Controlling Authoritarianism and Discretion in State Decision-Making in the 1988 Brazilian Constitution: The Role of the Constitutional Model of Due Process
Revista de Gestão Social e Ambiental · 31.05.2024 · 18 (5) · e014113
DOI: 10.24857/rgsa.v18n5-201 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Revista de Gestão Social e Ambiental, online erschienen am 31.05.2024. Verfasst von Lorena Ribeiro de Carvalho Sousa und 1 weiteren Autor:innen. Die Arbeit nennt 19 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Institution: This essay aims to analyze the historical and theoretical foundations that underpin the formation of the Brazilian State, especially after the promulgation of the 1988 Federal Constitution (CRFB/88). The context addressed is the period of transition from the dictatorial regime established in 1964, marked by repression, arbitrariness, and violations of fundamental rights, to a democratic regime. Despite political efforts toward democratization, it is observed that, almost forty years after the promulgation of the Constitution, the remnant of authoritarianism in the Brazilian State emerges as a problem to be solved by this research. This authoritarianism manifests itself in the uncheckable discretion, stemming from open-ended normative commands, which grants the interpreter the possibility of filling in the meaning, which may sometimes be characterized by arbitrariness, subjectivism, or voluntariness. Adopting a bibliographic methodology, based on a review of Brazilian and foreign literature on the subject, this study seeks to clarify the arrangements between the rupture of the Dictatorial Regime and (re)democratization in the 1980s; the phenomenon of discretion; and, finally, the delineation of the Democratic Rule of Law in the 1988 Brazilian Constitution, and the importance of the constitutional model of due process in the state decision-making process. In conclusion, it will be argued that the guarantees of adversarial proceedings, full defense, and reasoned decisions serve as a means of citizen control over state decision-making.
Objective
The objective of this study is to investigate the historical and theoretical foundations of authoritarianism and discretion in state decision-making in Brazil, especially in the post-promulgation context of the 1988 Constitution of the Federative Republic of Brazil, with the aim of analyzing how the constitutional model of due process can act as a form of democratic control of state power, ensuring the legitimacy of decisions and the realization of fundamental rights. Theoretical Framework: This study is based on the theory of the Democratic Rule of Law and democratic constitutionalism, with special attention to authoritarian remnants and spaces of state discretion in the post-promulgation context of the 1988 Constitution of the Federative Republic of Brazil. The analysis engages with theoretical contributions that examine the transition from dictatorial regime to democratic constitutional order, highlighting how the semantic openness of normative commands can favor decision-making practices marked by subjectivism and arbitrariness. The framework mobilizes contributions from Jürgen Habermas regarding procedural democracy, as well as critiques of administrative and judicial discretion formulated by authors such as Georges Abboud, Lenio Streck, and Celso Antônio Bandeira de Mello. Furthermore, the constitutional model of process is adopted as the central axis of analysis, understanding the guarantees of adversarial proceedings, full defense, and the justification of decisions as essential forms of legitimation and democratic control of state action.
Method
This research adopts a qualitative approach, of a theoretical and bibliographical nature, developed from a historical-dogmatic analysis of the process of formation of the Brazilian State in the post-Military Regime period. The study is based on a critical review of national and foreign literature on authoritarianism, state discretion, democratic constitutionalism, and the constitutional model of process, with the aim of examining the impacts of these elements on administrative, legislative, and jurisdictional decision-making within the framework of the Democratic Rule of Law established by the 1988 Constitution. Results and Discussion: The analysis reveals that, despite the promulgation of the 1988 Constitution of the Federative Republic of Brazil formally establishing the Democratic Rule of Law, decision-making practices marked by authoritarianism and broad state discretion persist. The results indicate that the semantic openness of constitutional normative commands, associated with the institutional remnants of the dictatorial regime, contributes to the formation of undefined and poorly monitored decision-making spaces, both in the administrative and judicial spheres. The discussion demonstrates that such spaces favor the subjective and, at times, arbitrary actions of state agents, straining the effectiveness of fundamental rights and the democratic legitimacy of decisions. In this context, the constitutional model of due process emerges as a central mechanism for containing authoritarianism, by ensuring the right to a fair hearing, full defense, and reasoned decisions as indispensable guarantees for the democratic control of state action and the rationalization of decision-making processes. Research Implications: This research contributes to a critical understanding of the limits of state discretion within the context of a democratic rule of law, highlighting the importance of the constitutional model of due process as a guarantee of controlling authoritarianism in state decision-making. The results offer theoretical support for strengthening more transparent, well-founded, and participatory decision-making practices, with potential impact on administrative, legislative, and judicial actions. Originality/Value: This study distinguishes itself by articulating the historical analysis of authoritarianism in the Brazilian state with contemporary critiques of state discretion, highlighting the constitutional model of due process as a central axis of democratic control over decisions. By emphasizing procedural guarantees as a way of legitimizing state power, the work adds value to the legal debate by proposing an interpretation that goes beyond merely formal approaches to post-1988 constitutionalism.
Zitieren
APA
Sousa, L. R. D. C., & Soalheiro, L. (2024). Controlling Authoritarianism and Discretion in State Decision-Making in the 1988 Brazilian Constitution: The Role of the Constitutional Model of Due Process. Revista de Gestão Social e Ambiental, 18(5), e014113. https://doi.org/10.24857/rgsa.v18n5-201
Vancouver
Sousa LRDC, Soalheiro L. Controlling Authoritarianism and Discretion in State Decision-Making in the 1988 Brazilian Constitution: The Role of the Constitutional Model of Due Process. Revista de Gestão Social e Ambiental. 2024;18(5):e014113. doi:10.24857/rgsa.v18n5-201
BibTeX
@article{Sousa2024,
author = {Sousa, Lorena Ribeiro de Carvalho and Soalheiro, Luiza},
title = {Controlling Authoritarianism and Discretion in State Decision-Making in the 1988 Brazilian Constitution: The Role of the Constitutional Model of Due Process},
journal = {Revista de Gestão Social e Ambiental},
year = {2024},
volume = {18},
number = {5},
pages = {e014113},
doi = {10.24857/rgsa.v18n5-201}
}
EUVIMED