated decision-making (Kennedy et al., 2012).Yet systems thinking should not become synonymous with increasingly complex modeling. In many Global South cities, incomplete data, fragmented institutional responsibilities, and limited technical capacity may constrain highly data-intensive approaches. More importantly, models alone cannot resolve competing interests, unequal power, or questions about who benefits from particular planning choices. The Grand Challenge is therefore to translate systems thinking from a compelling conceptual ideal into actionable planning practice under real institutional, data, and resource constraints. Research must determine which interdependencies matter most for planning decisions, how cross-sector trade-offs can be assessed transparently, and how integrated approaches can remain practicable where data and governance capacity are uneven.Long-term urban planning has traditionally depended on the ability to anticipate future population, land-use, infrastructure, and development needs with reasonable confidence. Yet the conditions shaping urban futures are becoming increasingly uncertain. Climate extremes, migration, resource scarcity, demographic change, economic shocks, and geopolitical disruptions can alter development trajectories in ways that fixed plans cannot fully anticipate. Evidence from Dhaka, for example, demonstrates how uncertainties associated with both climate change and urbanisation can push existing strategies beyond their effective limits, reinforcing the need to move from predictive planning toward approaches based on continuous monitoring and adaptation (Ahmed et al., 2018).Adaptive and resilient planning therefore requires a shift from treating planning and implementation as a largely linear process toward an iterative approach in which anticipation, implementation, monitoring, evaluation, and adjustment are continuously connected. This shift is consistent with resilience-oriented planning, which conceptualizes urban planning not as a static process but as one that must respond to the dynamic and non-equilibrium nature of urban systems (Sharifi & Yamagata, 2018). Scenario planning, adaptive pathways, risk-informed decisionmaking, periodic reassessment, and resilience thinking can enable cities to prepare for multiple plausible futures rather than relying on a single expected trajectory. This does not imply abandoning long-term planning. Rather, long-term sustainability objectives should provide strategic direction while allowing the pathways toward those objectives to evolve as risks, knowledge, technologies, and urban conditions change. Experience from Quito, Surat, and Durban further indicates that sustained political leadership, institutional coordination, stakeholder involvement, learning, and capacity building are important for embedding adaptation within urban governance rather than treating it as a one-off planning exercise (Anguelovski et al., 2014).The Grand Challenge is therefore to institutionalize adaptive planning without allowing flexibility to become short-termism or reactive decision-making. Research should examine how monitoring thresholds, periodic review mechanisms, and adaptive pathways can be embedded within statutory planning systems while preserving accountability, institutional continuity, and long-term sustainability objectives.In many cities across the Global South, the lived city extends far beyond the city represented in statutory plans and formal regulatory systems. The scale of this challenge is substantial: more than 1.1 billion people worldwide were living in slums or informal settlements in 2022, an increase of over 120 million since 2016 (United Nations, 2026). Informal settlements, informal economies, peri-urban development, community networks, and locally organized forms of service provision are therefore not peripheral exceptions but integral components of how urbanization occurs and how cities function. Research across African cities similarly shows that formal planning often struggles to accommodate informal, temporary, and citizen-led urban processes, despite the important role these practices play in shaping urban space and responding to unmet needs. Rather than treating such practices simply as deviations from formal planning, more inclusive approaches can recognize citizens as active place-makers and better integrate appropriate informal and adaptable forms of urban development into planning processes (Andres et al., 2021). This direction is also reflected in the United Nations (2026) assessment of the New Urban Agenda, which calls for integrated and place-based approaches to informal settlements that combine adequate housing with climate resilience, public health, safety, and livelihoods while avoiding forced evictions.Yet planning systems can marginalize these realities when informality is treated primarily as a regulatory deficit to be eliminated rather than as a complex urban condition that must be understood and engaged. Importantly, informality should not be equated exclusively with poverty or marginality, as it may also be produced through entrepreneurship, wealth, power, and the actions of actors operating across formal and informal institutional boundaries (Swapan et al., 2020).Research on community-based flood adaptation in informal settlements across the Global South shows that local knowledge, grassroots organization, participatory governance, and locally appropriate innovations can support adaptation, while limited funding, weak governance, and legal exclusion constrain their wider and longer-term impact (Bhanye, 2025a). Evidence from diverse Global South contexts further demonstrates the importance of locally grounded knowledge, community networks, and participatory approaches in enabling adaptation, while highlighting institutional, financial, and governance constraints on community responses (Adelina et al., 2020).More broadly, community-based adaptation scholarship emphasizes context-specific knowledge, inclusive decision-making, local ownership, and attention to power relations, while also underscoring the need to connect locally led initiatives with wider governance structures (Selje et al., 2024).Inclusive urbanism therefore requires more than extending formal planning procedures into informal areas. It requires planning to recognize residents and community organizations as producers of urban knowledge and active participants in shaping urban development. Evidence from Nairobi illustrates how co-production of infrastructure and public services can create spaces for more inclusive governance when communities and state actors engage in sustained deliberation (Otsuki, 2016). However, participation alone is insufficient: evidence from informal settlements in Accra shows that having a voice in participatory processes does not necessarily translate into substantive influence over decisions (Bandauko et al., 2025).The Grand Challenge is therefore not simply how to formalize informal urban systems, but how planning can recognize, engage with, and improve them witho

Zitieren

APA

Almulhim, A. I. (2026). Rethinking sustainable urban planning in the Global South: six paradigm shifts for the next decade. Frontiers in Sustainable Cities, 8. https://doi.org/10.3389/frsc.2026.2014131

Vancouver

Almulhim AI. Rethinking sustainable urban planning in the Global South: six paradigm shifts for the next decade. Frontiers in Sustainable Cities. 2026;8. doi:10.3389/frsc.2026.2014131

BibTeX
@article{Almulhim2026,
  author = {Almulhim, Abdulaziz I.},
  title = {Rethinking sustainable urban planning in the Global South: six paradigm shifts for the next decade},
  journal = {Frontiers in Sustainable Cities},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {8},
  doi = {10.3389/frsc.2026.2014131}
}
Kostenlos starten →