Progress and Parody in Resurrection Blues
The Arthur Miller Journal · 2013
DOI: 10.2307/42909104 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift The Arthur Miller Journal, 2013. Verfasst von Richard Brucher. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 1-mal zitiert (Crossref) und nennt 26 Literaturangaben.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Since the 1960s, at least in the United States, Arthur Miller's plays have been liked but not well liked. His last plays, from the 1990s and 2000s, have hardly been liked at all. This general disfavor with reviewers might be attributed to one of two reasons: either the late play is too much like Miller's early great plays-the big four-or it is not like them enough. One critic dismissed Broken Glass, Miller's 1994 play about a troubled Jewish marriage and a philandering doctor in Brooklyn at the time of Kristallnacht, as being "Ibsenism by the book" (Richard 129), as if Miller slavishly replicated the moral causation and social realism of A Doll's House (1879) and All My Sons (1947). Resurrection Blues, Miller's 2002 play about a televised crucifixion of a South American revolutionary who may be the Messiah, has been dismissed as lame Monty Pythonism, as if Miller desecrated with satire his own reputation for high-minded political tragedy on the order of The Crucible (1953) (Herman). Another critic, from the United Kingdom where even Miller's late plays are usually very well liked, remarked that "You don't really know what embarrassment is until you've witnessed [Maxmillian] Schell, as the wicked dictator, lamenting his impotence with the words: 'My dog won't go hunting anymore'" (Spencer). An American critic who was trying to like Resurrection Blues as "a bitter comedy about the world that the American century wrought," also regretted General Barriaux's sex jokes as "juvenile and truly beneath a playwright of Mr. Miller's stature" (Weber).The General's line was funny in the spring 2010 production of Resurrection Blues I chanced to see in Chicago on Good Friday. Matt Welton played Felix Barriaux with persuasive comic-melodramatic consternation-as a ruthless pragmatist surrounded by fucking idiots, as Felix suggests late in the play, not as a cartoon. Perhaps because Welton lacked Schell's stature I didn't take the character's lines to be an insult to the actor. Perhaps the line strikes me as funny because Felix is not joking and because the euphemism is oddly in character. Felix is a cross between a Hitler or Juan Peron and one of Ibsen's autocratie Victorian prudes. In context, Felix's confession of impotence to his cousin Henri Schultz, a wealthy pharmaceuticals distributor turned public intellectual, comes as a disjunctive surprise. Neither the impotence itself nor Felix's contradictory image comes as a surprise; both matters are established by the play's opening gambits. Felix acknowledges his impotence in his opening speech, on the intercom with his secretary Isabelle, who appeared as a busty silhouette in the American premiere (see Weber) and whom he disappointed the night before. With Isabelle he uses a tone of macho dismissiveness: "I want you to forget last night, agreed?" (Miller, RB 5). His niece Jeanine, Henri's daughter, has already established his ruthlessness. Jeanine has attempted suicide, she explains in the prologue Miller added after the premiere American production, because her uncle spared her life when his soldiers annihilated her "little brigade" of revolutionaries: "shot them all in thirty seconds," and not one of them over nineteen years old (RB 3).Felix Barriaux is Miller's contribution to a long line of ruthless but comic stage despots who are politically, morally, and aesthetically problematic figures. Daniel Gerould notes W. H. Auden's contention that "Hitler is no fit subject for humor [because] we cannot consider comic what we hate. On these grounds, the comic despot who is both hateful and powerful becomes an impossibility." Gerould argues that "the loathsome dictator is by his very nature grotesquely ludicrous, and the terrible plight of the tyrannized may well be equally preposterous" (Gerould 4). Writing a few years after The Crucible opened, Miller said that in retrospect he wishes that he had made Judge Danforth less human. "I was wrong in mitigating the evil of this man and the judges he represents. …
Zitieren
APA
Brucher, R. (2013). Progress and Parody in Resurrection Blues. The Arthur Miller Journal. https://doi.org/10.2307/42909104
Vancouver
Brucher R. Progress and Parody in Resurrection Blues. The Arthur Miller Journal. 2013. doi:10.2307/42909104
BibTeX
@article{Brucher2013,
author = {Brucher, Richard},
title = {Progress and Parody in Resurrection Blues},
journal = {The Arthur Miller Journal},
year = {2013},
doi = {10.2307/42909104}
}
EUVIMED