EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Mixed-Methods-Studie

Shared decision-making during childbirth in maternity units: the VIP mixed-methods study

Ellen Annandale, Helen Baston, Siân Beynon-Jones, Lyn Brierley-Jones, Alison Brodrick, Paul Chappell, Josephine Green, Clare Jackson, Victoria Land, Tomasina Stacey

Health and Social Care Delivery Research · 2022

DOI: 10.3310/fpfp4621 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Mixed-Methods-Studie in der Zeitschrift Health and Social Care Delivery Research, 2022. Verfasst von Ellen Annandale und 9 weiteren Autor:innen. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 12-mal zitiert (Crossref) und nennt 303 Literaturangaben. Gefördert von: Health and Social Care Delivery Research (HSDR) Programme.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Background

NHS policy emphasises shared decision-making during labour and birth. There is, however, limited evidence concerning how decision-making happens in real time.

Objectives

Our objectives were as follows – create a data set of video- and audio-recordings of labour and birth in midwife-led units; use conversation analysis to explore how talk is used in shared decision-making; assess whether or not women’s antenatal expectations are reflected in experiences and whether or not the interactional strategies used (particularly the extent to which decisions are shared) are associated with women’s postnatal satisfaction; and disseminate findings to health-care practitioners and service users to inform policy on communication in clinical practice.

Design

This was a mixed-methods study. The principal method was conversation analysis to explore the fine detail of interaction during decision-making. Derived from the conversation analysis, a coding frame was developed to quantify interactions, which were explored alongside questionnaire data concerning women’s antenatal expectations and preferences, and women’s experiences of, and postnatal satisfaction with, decision-making. Semistructured interviews with health-care practitioners explored factors shaping decision-making. Setting and participants The study took place in midwife-led units at two English NHS trusts. A total of 154 women (aged ≥ 16 years with low-risk pregnancies), 158 birth partners and 121 health-care practitioners consented to be recorded. Of these participants, 37 women, 43 birth partners and 74 health-care practitioners were recorded. Key findings Midwives initiate the majority of decisions in formats that do not invite women’s participation (i.e. beyond consenting). The extent of optionality that midwives provide varies with the decision. Women have most involvement in decisions pertaining to pain relief and the third stage of labour. High levels of satisfaction are reported. There is no statistically significant relationship between midwives’ use of different formats of decision-making and any measures of satisfaction. However, women’s initiation of decisions, particularly relating to pain relief (e.g. making lots of requests), is associated with lower satisfaction.

Limitations

Our data set is explored with a focus on decision initiation and responses, leaving other important aspects of care (e.g. midwives’ and birth partners’ interactional techniques to facilitate working with pain) underexplored, which might be implicated in decision-making. Despite efforts to recruit a diverse sample, ethnic minority women are under-represented.

Conclusions

Policy initiatives emphasising patient involvement in decision-making are challenging to enact in practice. Our findings illustrate that women are afforded limited optionality in decision-making, and that midwives orient to guidelines/standard clinical practice in pursuing particular decisional outcomes. Nonetheless, the majority of women were satisfied with their experiences. However, when women needed to pursue decisions, particularly concerning pain relief, satisfaction is lower. Conversation analysis demonstrates that such ‘women-initiated’ decision-making occurs in the context of midwives’ avoiding pharmacological methods of pain relief at particular stages of labour. Future research We suggest that future research address the following – the barriers to inclusion of ethnic minority research participants, decision-making in obstetric units, systematic understanding of how pain relief decisions are pursued/resolved, conversation analysis of interactional elements beyond the specific decision-making context, interactional ‘markers’ of the emotional labour and inclusion of antenatal encounters.

Trial registration

This trial is registered as ISRCTN16227678 and National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) CRN Portfolio (CMPS):32505 and IRAS:211358. Funding This project was funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health and Social Care Delivery Research programme and will be published in full in Health and Social Care Delivery Research ; Vol. 10, No. 36. See the NIHR Journals Library website for further project information.

Förderung

  • Health and Social Care Delivery Research (HSDR) Programme

Zitieren

APA

Annandale, E., Baston, H., Beynon-Jones, S., Brierley-Jones, L., Brodrick, A., Chappell, P., Green, J., Jackson, C., Land, V., & Stacey, T. (2022). Shared decision-making during childbirth in maternity units: the VIP mixed-methods study. Health and Social Care Delivery Research. https://doi.org/10.3310/fpfp4621

Vancouver

Annandale E, Baston H, Beynon-Jones S, Brierley-Jones L, Brodrick A, Chappell P, et al. Shared decision-making during childbirth in maternity units: the VIP mixed-methods study. Health and Social Care Delivery Research. 2022. doi:10.3310/fpfp4621

BibTeX
@article{Annandale2022,
  author = {Annandale, Ellen and Baston, Helen and Beynon-Jones, Siân and Brierley-Jones, Lyn and Brodrick, Alison and Chappell, Paul and Green, Josephine and Jackson, Clare and Land, Victoria and Stacey, Tomasina},
  title = {Shared decision-making during childbirth in maternity units: the VIP mixed-methods study},
  journal = {Health and Social Care Delivery Research},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3310/fpfp4621}
}
Kostenlos starten →