EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

Stewardship Obligations for Biobankers

R. Jean Cadigan, Karen M. Meagher

Stanford Digital Repository · 01.01.2025

DOI: 10.25936/q087-nh86 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Stanford Digital Repository, erschienen am 01.01.2025. Verfasst von R. Jean Cadigan und 1 weiteren Autor:innen.

AbstractSchlagwörterBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Biobanks are organized repositories of human biological samples and related data, designed to support current and future research. By relieving researchers of the need to collect new samples and enabling studies that link genetic, clinical, and environmental data, biobanks have become foundational to genomic science. However, they face persistent operational, funding, and sustainability challenges, often stemming from the mistaken assumption that biobanks primarily require only up-front investment. These challenges can undermine their long-term mission and erode public trust. Addressing them is a key responsibility for biobankers. Biobank stewardship has been shaped by a series of high-profile controversies that continue to inform contemporary debates. For example, the case of Henrietta Lacks, whose cervical cancer cells were used without her knowledge to create the HeLa cell line, remains emblematic of nonconsensual use and racial inequities in biomedical research. Similarly, researchers at Arizona State University collected blood samples from members of the Havasupai Tribe for diabetes research but later used them for unrelated studies without proper consent, resulting in a lawsuit and settlement. More recently, the bankruptcy of 23andMe and concerns over the potential sale of its biospecimens and genetic database have reignited public anxieties about the commodification of genomic data, privacy, and the feasibility of long-term stewardship. These and other cases around the world underscore the ethical and practical obligations of biobankers. Early ELSI scholarship on biobanking focused heavily on informed consent and the return of results, issues that remain important. However, as biobanks have become more complex and interconnected, especially amid funding insecurities, the focus has expanded to include questions of access, trust, commercialization, and long-term sustainability. The articles gathered here reflect this broader view of stewardship, highlighting the evolving responsibilities of biobankers across the full lifecycle of biobanks. This collection brings together interdisciplinary scholarship on biobank stewardship: the responsibility to manage collections in ways that are scientifically productive, sustainable, socially responsible, and respectful of participant contributions. It is organized around five key themes. Access, Utilization, and Sustainability addresses the ongoing difficulty of ensuring biobanks are used to their full scientific potential. Underuse or misuse, barriers to access, and unsustainable operations raise concerns by undermining the promise to contributors that their donations will benefit society. This theme also considers the importance of responsible planning to protect participant contributions in the event of biobank closure. Consent and Its Limits explores whether broad consent is ethically sufficient, how bioethics experts’ ideals of informed consent map onto empirical data of participant understanding, and how research contexts shape participants’ perceptions of this issue. Community and Participant Engagement and Trust highlights how inclusive governance, public dialogue, and ethical reflexivity are essential to maintaining legitimacy and trust. These works emphasize the importance of engaging participants not just as data sources, but as partners in shaping the goals, governance, and outcomes of biobank research. Decolonizing Biobanking considers how Indigenous and African perspectives can inform more culturally grounded and socially just biobanking practices. The readings emphasize values such as relationality, community consent, and sovereignty, and call for centering the rights, interests, and expectations of historically marginalized communities. Finally, Minimizing Group Harms and Advancing Reciprocity addresses how biobank research can pose risks to communities through stigma, misuse of data, and exploitation in the context of commercialization. It also explores the imperative of reciprocity and the role of Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) in recognizing and mitigating group-level harms. While grouped by theme, many articles speak to multiple dimensions of stewardship obligations, reflecting the interconnected nature of ELSI concerns in biobanking.

Schlagwörter

biobank ethicsinformed consentbroad consentbiobank sustainability23andMeHenrietta Lacksparticipant trustreturn of resultsgenomic data privacy

Zitieren

APA

Cadigan, R. J., & Meagher, K. M. (2025). Stewardship Obligations for Biobankers. Stanford Digital Repository. https://doi.org/10.25936/q087-nh86

Vancouver

Cadigan RJ, Meagher KM. Stewardship Obligations for Biobankers. Stanford Digital Repository. 2025. doi:10.25936/q087-nh86

BibTeX
@article{Cadigan2025,
  author = {Cadigan, R. Jean and Meagher, Karen M.},
  title = {Stewardship Obligations for Biobankers},
  journal = {Stanford Digital Repository},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.25936/q087-nh86}
}
Kostenlos starten →