The “language of indirect coding” in the analysis of U.S. strategic documents: the limits of formalization, reproducibility, and validity
Manuscript · 10.11.2026 · 19 (5) · 2283-2292
DOI: 10.30853/mns20260283 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Manuscript, online erschienen am 10.11.2026. Verfasst von Nikolay Nikolaevich Goryachev. Die Arbeit nennt 9 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The study aims to determine the methodological limits of the “language of indirect coding” (LIC), as applied by V. E. Boldyrev to the analysis of U.S. strategic documents, and the implications of these limitations for specific conclusions. The article examines the consistency of the transitions from source selection and text segmentation to codes, quantitative indicators, historical and political interpretations, and forecasts. The scientific novelty lies in a comprehensive test of the reproducibility and validity of these transitions, a mathematical reconstruction of the system stability coefficient (SSC), and a comparison of individual LIC conclusions with the underlying data. It is demonstrated that the SSC is algebraically reducible to 100/N and therefore does not measure the adaptability of subsystems; comparisons between the administrations of B. Obama and D. Trump based on this coefficient depend on the size of the coded corpus. It is shown that coincidences in codes do not, in themselves, confirm interagency interaction, and that similarities in interpretations do not establish the optimality of political development. A comparison of the forecast of J. Biden’s policy with the original U.S. document reveals insufficient justification for treating the areas of U.S. – China cooperation listed therein as an exhaustive list and does not allow the independent predictive value of the LIC to be established. Consequently, the LIC should be regarded primarily as a system for structured annotation and hypothesis generation. The measurement, explanatory, and predictive validity of the applications under consideration requires independent confirmation, while the SSC should be excluded from the category of substantively interpretable indicators.
Zitieren
APA
Goryachev, N. N. (2026). The “language of indirect coding” in the analysis of U.S. strategic documents: the limits of formalization, reproducibility, and validity. Manuscript, 19(5), 2283-2292. https://doi.org/10.30853/mns20260283
Vancouver
Goryachev NN. The “language of indirect coding” in the analysis of U.S. strategic documents: the limits of formalization, reproducibility, and validity. Manuscript. 2026;19(5):2283-2292. doi:10.30853/mns20260283
BibTeX
@article{Goryachev2026,
author = {Goryachev, Nikolay Nikolaevich},
title = {The “language of indirect coding” in the analysis of U.S. strategic documents: the limits of formalization, reproducibility, and validity},
journal = {Manuscript},
year = {2026},
volume = {19},
number = {5},
pages = {2283--2292},
doi = {10.30853/mns20260283}
}
EUVIMED