EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Open Access · CC BY 4.0

Natureza Jurídica da Cláusula Take-or-Pay nos Contratos de Fornecimento da Cadeia do Gás Natural

José Querino de Macêdo Neto

Journal of Law and Regulation · 04.06.2026 · 12 (1) · 113-136

DOI: 10.26512/2446-52592026e61506 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Law and Regulation, online erschienen am 04.06.2026. Verfasst von José Querino de Macêdo Neto. Die Arbeit nennt 20 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

[Purpose] This study aims to examine the take-or-pay clause in natural gas supply contracts, investigating its historical origins, economic function, and the divergent doctrinal and jurisprudential positions regarding its legal nature under Brazilian law. It further seeks to identify the limits that contemporary contract law imposes on the unrestricted exercise of private autonomy in such contracts, proposing a moderate position that acknowledges the validity of the instrument without admitting its absolute and unconditional application. [Methodology/approach/design] The research adopts a legal-dogmatic methodology, employing qualitative analysis of national and foreign legal scholarship, relevant legislation, and the case law of Brazilian courts, with particular emphasis on precedents from the Superior Court of Justice. The study also draws on a historical-comparative approach to contextualize the emergence of the clause in the North American natural gas market and its reception in Brazil, as well as elements of law and economics to examine the rationality of the risk allocation the instrument performs. [Findings] The take-or-pay clause does not bear the legal nature of a penalty clause, nor of an alternative obligation, being more adequately qualified, according to the prevailing doctrine, as a guarantee obligation whereby the buyer assumes the risk of failing to consume the minimum contracted volume. Nevertheless, the validity of the clause does not entail absolute intangibility, as it remains subject to judicial review on grounds of excessive onerousness and objective good faith in duly characterized circumstances, particularly when extraordinary and unforeseeable events exceed the contractual risk allocation assumed by the buyer. [Practical implications] The findings of this article have direct application in the structuring and management of long-term natural gas and energy supply contracts, guiding legal practitioners, industry companies, and judges regarding the applicable legal regime for the take-or-pay clause. The consolidation of its obligational — rather than penal — nature strengthens legal certainty in energy infrastructure contracts, with a positive impact on the investment environment in Brazil's oil and gas sector. Furthermore, the delineation of limits on the exercise of the clause provides practical parameters for negotiating contractual risk mitigation mechanisms, such as make-up rights and carry-forward rights. [Originality/value] The proposed study fills a relevant gap in Brazilian legal literature by systematizing, in a critical and integrated manner, the divergent positions on the legal nature of the take-or-pay clause in light of recent Superior Court of Justice precedents, which remain underexplored in legal scholarship. The original contribution lies in mapping the impacts of the clause on natural gas supply chain contracts in a way that rejects both contractual absolutism — which would immunize the clause from any judicial review — and indiscriminate judicial intervention that, by qualifying the instrument as a penalty clause, frustrated the legitimate expectations of the parties and destabilized contracts of enormous significance for the development of national energy infrastructure.

Zitieren

APA

Neto, J. Q. D. M. (2026). Natureza Jurídica da Cláusula Take-or-Pay nos Contratos de Fornecimento da Cadeia do Gás Natural. Journal of Law and Regulation, 12(1), 113-136. https://doi.org/10.26512/2446-52592026e61506

Vancouver

Neto JQDM. Natureza Jurídica da Cláusula Take-or-Pay nos Contratos de Fornecimento da Cadeia do Gás Natural. Journal of Law and Regulation. 2026;12(1):113-136. doi:10.26512/2446-52592026e61506

BibTeX
@article{Neto2026,
  author = {Neto, José Querino de Macêdo},
  title = {Natureza Jurídica da Cláusula Take-or-Pay nos Contratos de Fornecimento da Cadeia do Gás Natural},
  journal = {Journal of Law and Regulation},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {12},
  number = {1},
  pages = {113--136},
  doi = {10.26512/2446-52592026e61506}
}
Kostenlos starten →