Correction: Implementation process of community-based lifestyle interventions supported by technology for elderly population: qualitative evaluation of six European regions case studies
Frontiers in Digital Health · 16.11.2026 · 8
DOI: 10.3389/fdgth.2026.1993340 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Frontiers in Digital Health, online erschienen am 16.11.2026. Verfasst von Irati Erreguerena und 19 weiteren Autor:innen. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0). Gefördert von: Horizon 2020.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Community-based interventions represent a strategic approach to integrating the salutogenic model, involving multi-sectoral stakeholders to improve the health of specific communities. In the context of the EU's ageing population, eHealth technologies provide valuable solutions by improving older individuals' health and well-being through better access to knowledge, strengthening environmental relationships, and supporting the sustainability of health systems. This manuscript explores a community-based health promotion intervention focused on eHealth apps tested across six European regions within the GATEKEEPER project.qualitative evaluation of case studies in six European regions case studies. IntroductionThe population aged 65 and over has increased in recent years, being expected to comprise 22% of the world's population by 2030 [1]. In this scenario, the target life expectancy is 3.3 years longer for women than for men [2] in similar socio-economic conditions; however, women endure a greater burden of illness and discomfort [3]. There are many complex factors [4] that constitute and influence ageing and can be categorised in two: factors related to the physiological risk of developing a disease and losing physical function; and psychosocial alteration determinants such as isolation, loneliness, depression, or lack of income [5][6][7] , . While healthcare systems are facing the challenges brought by this new paradigm of demographic change, this situation can also be seized as an opportunity to change the way care is delivered, facilitating services or deploying new resources for encouraging and improving elderly health treatment behaviours.In this sense, social determinants [8][9] can have a direct influence on health-related habits among this population [10]. An example can be how the activity levels drop significantly when people retire: the promotion of active and healthy assets and the early detection of risk factors for functional decline is essential [11]. Therefore, developing health promotion strategies [12], strengthening community-based interventions [13], and mobilising community health assets [14] to reinforce and adapt elderly people behaviours to healthier ones may be key especially when they still have a high and relatively stable functional capacity [15]. The salutogenic approach [16][17] , which integrates health into all policies, and boosts health promotion actions and programmes, can be an appropriate model to be implemented in communities by considering people's health, well-being, and quality of life as a human right [18].Community-based interventions constitute a strategy for integrating the salutogenic approach, by deploying actions where multi-sectorial stakeholders are involved [19] to improve the health status of a community or a group [20] in a specific area or setting [21].Furthermore, the main objective of community action is the "construction of citizenship", strengthening their engagement to a community, or bolstering the empowerment, understood as the responsibility process of individual and collective people [22]. The action focused on the community seeks to mobilise existing health assets [23] and include some main elements [24]: (1) enhance communities: building community capacity to act together on health and the social determinants of health; (2) volunteer and peer-to-peer roles focused on enhancing the capacities of organisations and individuals; (3) foster collaborations and partnerships for the involvement of key stakeholder, and (4) give access to community resources: connecting people to resources for practical help, group activities and volunteer opportunities to meet health needs and increase social participation.Health technologies can be effective instruments to address the challenge of ageing [25][26] and to boost the community interventions for promoting health through the use of community health assets and/or resources [27][28]. Similarly, they allow progress to be made towards promoting the health of older people and tackling well-being outcomes, hence prevent, treat [29] and ensure the sustainability of health systems [30]. In this sense, eHealth Apps offer the possibility of personalizing, tailoring and adapting behaviour change interventions based on real time user and environmental data to improve health outcomes [31]. Therefore, these Apps become a potential tool to support health promotion, disease prevention and management of different pathologies and revolutionising the way that health professionals and researchers monitor, manage and promote population health [32].As such, interest in mobile health apps is also driven by the possibility of replicating resource-intensive, face-to-face interventions for health promotion and management.However, despite the availability of many mobile health apps (71,000 new health apps were launched in 2020 [33]), the level of adoption by end users is generally low and not sustained over time (55% of apps get