EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Multizentrische StudieRandomisierte kontrollierte StudiePragmatische StudieOpen Access · CC BY 4.0

Comparison of surgical or non-surgical management for non-acute anterior cruciate ligament injury: the ACL SNNAP RCT

David J Beard iD, Loretta Davies iD, Jonathan A Cook iD, Jamie Stokes iD, Jose Leal iD, Heidi Fletcher iD, Simon Abram iD, Katie Chegwin iD, Akiko Greshon iD, William Jackson iD, Nicholas Bottomley iD, Matthew Dodd iD und 17 weitere

Health Technology Assessment · 2024

DOI: 10.3310/vdkb6009 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Multizentrische Studie in der Zeitschrift Health Technology Assessment, 2024. Verfasst von David J Beard und 28 weiteren Autor:innen. Beteiligte Einrichtung: Nuffield Department of Orthopaedics, Rheumatology and Musculoskeletal Sciences, Botnar Research Centre, University of Oxford, Headington, Oxford, UK. Hauptthemen laut MEDLINE: Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injuries, Cost-Benefit Analysis, Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 9-mal zitiert (Crossref) und nennt 65 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0). Gefördert von: Health Technology Assessment programme.

AbstractSchlagwörterBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Background

Anterior cruciate ligament injury of the knee is common and leads to decreased activity and risk of secondary osteoarthritis of the knee. Management of patients with a non-acute anterior cruciate ligament injury can be non-surgical (rehabilitation) or surgical (reconstruction). However, insufficient evidence exists to guide treatment. Objective(s) To determine in patients with non-acute anterior cruciate ligament injury and symptoms of instability whether a strategy of surgical management (reconstruction) without prior rehabilitation was more clinically and cost-effective than non-surgical management (rehabilitation).

Design

A pragmatic, multicentre, superiority, randomised controlled trial with two-arm parallel groups and 1:1 allocation. Due to the nature of the interventions, no blinding could be carried out.

Setting

Twenty-nine NHS orthopaedic units in the United Kingdom.

Participants

Participants with a symptomatic (instability) non-acute anterior cruciate ligament-injured knee.

Interventions

Patients in the surgical management arm underwent surgical anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction as soon as possible and without any further rehabilitation. Patients in the rehabilitation arm attended physiotherapy sessions and only were listed for reconstructive surgery on continued instability following rehabilitation. Surgery following initial rehabilitation was an expected outcome for many patients and within protocol. Main outcome measures The primary outcome was the Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score 4 at 18 months post randomisation. Secondary outcomes included return to sport/activity, intervention-related complications, patient satisfaction, expectations of activity, generic health quality of life, knee-specific quality of life and resource usage.

Results

Three hundred and sixteen participants were recruited between February 2017 and April 2020 with 156 randomised to surgical management and 160 to rehabilitation. Forty-one per cent ( n = 65) of those allocated to rehabilitation underwent subsequent reconstruction within 18 months with 38% ( n = 61) completing rehabilitation and not undergoing surgery. Seventy-two per cent ( n = 113) of those allocated to surgery underwent reconstruction within 18 months. Follow-up at the primary outcome time point was 78% ( n = 248; surgical, n = 128; rehabilitation, n = 120). Both groups improved over time. Adjusted mean Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score 4 scores at 18 months had increased to 73.0 in the surgical arm and to 64.6 in the rehabilitation arm. The adjusted mean difference was 7.9 (95% confidence interval 2.5 to 13.2; p = 0.005) in favour of surgical management. The per-protocol analyses supported the intention-to-treat results, with all treatment effects favouring surgical management at a level reaching statistical significance. There was a significant difference in Tegner Activity Score at 18 months. Sixty-eight per cent ( n = 65) of surgery patients did not reach their expected activity level compared to 73% ( n = 63) in the rehabilitation arm. There were no differences between groups in surgical complications ( n = 1 surgery, n = 2 rehab) or clinical events ( n = 11 surgery, n = 12 rehab). Of surgery patients, 82.9% were satisfied compared to 68.1% of rehabilitation patients. Health economic analysis found that surgical management led to improved health-related quality of life compared to non-surgical management (0.052 quality-adjusted life-years, p = 0.177), but with higher NHS healthcare costs (£1107, p < 0.001). The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio for the surgical management programme versus rehabilitation was £19,346 per quality-adjusted life-year gained. Using £20,000–30,000 per quality-adjusted life-year thresholds, surgical management is cost-effective in the UK setting with a probability of being the most cost-effective option at 51% and 72%, respectively.

Limitations

Not all surgical patients underwent reconstruction, but this did not affect trial interpretation. The adherence to physiotherapy was patchy, but the trial was designed as pragmatic.

