A Perspective from the Civil Procedure Act on Ensuring Accountability in Medical Appraisal
Korea Association of the Law of Civil Procedure · 30.06.2026 · 30 (2) · 41-92
DOI: 10.30639/cp.2026.6.30.2.041 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Korea Association of the Law of Civil Procedure, online erschienen am 30.06.2026. Verfasst von 이찬양 이찬양.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
In recent medical malpractice lawsuits, medical expert opinions function as a key evidentiary method that significantly influences judgments. However, various limitations, such as the ambiguity and bias of expert opinions, are continuously raised, necessitating the development of improvement measures. While existing studies have accumulated meaningful results focusing on individual topics of medical expert opinions, research that comprehensively examines the relationship between medical expert opinions and the court from the perspective of accountability, reflecting the unique characteristics of the field, has been relatively lacking. Accordingly, this study examined the systems of the United States, Germany, and Japan through comparative law and sought improvement measures for medical expert opinions based on accountability, focusing on the relationship between the expert and the court. First, it is necessary to consider specific measures for the court to draft judgments, such as including detailed review opinions regarding the relevant medical expert opinion, and to state the reasons for such adoption in the judgment when the court accepts the opinion. Second, it is also reasonable to consider specific measures to state the reasons for non-adoption in the judgment when the court does not accept the medical expert opinion. Third, since requiring the inclusion of clear grounds and criteria for court judgments could lead to limitations such as delays in trial proceedings due to excessive workload, further review is needed to align with judicial practice regarding whether to mandate the inclusion of specific grounds for the court's judgment on medical expert opinions. Regarding the issue of limited liability for damages concerning expert witnesses, first, it is reasonable to exercise caution in principle when determining whether to hold medical expert witnesses liable for damages. Second, exceptionally, it is necessary to discuss the possibility of an expert witness's liability for damages very cautiously, limiting it to the following cases by reviewing legal principles regarding expert witnesses in Germany: i) when the adoption by the relevant court of an erroneous expert opinion or result is deemed to have caused a serious infringement on the rights, interests, or protection of rights of the parties; and ii) when the expert witness is recognized as having intentionally or through gross negligence in infringing upon the legal interests of a third party while conducting the medical expert opinion. In such cases, carefully reviewing the liability for damages of the expert witness is, at best, reasonable. Regarding the topic of introducing prior consent and subsequent consent systems to overcome the limitations of anonymity in medical expert opinions, first, it is reasonable to keep the information of medical experts confidential in principle. Second, it is generally valid to structure the system so that, exceptionally, only the court can access the information of medical experts in the case of medical expert opinions. Third, there is a reasonable perspective on introducing a prior consent system (opt-in) and a subsequent consent system (opt-out) for the personal information of medical experts. Fourth, it is reasonable to avoid operating both the prior consent system (opt-in) and the subsequent consent system (opt-out) simultaneously.
Zitieren
APA
이찬양, 이. (2026). A Perspective from the Civil Procedure Act on Ensuring Accountability in Medical Appraisal. Korea Association of the Law of Civil Procedure, 30(2), 41-92. https://doi.org/10.30639/cp.2026.6.30.2.041
Vancouver
이찬양 이. A Perspective from the Civil Procedure Act on Ensuring Accountability in Medical Appraisal. Korea Association of the Law of Civil Procedure. 2026;30(2):41-92. doi:10.30639/cp.2026.6.30.2.041
BibTeX
@article{2026,
author = {이찬양, 이찬양},
title = {A Perspective from the Civil Procedure Act on Ensuring Accountability in Medical Appraisal},
journal = {Korea Association of the Law of Civil Procedure},
year = {2026},
volume = {30},
number = {2},
pages = {41--92},
doi = {10.30639/cp.2026.6.30.2.041}
}
EUVIMED