Transnational Surrogacy, Active Nationality Principle, and the Legitimacy of (Transnational) Criminal Law
Transnational Criminal Law Review · 09.01.2026 · 4 (2)
DOI: 10.22329/tclr.v4i2.8967 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Transnational Criminal Law Review, online erschienen am 09.01.2026. Verfasst von Alberto Di Martino. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This article starts from the heated political and cultural discussion stirred up in Italy by a draft law criminalizing gestational surrogacy carried out by Italian citizens abroad. Extraterritorial punishment would be then enforced beyond the limiting requirements set out by the current domestic system of extraterritorial criminal jurisdiction –i.e., unconditionally. While the domestic debate is mainly concerned with classical operational aspects of extraterritorial criminal jurisdiction (e.g., content and scope of the double criminality requirement; interstate cooperation especially in evidentiary issues), this contribution intends to underline the relevance of the case-study for the broader issue of legitimacy to impose criminal punishment. In this vein, it provides a critical overview of conventional foundations of the nationality principle from an analytical standpoint, accounting for a human-rights oriented reconceptualization. After considering authoritative philosophical criticisms of extraterritorial jurisdiction in general, with special reference to Duff’s ‘citizen theory of criminal law’, the article maintains that legitimacy does not lie in the (however defined) concept of citizenship, but rather in the actual relationship between any authority vested with a legitimate criminal power and the complex ‘situation of life’ set up by the behavior carried out by individuals. This leads to an innovative functional reading of criminal jurisdiction that, while overcoming a purely geographical notion of territory, overcomes the very distinction between territoriality and extra-territoriality in the legal space built through social relations that fall within the remit of criminal law.
Zitieren
APA
Martino, A. D. (2026). Transnational Surrogacy, Active Nationality Principle, and the Legitimacy of (Transnational) Criminal Law. Transnational Criminal Law Review, 4(2). https://doi.org/10.22329/tclr.v4i2.8967
Vancouver
Martino AD. Transnational Surrogacy, Active Nationality Principle, and the Legitimacy of (Transnational) Criminal Law. Transnational Criminal Law Review. 2026;4(2). doi:10.22329/tclr.v4i2.8967
BibTeX
@article{Martino2026,
author = {Martino, Alberto Di},
title = {Transnational Surrogacy, Active Nationality Principle, and the Legitimacy of (Transnational) Criminal Law},
journal = {Transnational Criminal Law Review},
year = {2026},
volume = {4},
number = {2},
doi = {10.22329/tclr.v4i2.8967}
}
EUVIMED