Editorial: Personality functioning impairment: early signs, risk factors and assessment from childhood to young adulthood
Frontiers in Psychiatry · 02.11.2026 · 17
DOI: 10.3389/fpsyt.2026.2014906 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Frontiers in Psychiatry, online erschienen am 02.11.2026. Verfasst von Marc Birkhölzer und 5 weiteren Autor:innen. Die Arbeit nennt 4 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The Alternative Model for Personality Disorders (AMPD) in the fifth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5) and the eleventh revision of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-11) have moved the diagnosis of personality disorder away from categorical types and toward a single severity continuum of impairment in self (identity, self-direction) and interpersonal (empathy, intimacy) functioning (1,2). For young people this shift matters a great deal. Because personality functioning (PF) does not presuppose fixed maladaptive traits, it can be assessed while personality is still consolidating, allowing subthreshold impairment in PF to be identified at a stage when intervention may be most effective (3). Building on our previous Research Topic on the dimensional assessment of personality disorders in young people (4), this collection asked how PF first becomes visible, which factors place children and adolescents at risk, and how PF can be assessed in a developmentally and culturally appropriate way from childhood into young adulthood. The seven contributions, drawing on samples from Lithuania, the United States, Slovenia and Türkiye and on the global literature, address each of these questions.Two contributions examine how PF emerges and unfolds early in adolescence. Gaudiešiūtė et al. (5) investigated whether adolescents follow distinct trajectories of personality functioning over time and which baseline characteristics distinguish these patterns. Following 855 Lithuanian community adolescents aged 11-18 across three annual waves, the authors assessed Criterion A domains using the Levels of Personality Functioning Questionnaire for adolescents aged 12-18 (LoPF-Q 12-18). At baseline, they also measured internalizing and externalizing problems via the Youth Self-Report (YSR), alongside peer victimization and self-harm.Latent class growth analysis identified four trajectories: an adaptive and declining course (21.5%), a normative and stable course (49.2%), a slightly impaired but stable course (25.5%) and a significantly impaired, stable course (3.7%). The last group scored at or above the 97.7th percentile of Lithuanian norms, a proportion that closely matches prevalence estimates of personality disorder in the general population. Neither PF group improved over the two years. Compared with the normative course, membership in the slightly impaired trajectory was predicted by baseline affective, anxiety and attention-deficit/hyperactivity problems, younger age and female sex. In contrast, only affective problems distinguished the significantly impaired trajectory; self-harm, oppositional and conduct problems as well as victimization provided no additional predictive value once internalizing problems were controlled for. The authors reach three main conclusions. First, established risk factors for categorically defined personality disorder apply equally to dimensionally assessed personality functioning. Second, a stable, identifiable minority of community adolescents carries persistent impairment in PF Finally, adolescent mood and personality pathology should be assessed and treated as an integrated system rather than as isolated problems.Boone et al. (6) moved further down the age range and asked how parent and child reports of personality functioning relate to each other in pre-and early adolescence, and whether their agreement or disagreement carries clinical meaning. In 432 children aged 10-15 from three samples oversampled for psychopathology, both children and parents completed the Level of Personality Functioning Scale -Brief Form 2.0 (LPFS-BF 2.0); outcomes were parent-reported caregiver strain, parent-reported child functional impairment and child-reported lifetime suicidal and non-suicidal self-injury (NSSI) related thoughts and behaviors. Parent and child reports were only modestly correlated (r = .27). Latent profile analysis yielded two convergent profiles (both low, both high) and two divergent profiles (parent high/child low, child high/parent low). Convergence on strong impairment in PF carried the strongest associations across all outcomes, including more suicidal ideation, suicide plans and attempts, and NSSI. Each divergent profile, in turn, predicted the outcomes reported by the informant who had endorsed stronger impairment in PF: the parent-high profile was associated with caregiver strain and functional impairment to the same extent as the convergent-high profile, whereas the child-high profile was associated with more NSSI. The authors conclude that parent and child reports of personality functioning each carry unique information and that, rather than discounting a discrepant report, clinicians should treat the pattern of