EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

Review of the Legal Doctrine of the Reasonable Expectation of Contract Renewal for Fixed-Term Workers and Recent Judicial Trends: Focusing on Court Decisions from 2024 to 2025

Dong Uk Lee

Wonkwang University Legal Research Institute · 31.03.2026 · 42 (1) · 187-215

DOI: 10.22397/wlri.2026.42.1.187 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Wonkwang University Legal Research Institute, online erschienen am 31.03.2026. Verfasst von Dong Uk Lee.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

This study aims to examine, from multiple perspectives, recent trends in the judicial application of the legal doctrine of the “reasonable expectation of renewal” in relation to fixed-term employment contracts, which are widely used in the modern labor market as a means of securing employment flexibility. In the current legal framework, the Act on the Protection of Fixed-Term and Part-Time Employees limits the period of employment for fixed-term workers to two years, but, in principle, the expiry of the contract term constitutes a ground for the automatic termination of the employment relationship. Nevertheless, courts have developed the doctrine of the reasonable expectation of renewal—under which a refusal to renew a contract without reasonable grounds is deemed null and void, equivalent to unfair dismissal—where a legitimate expectation of renewal is recognized in light of the structural imbalance of power between labor and management. While this doctrine originated as a judicial interpretation designed to fill a legislative gap, debates between academic commentators and the courts over its continued existence and function have persisted even after the enactment of the Fixed-Term Act, making it a core issue for understanding the overall protection system for fixed-term employment relationships. Focusing on approximately 70 recent decisions handed down between 2024 and 2025, this paper empirically analyzes the concrete standards and reasoning structures through which the doctrine of the reasonable expectation of renewal is applied in actual cases. The analysis shows that recent case law examines various factors—including the presence of explicit renewal clauses, repeated renewals, the permanence and continuity of duties, the specificity and fairness of evaluation criteria, and circumstances surrounding recruitment and contract formation—within a largely standardized framework. Notably, the existence of a reasonable expectation of renewal was recognized in approximately 65% of the analyzed cases. Furthermore, this study identifies how this reasoning structure corresponds to the existing theoretical distinction between “rule-based” and “circumstance-based” types of expectations. Regarding “reasonable grounds” for refusal of renewal, the courts apply a standard more lenient than the “just cause” required for dismissal under the Labor Standards Act, while simultaneously constraining the employer's evaluative discretion from being exercised arbitrarily. Specifically, courts engage in a multi-layered review of the objectivity and transparency of evaluation criteria, the fairness of evaluator composition and procedures, and the seriousness of individual factors such as the employee’s competence, work attitude, and misconduct to balance freedom of contract with job security. Among cases where an expectation of renewal was recognized, the proportion of refusals deemed “unfair” (approx. 57%) was higher than those deemed “justified” (approx. 43%), suggesting that courts are strictly controlling employer discretion through procedural requirements. Furthermore, the study examines exceptional issues, including the reasonable expectation of renewal for post-retirement “choktak” (contract-based) workers, the application of the doctrine to small businesses with four or fewer employees, and the relationship with the procedural requirements for dismissal under Article 27 of the Labor Standards Act. For post-retirement workers, additional factors—such as age-related declines in capacity and productivity, heightened accident risks, and workplace practices—act as supplementary considerations. For businesses with four or fewer employees, the paper notes that the doctrine is accepted in principle despite the non-application of statutory dismissal restrictions. Additionally, the courts have held that the written-notification requirement under Article 27 of the Labor Standards Act does not appl

Zitieren

APA

Lee, D. U. (2026). Review of the Legal Doctrine of the Reasonable Expectation of Contract Renewal for Fixed-Term Workers and Recent Judicial Trends: Focusing on Court Decisions from 2024 to 2025. Wonkwang University Legal Research Institute, 42(1), 187-215. https://doi.org/10.22397/wlri.2026.42.1.187

Vancouver

Lee DU. Review of the Legal Doctrine of the Reasonable Expectation of Contract Renewal for Fixed-Term Workers and Recent Judicial Trends: Focusing on Court Decisions from 2024 to 2025. Wonkwang University Legal Research Institute. 2026;42(1):187-215. doi:10.22397/wlri.2026.42.1.187

BibTeX
@article{Lee2026,
  author = {Lee, Dong Uk},
  title = {Review of the Legal Doctrine of the Reasonable Expectation of Contract Renewal for Fixed-Term Workers and Recent Judicial Trends: Focusing on Court Decisions from 2024 to 2025},
  journal = {Wonkwang University Legal Research Institute},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {42},
  number = {1},
  pages = {187--215},
  doi = {10.22397/wlri.2026.42.1.187}
}
Kostenlos starten →