ANGLO-IRISH RELATIONS FROM THE TWELFTH TO THE FIRST HALF OF THE SEVENTEENTH CENTURY IN THE SCHOLARSHIP OF HEORHIY AFANASIEV (1848–1925)
Наукові зошити історичного факультету Львівського університету / Proceedings of History Faculty of Lviv University · 10.11.2025 · (26) · 245-252
DOI: 10.30970/fhi.2025.26.4983 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Наукові зошити історичного факультету Львівського університету / Proceedings of History Faculty of Lviv University, online erschienen am 10.11.2025. Verfasst von Sergey LYMAN.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The article examines the study of the complex set of Anglo-Irish relations by the renowned scholar, publicist, politician, diplomat, and future Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Ukrainian State, Heorhiy Afanasyev (1848–1925). Although Afanasyev is known in historiography primarily as a specialist on the history of France during the L`Ancien Régime, he successfully offered a comprehensive account of the causes, stages, and consequences of the English conquest of Ireland. The main argument of the article is that H. Afanasyev was the first in Ukrainian historiography to address Ireland’s past and the nature of Anglo-Irish relations in the Middle Ages and the Early Modern period, formulating conclusions that remain relevant today. His assessments are reflected in the collection of public lectures The Fate of Ireland (1887–1888) and in the general work History of Ireland (1907). The purpose of this article is to examine Afanasyev’s publications devoted to Anglo-Irish relations from the twelfth century to the first half of the seventeenth century and to investigate how his conclusions align with the perspectives of modern researchers on this topic. The methods used to achieve this research objective include historical and comparative analysis, systematization and generalization, and the retrospective method. According to Afanasyev, successive English conquests of Ireland beginning in 1169 had significant political, linguistic, religious, and economic consequences for the local population, while also influencing international relations in Western Europe. In analyzing the national and political contradictions between the two sides in this centuries-long conflict, Afanasyev not only provided examples of armed clashes and efforts at forcible colonization by the English, but also highlighted the complex problem of assimilation and cultural interaction between the two peoples. He supported his thesis—that the Irish prior to the Anglo-Norman conquest, and in the first centuries following it, stood at a higher level of cultural development than the English—by citing evidence of the English conquerors borrowing Irish customs. As a representative of the positivist school of historiosophy, Afanasyev defended the thesis of the multifactorial nature of historical processes and argued, with good reason, that the “Irish question” was a complex phenomenon encompassing economic, national, political, religious, and other interrelated dimensions. The main conclusions of Afanasyev have been confirmed by British and Irish historians to this day. The analysis presented in this article, together with the study of both the positive and negative experiences of these bilateral relations, will be valuable for the development of effective strategies of international interaction for other states, including Ukraine. Keywords: Heorhiy Afanasyev, Ireland, England, international relations, conquest, colonization, Middle Ages.
Zitieren
APA
LYMAN, S. (2025). ANGLO-IRISH RELATIONS FROM THE TWELFTH TO THE FIRST HALF OF THE SEVENTEENTH CENTURY IN THE SCHOLARSHIP OF HEORHIY AFANASIEV (1848–1925). Наукові зошити історичного факультету Львівського університету / Proceedings of History Faculty of Lviv University, 245-252. https://doi.org/10.30970/fhi.2025.26.4983
Vancouver
LYMAN S. ANGLO-IRISH RELATIONS FROM THE TWELFTH TO THE FIRST HALF OF THE SEVENTEENTH CENTURY IN THE SCHOLARSHIP OF HEORHIY AFANASIEV (1848–1925). Наукові зошити історичного факультету Львівського університету / Proceedings of History Faculty of Lviv University. 2025:245-252. doi:10.30970/fhi.2025.26.4983
BibTeX
@article{LYMAN2025,
author = {LYMAN, Sergey},
title = {ANGLO-IRISH RELATIONS FROM THE TWELFTH TO THE FIRST HALF OF THE SEVENTEENTH CENTURY IN THE SCHOLARSHIP OF HEORHIY AFANASIEV (1848–1925)},
journal = {Наукові зошити історичного факультету Львівського університету / Proceedings of History Faculty of Lviv University},
year = {2025},
number = {26},
pages = {245--252},
doi = {10.30970/fhi.2025.26.4983}
}
EUVIMED