Diagnosing Response Processes in Preliminary Items for Measuring Democratic Citizenship Competency: Cognitive Interviews with Elementary, Middle, and High School Students
Korean Educational Research Association · 31.10.2026 · 64 (6) · 383-417
DOI: 10.30916/kera.64.6.383 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Korean Educational Research Association, online erschienen am 31.10.2026. Verfasst von Sungeun Bae.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This study examined how preliminary items for measuring democratic citizenship competency, developed to maintain conceptual continuity across school levels, actually functioned as response tasks for elementary, middle, and high school students. Cognitive interviews were conducted with 18 students (six per school level) on 13 item families selected through a prior quantitative item analysis, yielding 234 student–item response cases. For each item family, the response tasks required by the items and those actually constructed by students were compared in terms of the target of judgment, the response action, and the grounds of response. Three patterns emerged across the 13 item families: continuity/deepening, transition, and boundary/complexity. In continuity/deepening cases, the core target of judgment and response action remained stable while scope, abstraction, and expected performance expanded. In transition cases, the target of judgment or the required relational structure changed, or the response action itself shifted from behavioral self-report to value judgment. Boundary/complexity cases combined deepening with qualitative changes in the target or type of judgment. In addition, some quantitatively unstable items nevertheless retained stable core response tasks, indicating that quantitative anomalies and response-process problems do not correspond one-to-one. These findings suggest that conceptual continuity across school levels cannot be assumed from shared measurement concepts or goal-domain classifications alone; developers should specify the core response task to be maintained and examine empirically whether students actually perform it. Quantitative item analysis and cognitive interviewing should therefore be used as sequential and complementary sources of evidence, with implications for developing large-scale student democratic citizenship competency indicators.
Zitieren
APA
Bae, S. (2026). Diagnosing Response Processes in Preliminary Items for Measuring Democratic Citizenship Competency: Cognitive Interviews with Elementary, Middle, and High School Students. Korean Educational Research Association, 64(6), 383-417. https://doi.org/10.30916/kera.64.6.383
Vancouver
Bae S. Diagnosing Response Processes in Preliminary Items for Measuring Democratic Citizenship Competency: Cognitive Interviews with Elementary, Middle, and High School Students. Korean Educational Research Association. 2026;64(6):383-417. doi:10.30916/kera.64.6.383
BibTeX
@article{Bae2026,
author = {Bae, Sungeun},
title = {Diagnosing Response Processes in Preliminary Items for Measuring Democratic Citizenship Competency: Cognitive Interviews with Elementary, Middle, and High School Students},
journal = {Korean Educational Research Association},
year = {2026},
volume = {64},
number = {6},
pages = {383--417},
doi = {10.30916/kera.64.6.383}
}
EUVIMED