PROBLEMS OF EXERCISING THE RIGHT TO FREELY CHOOSE A DEFENSE PROCEDURE IN CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS IN UKRAINE
Law & Border · 30.05.2026 · 7 (1) · 216-276
DOI: 10.32453/law_border.v7i1.2193 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Law & Border, online erschienen am 30.05.2026. Verfasst von Bohdan ROMANIUK und 1 weiteren Autor:innen. Die Arbeit nennt 107 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The article highlights the transformation of the justice system in Ukraine and the adaptation of national legislation to the standards of the European Union, thereby emphasizing the need for a critical reconsideration of the institution of judicial representation. The legislative consolidation of the exclusive right of advocates to provide legal assistance in courts (the so-called “advocates’ monopoly”) declared the objective of improving the quality of the protection of citizens’ rights. At the same time, the current realities of the development of the legal system, intensified by the challenges of the legal regime of martial law, financial and economic instability, and the significant reduction in the human resources potential of the legal community, demonstrate the existence of profound systemic deformations and institutional barriers that contradict the original European principles of deregulation of the legal services market. The article provides a comprehensive theoretical and legal analysis of the destructive consequences of the monopolisation of judicial representation in Ukraine, examines its impact on the accessibility and quality of legal assistance for socially vulnerable groups, and substantiates scientific recommendations regarding the necessity of decentralisation and demonopolisation of this sphere of legal activity. The article proves that the level of professional competence of a representative does not imperatively depend on the possession of an advocate’s certificate, while the preventive function of qualification examinations is often neutralised by latent corporate risks. It is established that the introduction of monopolistic principles has resulted in excessive financial and administrative pressure exerted by the bodies of адвокатське самоврядування, transforming an independent self-governing institution into a vertically integrated structure displaying features of a disciplinary “super-monopoly.” Based on an analysis of the dynamics of property thresholds and indicators of free secondary legal aid, the article substantiates that the current mechanism restricts the constitutional right of an individual to freely choose a defence counsel, artificially creating a protectionist environment and narrowing citizens’ access to justice. The article proposes ways of legislative improvement of this criminal procedural institution through the restoration of free market competition.
Zitieren
APA
ROMANIUK, B., & RYABY, S. (2026). PROBLEMS OF EXERCISING THE RIGHT TO FREELY CHOOSE A DEFENSE PROCEDURE IN CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS IN UKRAINE. Law & Border, 7(1), 216-276. https://doi.org/10.32453/law_border.v7i1.2193
Vancouver
ROMANIUK B, RYABY S. PROBLEMS OF EXERCISING THE RIGHT TO FREELY CHOOSE A DEFENSE PROCEDURE IN CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS IN UKRAINE. Law & Border. 2026;7(1):216-276. doi:10.32453/law_border.v7i1.2193
BibTeX
@article{ROMANIUK2026,
author = {ROMANIUK, Bohdan and RYABY, Serhii},
title = {PROBLEMS OF EXERCISING THE RIGHT TO FREELY CHOOSE A DEFENSE PROCEDURE IN CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS IN UKRAINE},
journal = {Law & Border},
year = {2026},
volume = {7},
number = {1},
pages = {216--276},
doi = {10.32453/law_border.v7i1.2193}
}
EUVIMED