parent-child discrepancy as clinically informative and integrate both perspectives into assessment and feedback.Three contributions turn to the correlates and antecedents of impairment in PF. Adler et al. (7) asked whether impairment in PF marks a distinct high-risk subgroup among depressed adolescents. In 73 clinically referred adolescents aged 12-17 with a depression diagnosis or clinically significant depressive symptoms, personality functioning (LoPF-Q 12-18), childhood maltreatment (Childhood Experiences Questionnaire, CEQ), psychopathology (YSR), mentalizing (Reflective Function Questionnaire for Youth, RFQY-8), borderline features (Borderline Personality Features Scale for Children, BPFSC-11), self-harm and suicidal ideation were assessed. Using the LoPF-Q 12-18 clinical threshold (T ≥ 65), 72.6% of the sample showed clinically significant impairment in PF. Compared with adolescents with depression alone, this subgroup showed large deficits in all four domains, most pronounced for identity and self-direction, more borderline features, greater uncertainty about mental states (hypomentalizing), higher internalizing, externalizing, affective, anxiety, conduct and posttraumatic stress symptoms, an earlier onset and higher frequency of self-harm, more self-harm with the wish to die and more frequent suicidal ideation. Among the maltreatment types, emotional neglect most clearly distinguished the two groups, whereas total maltreatment did not differ. The authors conclude that impairment in PF is the rule rather than the exception in clinically referred depressed adolescents. Moreover, they suggest that depression in this population often expresses an underlying structural vulnerability of the self. Emotional neglect was identified as a potential developmental pathway to this vulnerability. Consequently, authors suggest that personality functioning should be assessed routinely in adolescents with clinically significant depressive symptoms to identify a subgroup at high risk for self-harm and suicide.Gregorec et al. (8) asked how PF relates to normative personality traits, on the premise that maladaptive traits are extreme variants of normal ones and may therefore serve as early indicators of personality pathology. In 61 Slovenian adolescents aged 12-19 in inpatient or outpatient psychiatric care, personality functioning (LoPF-Q 12-18) was related to the Inventory of Child Individual Differences (ICID), which assesses 15 lower-order traits organized into neuroticism, extraversion, disagreeableness and conscientiousness. Stronger impairment in PF correlated with higher neuroticism and lower conscientiousness and extraversion; in multiple regression, neuroticism and conscientiousness independently predicted impairment in PF and together explained 41% of its variance. At the domain level, identity and self-direction were most closely linked to emotional instability and low selfregulation, impairments in empathy to antagonism and disagreeableness, and impairments in intimacy to low sociability and positive emotions. Neither impairment in PF nor traits predicted membership in broad categorical diagnostic groups (internalizing versus comorbid/personality pathology). The authors conclude that two developmental mechanisms, emotional vulnerability and reduced self-regulation, underlie impairment in PF in adolescence, that trait profiles can point to emerging impairment in PF before diagnostic clarity is reached, and that categorical diagnoses map poorly onto the underlying dimensional processes, supporting the integration of trait and functioning assessment in clinical evaluation.Taking a bird's-eye view, Jin et al. ( 9) asked how research on adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) and personality disorders has developed as a field. They analyzed 5,084 Englishlanguage publications indexed in Web of Science, Scopus and PubMed up to the end of 2025. Output has grown steadily, with a marked increase after 2000; the United States, United Kingdom, Germany, Canada, the Netherlands and Australia dominate publication and collaboration networks, and borderline personality disorder, childhood abuse, depression and post-traumatic stress disorder form the core knowledge base. Keyword and co-citation analyses show a thematic shift from documenting exposure-outcome associations toward emotion dysregulation, NSSI, social support, neurobiological mechanisms and early intervention. The authors conclude that the field is moving from association to mechanism and clinical translation and call for longitudinal and cross-cultural designs that consider the type, timing, duration and severity of adversity and integrate neurobiological and clinical-course phenotypes, a call echoed in the empirical papers of this collection.Two contributions address assessment itself. Cosgun et al. (10) asked whether the adult version of the LoPF-Q, whose adolescent version has been validated in Turkish samples, is reliable and valid in Turkish adults and structurally comparable to the adolescent form. In 283 community adults and 65 clinical participants, of whom 34 had a personality disorder diagnosis according to