Schreibkompetenzen von Erstklässlern quantitativ-empirisch erfassen - Herausforderungen und Zugewinn eines analytisch-kriterialen Vorgehens gegenüber einer holistischen Bewertung
Journal for Educational Research Online · 2016 · 8 (2)
DOI: 10.25656/01:12429 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal for Educational Research Online, 2016. Verfasst von Pohlmann-Rother und 5 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The article examines whether holistic and analytic evaluation-strategies are comparably suitable to reliably determine writing skills already in texts of first graders. The analyses of the 540 texts in total are sourced from the DFG project Narrative Writing Skills in Grade One (NaSch 1). First of all, the dimensionality of writing skills is being examined based on the analytic evaluation. Subsequently, the competence values determined by the two evaluation strategies are compared taking into account the length of text. The results of the Rasch scaling of the analytic criteria are indicating a two-dimensional structure (semantic-pragmatic vs. language-systematic) of writing skills where a stronger correlation of the holistic rating with the semantic-pragmatic (r = .78) than with the language-systematic dimension (r = .47) is emerging. In turn, the length of text shows a comparably high accordance with the semantic-pragmatic dimension (r = .63) and the holistic rating (r = .62), whose correlation still stays distinct when controlling the influence of the length of text using partial correlation (r = .64). In contrast, a correlation between the length of text and the language-systematic writing skills (r = .09) cannot be identified. (DIPF/Orig.)
Schlagwörter
Zitieren
APA
Pohlmann-Rother, Sanna, Schoreit, Edgar, Kürzinger, & Anja (2016). Schreibkompetenzen von Erstklässlern quantitativ-empirisch erfassen - Herausforderungen und Zugewinn eines analytisch-kriterialen Vorgehens gegenüber einer holistischen Bewertung. Journal for Educational Research Online, 8(2). https://doi.org/10.25656/01:12429
Vancouver
Pohlmann-Rother, Sanna, Schoreit, Edgar, Kürzinger, Anja. Schreibkompetenzen von Erstklässlern quantitativ-empirisch erfassen - Herausforderungen und Zugewinn eines analytisch-kriterialen Vorgehens gegenüber einer holistischen Bewertung. Journal for Educational Research Online. 2016;8(2). doi:10.25656/01:12429
BibTeX
@article{PohlmannRother2016,
author = {Pohlmann-Rother and Sanna and Schoreit and Edgar and Kürzinger and Anja},
title = {Schreibkompetenzen von Erstklässlern quantitativ-empirisch erfassen - Herausforderungen und Zugewinn eines analytisch-kriterialen Vorgehens gegenüber einer holistischen Bewertung},
journal = {Journal for Educational Research Online},
year = {2016},
volume = {8},
number = {2},
doi = {10.25656/01:12429}
}
EUVIMED