Conclusions

Surgical management (reconstruction) for non-acute anterior cruciate ligament-injured patients was superior to non-surgical management (rehabilitation). Although physiotherapy can still provide benefit, later-presenting non-acute anterior cruciate ligament-injured patients benefit more from surgical reconstruction without delaying for a prior period of rehabilitation. Future work Confirmatory studies and those to explore the influence of fidelity and compliance will be useful.

Trial registration

This trial is registered as Current Controlled Trials ISRCTN10110685; ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT02980367. Funding This award was funded by the National Institute of Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health Technology Assessment programme (NIHR award ref: 14/140/63) and is published in full in Health Technology Assessment ; Vol. 28, No. 27. See the NIHR Funding and Awards website for further award information.

Schlagwörter

MeSH-Schlagwörter (MEDLINE)

Anterior Cruciate Ligament InjuriesCost-Benefit AnalysisAnterior Cruciate Ligament ReconstructionHumansMaleFemaleAdultUnited KingdomQuality of LifeQuality-Adjusted Life YearsMiddle AgedYoung AdultState MedicineJoint InstabilityAdolescentTechnology Assessment, Biomedical

Stichwörter der Autor:innen

ANTERIOR CRUCIATE LIGAMENTANTERIOR CRUCIATE LIGAMENT INJURIESANTERIOR CRUCIATE LIGAMENT RECONSTRUCTIONKNEE INJURIESORTHOPAEDICSQUALITY OF LIFERANDOMISED CONTROLLED TRIALREHABILITATION

Autor:innen und Institutionen

  • Nuffield Department of Orthopaedics, Rheumatology and Musculoskeletal Sciences, Botnar Research Centre, University of Oxford, Headington, Oxford, UK.
  • Nuffield Department of Population Health, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.
  • Nuffield Orthopaedic Centre, Oxford University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Oxford, UK.
  • Swansea Bay University Health Board, Swansea, UK.
  • Heatherwood and Wexham Park Hospitals, Frimley Health NHS Foundation Trust, Slough, UK.
  • College of Medicine and Health, University of Exeter, Exeter, UK.

ORCID-Profile: David J Beard, Loretta Davies, Jonathan A Cook, Jamie Stokes, Jose Leal, Heidi Fletcher, Simon Abram, Katie Chegwin, Akiko Greshon, William Jackson, Nicholas Bottomley, Matthew Dodd, Henry Bourke, Beverly A Shirkey, Arsenio Paez, Sarah E Lamb, Karen L Barker, Michael Phillips, Mark Brown, Vanessa Lythe, Burhan Mirza, Andrew Carr, Paul Monk, Carlos Morgado Areia, Sean O'Leary, Fares Haddad, Chris Wilson, Andrew Price

Förderung

  • Health Technology Assessment programme

Zitieren

APA

Beard, D. J., Davies, L., Cook, J. A., Stokes, J., Leal, J., Fletcher, H., Abram, S., Chegwin, K., Greshon, A., Jackson, W., Bottomley, N., Dodd, M., Bourke, H., Shirkey, B. A., Paez, A., Lamb, S. E., Barker, K. L., Phillips, M., Brown, M., …, & ACL SNNAP Study Group (2024). Comparison of surgical or non-surgical management for non-acute anterior cruciate ligament injury: the ACL SNNAP RCT. Health Technology Assessment. https://doi.org/10.3310/vdkb6009

Vancouver

Beard DJ, Davies L, Cook JA, Stokes J, Leal J, Fletcher H, et al. Comparison of surgical or non-surgical management for non-acute anterior cruciate ligament injury: the ACL SNNAP RCT. Health Technology Assessment. 2024. doi:10.3310/vdkb6009

BibTeX
@article{Beard2024,
  author = {Beard, David J and Davies, Loretta and Cook, Jonathan A and Stokes, Jamie and Leal, Jose and Fletcher, Heidi and Abram, Simon and Chegwin, Katie and Greshon, Akiko and Jackson, William and Bottomley, Nicholas and Dodd, Matthew and Bourke, Henry and Shirkey, Beverly A and Paez, Arsenio and Lamb, Sarah E and Barker, Karen L and Phillips, Michael and Brown, Mark and Lythe, Vanessa and Mirza, Burhan and Carr, Andrew and Monk, Paul and Areia, Carlos Morgado and O'Leary, Sean and Haddad, Fares and Wilson, Chris and Price, Andrew and ACL SNNAP Study Group, ACL SNNAP Study Group},
  title = {Comparison of surgical or non-surgical management for non-acute anterior cruciate ligament injury: the ACL SNNAP RCT},
  journal = {Health Technology Assessment},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3310/vdkb6009}
}
Kostenlos starten →