The Essence of Co-principals and Co-principals of Negligent Crimes
Wonkwang University Legal Research Institute · 31.03.2026 · 42 (1) · 3-24
DOI: 10.22397/wlri.2026.42.1.3 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Wonkwang University Legal Research Institute, online erschienen am 31.03.2026. Verfasst von Tae Gwon Yoo.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The question of whether to recognize joint negligence (joint principalship in negligent crimes) when multiple negligent actors contribute to a constituent result remains one of the unresolved challenges in the theory of joint principalship. However, existing studies have failed to provide a sufficiently persuasive solution from the dogmatic perspectives of both negligence and joint principalship. This paper begins with the question of whether the necessity of punishing joint negligence justifies sacrificing the essence of joint principalship. Based on the essence of joint principalship, which was originally the basis for negative theories, this study seeks to explore new possibilities for an affirmative theory. The affirmative theories that adopt a dualistic attitude; interpreting the essence of joint principalship differently for intentional and negligent crimes; are limited because they stem from the necessity of punishment rather than logical necessity. The theory of the essence of joint principalship should be applied consistently regardless of intent or negligence, and the acceptance of joint negligence must also originate from this essence. Functional act control (Funktionale Tatherrschaft), the current prevailing theory in Korea, understands that a joint principal is a principal not simply because they participated, but because they control the entire event through cooperation with others. According to Roxin, joint principalship is established when each individual is in a “key position” (Schlüsselstellung), capable of aborting the entire plan by withdrawing their contribution. Therefore, for a negligent actor to be recognized as a principal, there must be control from a normative and evaluative perspective, which is possible when the actor is evaluated as having normative control through a breach of the duty of care in their respective domain. However, existing affirmative theories, such as the theory of joint act or the focus on mutual communication and awareness of a shared breach of duty, lack a sufficient basis for attributing the results of another's actions to oneself, as they focus more on situational circumstances than on active participation or cooperation in the crime itself. Accordingly, this paper proposes “participation in a joint plan” as a restrictive requirement for affirming joint negligence. The moment actors participate in a joint plan, they share the effects of completing that plan and include others' compliance with the duty of care within their own sphere of responsibility. Thus, those participating under a joint plan can be inferred to have an intent to actively participate and attribute the legal effects of others' actions to themselves, which can be explained within the framework of functional act control. In conclusion, the requirement of “participation in a joint plan” serves as an alternative that prevents punishment gaps in large-scale corporate crimes within modern risk societies while maintaining the essential discourse of functional act control. This calls for a reflective review of existing precedents that have broadly recognized joint negligence simply based on the existence of mutual communication. By interpreting “joint” in Article 30 of the Criminal Act more strictly and sophisticatedly, this approach will contribute to preventing the undue expansion of punishment while ensuring legal stability.
Zitieren
APA
Yoo, T. G. (2026). The Essence of Co-principals and Co-principals of Negligent Crimes. Wonkwang University Legal Research Institute, 42(1), 3-24. https://doi.org/10.22397/wlri.2026.42.1.3
Vancouver
Yoo TG. The Essence of Co-principals and Co-principals of Negligent Crimes. Wonkwang University Legal Research Institute. 2026;42(1):3-24. doi:10.22397/wlri.2026.42.1.3
BibTeX
@article{Yoo2026,
author = {Yoo, Tae Gwon},
title = {The Essence of Co-principals and Co-principals of Negligent Crimes},
journal = {Wonkwang University Legal Research Institute},
year = {2026},
volume = {42},
number = {1},
pages = {3--24},
doi = {10.22397/wlri.2026.42.1.3}
}
EUVIMED