The Utopia That Confesses Its Own Impossibility: Ali Kemâl’s Novel Fetret
HİKMET-Akademik Edebiyat Dergisi (Journal Of Academic Literature) · 10.04.2026 · (24 [BAHAR 2026]) · 427-479
DOI: 10.28981/hikmet.1843565 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift HİKMET-Akademik Edebiyat Dergisi (Journal Of Academic Literature), online erschienen am 10.04.2026. Verfasst von Özgür İldeş. Die Arbeit nennt 28 Literaturangaben.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This article analyzes Ali Kemâl’s novel Fetret as an ideological manifesto that diagnoses the political, moral, and intellectual crisis of the Second Constitutional Era as a dystopian state of “interregnum” (fetret) and, in response, presents an individual-centered, liberal utopia of salvation. The study’s central thesis is that Ali Kemâl exposes the decay of the existing order by criticizing the era’s ignorant and verbose intellectuals, its corrupt intellectual life, and the “sick” Ottoman language, which was incapable of conveying thought. At the center of the utopian project proposed against this dystopia lies the model of the “new human,” designed in the person of the protagonist, Osman Fetret, who biologically and pedagogically represents a Turkish-English synthesis. The article reveals that the novel proposes rational, Westernist, and merit-based models of modernization in fields such as language, academia, public debate, and family. However, attention is also drawn to the project’s internal contradictions, such as its elitist nature that excludes the populace and its in-text admission of its own artificiality (being a product of “ihtilâl” [revolution/rupture] rather than “tekâmül” [evolution]). Finally, it is argued that the novel’s incompleteness, combined with the author’s tragic fate, should be read as a tragic metaphor for the failure and impossibility of this ambitious utopia in the face of reality. In this respect, the work is evaluated not so much as a prescription for salvation but as a poignant text documenting the unbridgeable gap between the modernist intellectual and their own society.
Zitieren
APA
İldeş, Ö. (2026). The Utopia That Confesses Its Own Impossibility: Ali Kemâl’s Novel Fetret. HİKMET-Akademik Edebiyat Dergisi (Journal Of Academic Literature), 427-479. https://doi.org/10.28981/hikmet.1843565
Vancouver
İldeş Ö. The Utopia That Confesses Its Own Impossibility: Ali Kemâl’s Novel Fetret. HİKMET-Akademik Edebiyat Dergisi (Journal Of Academic Literature). 2026:427-479. doi:10.28981/hikmet.1843565
BibTeX
@article{lde2026,
author = {İldeş, Özgür},
title = {The Utopia That Confesses Its Own Impossibility: Ali Kemâl’s Novel Fetret},
journal = {HİKMET-Akademik Edebiyat Dergisi (Journal Of Academic Literature)},
year = {2026},
number = {24 [BAHAR 2026]},
pages = {427--479},
doi = {10.28981/hikmet.1843565}
}
EUVIMED