less than 5,000 downloads per year and 62% of developers report digital solutions with less than 1,000 monthly active users [34]). Additionally, in many eHealth studies, particularly those conducted on the Internet and especially with self-help applications, high dropout rates may be a natural and typical feature [35]. Usage metrics and determinants of dropout should be highlighted, measured, analysed, and discussed. This also includes analysing and reporting on the characteristics of the population for whom the app ultimately "works", i.e. those who remain in the trial and use it.Despite the increasing development of community-based and digitally supported interventions aimed at promoting healthy ageing, existing evidence has largely focused on their effectiveness under specific conditions, with less attention paid to how these interventions are implemented across different real-world settings. Studies on mobile health and community-centred approaches highlight important variability in design, user engagement, and contextual adaptation, which can significantly influence outcomes [36][37]. In addition, high attrition rates and low sustained use of digital health solutions further underline the importance of better understanding implementation processes and user interaction in practice [38]. However, there is still a lack of shared methodological frameworks to systematically evaluate the implementation, scalability, and transferability of community-based, technology-supported interventions across regions and populations [39]. Addressing this gap is essential to identify key factors that influence successful deployment and long-term sustainability in diverse European contexts.In this context the European Horizon 2020 project GATEKEEPER (Smart living homes -Whole interventions demonstrator for people at health and social risks) is a European multi-centric large-scale pilot on smart living environments [40] with the aim of tackling the improvement of the quality of life of citizens through advance Information and Communications Technologies (ICT). This manuscript describes a mixed-methods process evaluation of a community-based health promotion intervention deployed in six European regions within the GATEKEEPER project, focused on testing innovative eHealth Apps. The aim of this study was to evaluate the implementation of the intervention across settings and to identify the main facilitators, barriers, and contextual factors influencing its delivery.A longitudinal observational qualitative study was carried out in six different regions (Basque Country and Aragon from Spain, Saxony from Germany, Puglia from Italy, Lodz from Poland, and Central Greece and Attica from Greece) between 2021 and beginning of the 2024, in the framework or GATEKEEPER project [41], to evaluate the implementation process of the community-based lifestyle intervention, and the user experience regarding the technologies offered. Data analysis adheres to the Consolidated Criteria for Qualitative Research (Supplementary material 1. COREQ checklist).In the six implementation sites, there were implemented a community-based intervention based on self-managed digital health applications. The deployed interventions, the addressed target populations, and the digital solutions tested in the six implementation sites are described in Supplementary material 2 & Table 1. By combining personalized content, unobtrusive monitoring, and coaching or guidance, they aimed to enhance independence, improve quality of life, and encourage active, and healthy ageing through digital, preventive, and user-centered strategies.In each site, an ecosystem composed of health care and community-based organisations, partners from industry, civil society, academia, and government authorities was built. Users were considered as participants if they met the inclusion criteria that were citizen over 50 years old, healthy or at risk of chronic diseases or mental impairment, and having agreed to take part in the intervention after being invited by the recruiters. Gender was not defined as an inclusion criterion, as these community-based interventions were designed to be inclusive and to reflect the diversity of the general population. In all cases, recruitment followed a multi-channel approach by coordinating the use of several communication and delivery pathways to engage participants and Different qualitative techniques were implemented to gather stakeholders' perception on the intervention, usability, accessibility and satisfaction, as well as the usefulness and acceptance of the tools. Determinants that influence the commitment with and the adherence to the intervention in the different settings were explored as well. The activities were carried out by a researcher's team with qualitative techniques experience composed by PhD and senior researcher, female, and a BD junior researcher, female. This team was in charge to take field notes from all the activities carried out.The activities conducted were:(1) Collective sense-making workshops [42] to identify barriers, strengths, key insights for improvement and sustainability of the use cases and share user experiences and ideas of new actions and activities to encourage users' engagement.(2) Participatory approach co-creation workshops [43] among intervention implementers and project managers to analyse the implementation methodologies, process, share baseline and intermediate results from each use case, Knowledge and experience exchange, and discuss activities conducted for plans redefinition. Moderated by one or more members of the large-scale pilot coordination team from Gatekeeper EU project , they took place in a hybrid environment having some participant's in-presence and others remotely.