EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

A Study on the Interest in Filing an Application for Remedy against Unfair Dismissal and Other Unfair Employment Action : Focusing on Supreme Court Decision 2025Du33276,Rendered on October 16, 2025

Geonho Min

Wonkwang University Legal Research Institute · 30.06.2026 · 42 (2) · 169-193

DOI: 10.22397/wlri.2026.42.2.169 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Wonkwang University Legal Research Institute, online erschienen am 30.06.2026. Verfasst von Geonho Min.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Supreme Court Decision 2025Du33276, rendered on October 16, 2025, held that if an employee submitted a resignation letter before filing an application for remedy against unfair dismissal and the employment relationship was thereby terminated, the employee had already lost employee status at the time of filing and therefore had neither an interest in obtaining a remedial order from the Labor Relations Commission nor a legal interest in maintaining an action for revocation of the National Labor Relations Commission’s review decision. The decision can be understood as an extension of existing case law that determines the interest in filing an application by reference to whether the applicant retained employee status at the time of filing. It also reaffirms the procedural significance of the interest in filing in the statutory remedy procedure for unfair dismissal and other unfair employment actions. However, the statutory remedy system for unfair dismissal does not merely aim to reinstate employees to their original positions. Under the Labor Standards Act, where unfair dismissal or another unfair employment action is established, the Labor Relations Commission may order reinstatement as well as payment of back pay. If the employee does not wish to be reinstated, the Commission may order monetary compensation in lieu of reinstatement. In addition, where reinstatement has become impossible due to the expiration of the employment contract, mandatory retirement, or similar circumstances, the Commission may still order payment of back pay or other monetary relief equivalent to restoration. These rules show that the remedy system serves not only to restore formal employee status, but also to restore the legal and economic position that the employee would have enjoyed but for the unfair dismissal. This case comment examines the decision by classifying the relevant situations into four types, based on two criteria: whether the relevant event occurred before or after the filing of the application, and whether it involved waiver of reinstatement or impossibility of reinstatement. Through this framework, it considers whether a pre-filing waiver of reinstatement, as in the present case, should be treated in the same way as pre-filing impossibility of reinstatement, and whether it should be distinguished from post-filing waiver of reinstatement. This comment argues that denying the interest in filing solely because the employee expressed an intention to waive reinstatement before filing the application fails to adequately reflect the distinction between waiver and impossibility of reinstatement, as well as the structure and function of monetary compensation orders. This comment also reconsiders the evidentiary value of resignation letters in employment relationships. In ordinary civil litigation, a document signed or sealed by a party may carry significant evidentiary weight. In employment disputes, however, the context in which such a document is prepared requires closer scrutiny. Given the imbalance of information and bargaining power between employers and employees, courts should be cautious in inferring a genuine intention to resign solely from the existence of a resignation letter. Otherwise, employers may be able to circumvent statutory restrictions on dismissal through the formal device of a resignation letter. This is particularly problematic where the resignation letter is obtained in connection with the settlement of retirement pay or other post-employment documents, and where the employee soon thereafter contests the termination as unfair dismissal. Finally, this comment examines the decision from the perspective of procedural economy. The decision may appear, from an ex post perspective, to promote efficiency by allowing courts and labor relations commissions to avoid merits review where the applicant no longer retains employee status.

Zitieren

APA

Min, G. (2026). A Study on the Interest in Filing an Application for Remedy against Unfair Dismissal and Other Unfair Employment Action : Focusing on Supreme Court Decision 2025Du33276,Rendered on October 16, 2025. Wonkwang University Legal Research Institute, 42(2), 169-193. https://doi.org/10.22397/wlri.2026.42.2.169

Vancouver

Min G. A Study on the Interest in Filing an Application for Remedy against Unfair Dismissal and Other Unfair Employment Action : Focusing on Supreme Court Decision 2025Du33276,Rendered on October 16, 2025. Wonkwang University Legal Research Institute. 2026;42(2):169-193. doi:10.22397/wlri.2026.42.2.169

BibTeX
@article{Min2026,
  author = {Min, Geonho},
  title = {A Study on the Interest in Filing an Application for Remedy against Unfair Dismissal and Other Unfair Employment Action : Focusing on Supreme Court Decision 2025Du33276,Rendered on October 16, 2025},
  journal = {Wonkwang University Legal Research Institute},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {42},
  number = {2},
  pages = {169--193},
  doi = {10.22397/wlri.2026.42.2.169}
}
Kostenlos starten →