Comparison of the Russian State-Civilization and the Western Nation-State: The Civilizational Reconstruction of the Concept of the State and its Reality
Institute for Russian and Altaic Studies Chungbuk University · 30.05.2026 · 32 · 129-154
DOI: 10.24958/rh.2026.32.129 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Institute for Russian and Altaic Studies Chungbuk University, online erschienen am 30.05.2026. Verfasst von Woo Ik Choi.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This study provides a structural comparison between Russia's discourse of the “state-civilization” and the Western model of the “nation-state”. While the Western nation-state is characterized by “bottom-up dynamics” where civil society forms the state based on social contract theory and capitalist development, Russia has followed a path of “state precedence” and “top-down modernization”, where a civilization with historical and cultural continuity constitutes the state. The analysis reveals that while the Western conception of the state is an “instrumental entity” emphasizing legal-territorial sovereignty and market efficiency, the Russian civilization-state aims to be an “organic supra-structure” that preserves multi-ethnic integration, strategic autonomy, and spiritual values. These differences manifest as a clash between Western universalism and Russian multipolarity in international politics, providing the theoretical foundation for Russia's “economic fortification” and “de-dollarization” policies. By examining the civilization-state not as a mere ideological aberration but as an alternative model of state formation resulting from a distinct historical trajectory, this paper offers an in-depth understanding of the shifting multipolar world order and the increasing block-based geopolitics in Eurasia.
Zitieren
APA
Choi, W. I. (2026). Comparison of the Russian State-Civilization and the Western Nation-State: The Civilizational Reconstruction of the Concept of the State and its Reality. Institute for Russian and Altaic Studies Chungbuk University, 32, 129-154. https://doi.org/10.24958/rh.2026.32.129
Vancouver
Choi WI. Comparison of the Russian State-Civilization and the Western Nation-State: The Civilizational Reconstruction of the Concept of the State and its Reality. Institute for Russian and Altaic Studies Chungbuk University. 2026;32:129-154. doi:10.24958/rh.2026.32.129
BibTeX
@article{Choi2026,
author = {Choi, Woo Ik},
title = {Comparison of the Russian State-Civilization and the Western Nation-State: The Civilizational Reconstruction of the Concept of the State and its Reality},
journal = {Institute for Russian and Altaic Studies Chungbuk University},
year = {2026},
volume = {32},
pages = {129--154},
doi = {10.24958/rh.2026.32.129}
}
EUVIMED