(3) Collaborative diagnostic sessions [44] for each region pilot to share and report the status of the interventions through the implementation log and issue tracker tool such as PowerBI [46]platform designed for this purpose and Warwick Analytics which pilots' managers completed to report key issues, propose mitigation actions, identify responsible partners, and schedule contingency plans.(4) Monitoring sessions for reporting Operative Key Performance Indicators (KPI) [45] through an ad-hoc Business Intelligence tool (i.e., Power BI) and Warwick Analytics, focused on enabling the measurement of the implementation and performance of the pilot, identify areas for improvement and facilitate the decision-making process. KPIs, Supplementary material 3, were reported on monthly basis by pilots for assessing each pilot progress and identify needs and challenges to be addressed, users recruited, stakeholder engagement level, user registered on the tools, baseline questionnaire completed and others.A summary of these KPIs by pilot site is provided in Table 2. However, these indicators reflect implementation processes (e.g., recruitment, engagement, and monitoring) and are not directly comparable with the qualitative findings presented, which capture stakeholders' perceptions of usability, engagement, and contextual barriers.In total, three collective sense-making workshops, one co-creation workshops, four collaborative diagnostic sessions and 10 monitoring meetings were conducted with the six pilot sites between March 2023 and February 2024. For each activity, structured documentation was produced, including meeting minutes, field notes, implementation reports and summaries of issues and decisions recorded in the Power BI and Warwick Analytics dashboards, which constituted the qualitative material used for thematic analysis.First, a descriptive analysis of each implementation site interventions was performed.The approach considered for the community-based interventions was based on an 'intention to treat' approach, thus allowing the results to be analysed considering all people included in the study, regardless of whether they complied with the intervention protocol or not. The KPIs collected by each pilot site provided an unbiased estimate of the effect of the intervention, as it included compliers, non-compliers and dropouts.The working data for the qualitative analyses consisted of: structured summaries and from the collective sense-making and co-creation workshops by the project coordination monthly implementation and issue tracker from the collaborative diagnostic sessions completed by each pilot in and used for this activity, and monitoring reports and key performance indicators and contextual notes provided monthly by each pilot in an and in PowerBI [45] were as a and analysed allowing the of from implementation decisions and performance data into a thematic this in the was to the and become with the were not to provide on the these an and thematic analysis of was carried by and The thematic analysis is described as for analysing and reporting within The through the analysis the of findings in to the Therefore, aim was to of and based on the that the participants use for of was The aim was also to the data into or were from the data by the members of the who and the to identify and issues related to implementation, user experience and contextual and data management were conducted structured in were into through team and and that each a of were the data and the for and and agreed by the The process included data and of was supported by meetings in which researchers on how their roles in the GATEKEEPER project, experience with digital health interventions and of each site the of the and these This process supported the by the influence of on the was through the researcher's the different activities and through data the pilot site data that all the documentation in the activities to the of the different data and is a of the collected different to the of different data and results of the main results from different sites and thus and and in understanding the This approach to the and of the the and contextual of each pilot site support the transferability of the The were across sites to and to increase the transferability of the the of diverse participants was in of working and intervention involvement these were followed to evaluate the of the study that all to this with the of the and on human Qualitative data that several factors the implementation and of digitally community-based interventions across pilot The qualitative findings are as across sites, as the analysis aimed to identify implementation than to and the data reflect process indicators than or effectiveness factors were into main and and engagement and contextual and performance of the use of digital solutions was with usability, including the content, and understanding how to use the applications. also reported and which in several cases and the use of an that some users not In addition, some were as each time they were issues were described as and For in the Country pilot, participants described the process as and that older users when to an reports support related to and to how sustained use among older characteristics that on the recruitment and user in co-creation workshops reported that interest