Non-Classical Correlation Between Subjective and Objective Color Observations
Journal of Anomalistics / Zeitschrift für Anomalistik · 30.06.2026 · 26 (1) · 14-36
DOI: 10.23793/zfa.2026.014 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Anomalistics / Zeitschrift für Anomalistik, online erschienen am 22.06.2026. Verfasst von Markus Maier und 3 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
In recent research testing the non-commutability conjecture of the Generalized Quantum Theory, Maier and Dechamps (2025) reported macroscopic complementary relations empirically documented as non-classical correlations between subjective assessment of likability of colors and variations of objective documentations of these colors. Specifically, they found higher likability mean scores in a condition where objective color parameters were not erased and stored in a result file compared to a condition in which these parameters were erased and inaccessible by experimenters. This effect was robust across four studies. Each study’s design in this series of experiments was intentionally confounded with a “color bias” variable. Only limited sets of colors after random creation were specifically assigned to one of the two conditions, so that the effect of the erasure manipulation could alternatively be explained by the specific features of the colors assigned to conditions (the confound was later statistically ruled out by permutations). The presence of a confound was introduced to avoid the impact of the NT axiom, which forbids a strict causal testing approach. Rather, according to the NT axiom when macroscopic complementary relations are tested in a strictly causal way, initial effect documentations should be followed by a decline within and across studies. In the study presented here, the studies of Maier and Dechamps (2025) were conceptually replicated by a strict, i. e. unconfounded, causal testing strategy, to explicitly test the proposed impact of the NT axiom. In two experimental conditions (within-subjects) objective color parameters were either stored or not stored. Assignment of colors to conditions was randomized on the participant level this time ensuring an unconfounded design. The prediction derived from the NT axiom was that under such circumstances the erasure-dependent likability effect should initially be found and later drastically decline. The results supported this prediction: A higher likability mean score was initially found in the non-erasure compared to the erasure condition with strong Bayesian evidence (BF10 = 39.77), replicating the previous findings but now followed by a decline within the study. These findings are in line with the conjectures of the GQT. Specifically, they indicate that subjective assessments and objective measurements of colors are non-commutable and that the data follow the predictions of the NT axiom exhibiting an “effect and decline” data pattern when strictly causally tested. An additional permutation analysis showed that the probability to find such an effect and decline data pattern by chance was very low (p < .03) indicating that it could hardly be interpreted as “false positive” finding. The impact of this and the previous results on the validity of the GQT in describing psychophysical relations as non-classical correlations between spatio-temporally separated subjective assessments and objective measurements of colors is discussed.
Zitieren
APA
Maier, M., Vogel, A., Storch, J., & Dechamps, M. (2026). Non-Classical Correlation Between Subjective and Objective Color Observations. Journal of Anomalistics / Zeitschrift für Anomalistik, 26(1), 14-36. https://doi.org/10.23793/zfa.2026.014
Vancouver
Maier M, Vogel A, Storch J, Dechamps M. Non-Classical Correlation Between Subjective and Objective Color Observations. Journal of Anomalistics / Zeitschrift für Anomalistik. 2026;26(1):14-36. doi:10.23793/zfa.2026.014
BibTeX
@article{Maier2026,
author = {Maier, Markus and Vogel, Anastasia and Storch, Johannes and Dechamps, Moritz},
title = {Non-Classical Correlation Between Subjective and Objective Color Observations},
journal = {Journal of Anomalistics / Zeitschrift für Anomalistik},
year = {2026},
volume = {26},
number = {1},
pages = {14--36},
doi = {10.23793/zfa.2026.014}
}
EUVIMED