the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM Personality Disorders (SCID-II), the LoPF-Q Adult showed excellent internal consistency (α = .96) and strong convergent correlations with psychological distress on the Brief Symptom Inventory (BSI; r = .76 for the total score). Bifactor modeling revealed a dominant general severity factor accounting for 76% of the common variance, with only small domain-specific variance, mirroring the structure reported for the LoPF-Q 12-18. Scores rose in a clear gradient from community adults to nonpersonality-disorder patients to patients with personality disorder (d = 1.56 versus community), and receiver operating characteristic analysis yielded an area under the curve of .85. The authors conclude that the LoPF-Q Adult captures the core severity dimension of Criterion A and is best interpreted with a severity-first, total-score approach, and that the structural similarity between adolescent and adult versions supports cross-age compatibility and thus the possibility of tracking personality functioning from adolescence into adulthood on a single metric, while stressing that developmental continuity itself remains to be demonstrated through longitudinal and measurement-invariance studies.Močnik and Gregorič Kumperščak (11) look ahead. Their mini review asks why adolescent borderline personality disorder remains underdetected despite validated instruments and what a more dynamic assessment might look like. They identify the overlap between normative adolescent development and early borderline pathology, clinician reluctance to diagnose before age 18, high comorbidity and gender-specific presentations as central diagnostic challenges. Established instruments such as the LoPF-Q 12-18, the Assessment of Identity Development in Adolescence (AIDA) and the Childhood Interview for Borderline Personality Disorder (CI-BPD) provide valuable severity anchors, but as static and retrospective measures they cannot capture the rapid, context-dependent fluctuations in affect, self-experience and relationships that characterize the disorder. The authors therefore propose a conceptual four-level hybrid pathway in which established clinical assessment and level-of-personality-functioning anchors are complemented by ecological momentary assessment, candidate digital biomarkers from smartphones and wearables (speech, activity, sleep, physiological arousal) and artificial intelligence (AI)-supported synthesis, with a clinician-led formulation remaining the final output. They conclude that digital and AI-based methods should be seen as adjuncts rather than diagnostic tools, that they require validation of feasibility, validity and acceptability in adolescents, and that privacy, consent, fairness and developmental appropriateness must be addressed from the outset.Several messages emerge. Impairment in PF is identifiable, and in a minority of adolescents stable, from early adolescence onward; clinicians should not wait for the age of 18 to assess it. Impairment in PF is deeply intertwined with internalizing psychopathology, which underscores its clinical relevance but also revives the question of the discriminant validity of self-report measures of Criterion A; multi-method and multi-informant designs, as modelled by Boone et al., will be essential to disentangle structural impairment in PF from state distress. The severity dimension proves psychometrically robust across languages, ages and settings, whereas categorical diagnostic groupings are not well predicted by it, adding to the case for dimensional classification in youth. Finally, the samples assembled here are predominantly female, crosssectional and self-report based, and childhood is still under-represented. Longitudinal studies that begin before adolescence, include boys and non-Western populations, formally test measurement invariance across age and culture, and link early impairment in PF to intervention outcomes are the obvious next steps. We thank the authors and reviewers for advancing this agenda and hope the collection encourages routine, developmentally informed assessment of PF in young people.
Zitieren
APA
Birkhölzer, M., Eikenæs, I. U., Boonmann, C., Schmeck, K., Skabeikytė-Norkienė, G., & Sharp, C. (2026). Editorial: Personality functioning impairment: early signs, risk factors and assessment from childhood to young adulthood. Frontiers in Psychiatry, 17. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2026.2014906
Vancouver
Birkhölzer M, Eikenæs IU, Boonmann C, Schmeck K, Skabeikytė-Norkienė G, Sharp C. Editorial: Personality functioning impairment: early signs, risk factors and assessment from childhood to young adulthood. Frontiers in Psychiatry. 2026;17. doi:10.3389/fpsyt.2026.2014906
BibTeX
@article{Birkhlzer2026,
author = {Birkhölzer, Marc and Eikenæs, Ingeborg Ulltveit-Moe and Boonmann, Cyril and Schmeck, Klaus and Skabeikytė-Norkienė, Gabrielė and Sharp, Carla},
title = {Editorial: Personality functioning impairment: early signs, risk factors and assessment from childhood to young adulthood},
journal = {Frontiers in Psychiatry},
year = {2026},
volume = {17},
doi = {10.3389/fpsyt.2026.2014906}
}
EUVIMED