if the not change or to their and several pilot reports that the of and to the the of the that were in this were the data such as that capture data or data to capture physical activity, lack of of the to the user based on the and effective or such as or direct for the the of data collected through with existing health technologies was to health professionals to provide personalized that support in users' health and In addition, of user activity and the to the promotion of engagement with these which was reported as a feature in some pilot This also the of allowing with individual user and of health or social care professionals recruitment and was an important of specific that intermediate in the community-based interventions as an important were the social and community or the communication between users and health professionals and/or citizen and community The of support and was with engagement and in a way in the interest in the digital participants who from health or social care professionals described the intervention as and monitoring notes from several pilots this support to rates of and characteristics of the population and health and low digital were to dropout or The high of the target population and the use of recruitment with among older such as social or also findings that the recruitment strategy and the digital level of the users are related to implementation For that in some cases older with on members to the applications, and some the intervention this support was longer reports also that recruitment conducted through social relatively of the among those to was also by contextual and The high among care related to or and of face-to-face group activities to the situation of the intervention delivery in several In some cases, the support to partnerships for the interventions was considered or addition, challenges were user to Data related which challenges user and in some cases and the adoption of the applications. data use for were also In several sites, stakeholders reported that potential participants not their data to be used for or and pilot managers in which to how and data directly implementation study insights into the factors that influence adherence to a digital health intervention implementation process, including interventions implemented in community settings. By the across pilot sites and contextual the study was designed to which implementation may be across settings despite in specific technologies and target populations by The findings with implementation usability, and contextual as for community such as complex and were reported across sites, that is a for adoption among older with low digital the of support the importance of hybrid that digital with human particularly for populations at risk of or functional insights provide practical for interventions that with real-world the in interventions, target populations and digital solutions across the six pilot sites, several implementation factors such as usability, availability of and with users' digital levels were reported as in all that they should be considered regardless of the specific such as care or existing community how these be in the for than a from the pilot sites the a process for intervention as is being implemented in several involvement in these interventions should on from the to ensure their needs and are and within users' and into the technologies a the digital solutions are more and which user to and in the of community-based health promotion interventions is digital, with mobile health apps as for supporting health promotion, disease and the management of health eHealth are how healthcare professionals and researchers monitor, and promote population health, with the of enhancing and However, as in the Gatekeeper community interventions, it is that these are not effective also and to a and fram
Förderung
- Horizon 2020
Zitieren
APA
Erreguerena, I., Gonzáleza, N., Larrañaga, I., Mercalli, F., Karaglani, E., Manios, Y., Androutsos, O., Schellong, J., Gand, K., Barbastro, R. A., Hurtado, M. T., Lewek, P., Przemyslaw, K., Cea, G., Gallego, A., Fico, G., Pecchia, L., Batlle, J. D., Piaggio, D., & Fullaondo, A. (2026). Correction: Implementation process of community-based lifestyle interventions supported by technology for elderly population: qualitative evaluation of six European regions case studies. Frontiers in Digital Health, 8. https://doi.org/10.3389/fdgth.2026.1993340
Vancouver
Erreguerena I, Gonzáleza N, Larrañaga I, Mercalli F, Karaglani E, Manios Y, et al. Correction: Implementation process of community-based lifestyle interventions supported by technology for elderly population: qualitative evaluation of six European regions case studies. Frontiers in Digital Health. 2026;8. doi:10.3389/fdgth.2026.1993340
BibTeX
@article{Erreguerena2026,
author = {Erreguerena, Irati and Gonzáleza, Nerea and Larrañaga, Igor and Mercalli, Franco and Karaglani, Eva and Manios, Yannis and Androutsos, Odysseas and Schellong, Julia and Gand, Kai and Barbastro, Rosana Angles and Hurtado, Maria Teresa and Lewek, Pawel and Przemyslaw, Kardas and Cea, Gloria and Gallego, Alba and Fico, Giuseppe and Pecchia, Leandro and Batlle, Jordi de and Piaggio, Davide and Fullaondo, Ane},
title = {Correction: Implementation process of community-based lifestyle interventions supported by technology for elderly population: qualitative evaluation of six European regions case studies},
journal = {Frontiers in Digital Health},
year = {2026},
volume = {8},
doi = {10.3389/fdgth.2026.1993340}
}
EUVIMED