An investigation of congruence in coaches' perception and awareness of motivational, goal climate, and mindset within a task-interdependent environment : a pilot study
Texas Digital Library (University of Texas) · 21.04.2023
DOI: 10.26153/tsw/48263 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Texas Digital Library (University of Texas), erschienen am 21.04.2023. Verfasst von Mikayla R. Devins und 1 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Objective
This study investigated the congruence of coach self-perceptions with objective observations of behavior by (1) comparing coaches' perceived motivational approach to objective observations of motivational climate. (2) investigation of a sport that requires a high level of synchrony and precision creating a unique coaching situation. Sample: 13 competitive cheerleading coaches from 7 different competitive cheerleading gyms in Central TX. 8 male coaches and 5 female coaches (avg. 33.3 yrs, range 23-46), had at least 5 years of competitive cheer coaching experience (avg. 13.7 yrs, range 5-27). Also had experience as a competitor, with an average of 8.6 years of competitive cheer experience ranging from 0-27 years.
Method
A self-report questionnaire was utilized that aimed to collect data on the coaches' perceived mindset (growth vs fixed) in the competitive cheer environment based upon modified questions from the 3-item Growth Mindset Scale and their perceived coaching style (task vs ego) based upon modified questions from The Perceived Motivational Climate in Sport Questionnaire-2 (PMCSQ-2). Demographic information was collected verbally after each observation and recorded by a researcher. Coaches' behaviors were observed using the Coaching Behavior Assessment System (CBAS).
Results
Self-report- 84.6% reported a very high mastery climate; 15.3% reported a high mastery climate; 30.8% reported very low-performance climates; 61.5% reported a low-performance climate; Ego orientation was correlated with task orientation, r=-.22. 77% reported a high - mostly fixed mindset; 23% reported a moderate - neutral mindset; 0% reported growth; Ego nor task orientation correlated with a growth mindset.
Conclusion
30.7% of coaches did not have congruent findings with the observations for perceived motivational climate. 38.5% of coaches did not have congruent findings with the observations for mindset. Cheer experience was related to TO, r=.33 & GM, r=.37; Coaching experience was related to EO, r=.24 & GM, r = .39, but negatively to observed behavior, r=-.27; Observed behaviors were related to GM, r=.27. Coaches within a task-interdependent environment, such as cheerleading, lacked self-awareness to a degree based on comparison from self-report measures and observations. This study calls for more qualitative research within competitive cheer environments and coaching interventions to improve self-awareness.
Schlagwörter
Zitieren
APA
Devins, M. R., & 0009-0005-0514-4526 (2023). An investigation of congruence in coaches' perception and awareness of motivational, goal climate, and mindset within a task-interdependent environment : a pilot study. Texas Digital Library (University of Texas). https://doi.org/10.26153/tsw/48263
Vancouver
Devins MR, 0009-0005-0514-4526. An investigation of congruence in coaches' perception and awareness of motivational, goal climate, and mindset within a task-interdependent environment : a pilot study. Texas Digital Library (University of Texas). 2023. doi:10.26153/tsw/48263
BibTeX
@article{Devins2023,
author = {Devins, Mikayla R. and 0009-0005-0514-4526},
title = {An investigation of congruence in coaches' perception and awareness of motivational, goal climate, and mindset within a task-interdependent environment : a pilot study},
journal = {Texas Digital Library (University of Texas)},
year = {2023},
doi = {10.26153/tsw/48263}
}
EUVIMED