Development and Pilot Evaluation of a Standardized and Accessible Rubric (OMNI) for Assessing Generative AI in Health Care Contexts: Four-Stage Mixed Methods Study
Journal of Medical Internet Research · 27.10.2026 · 28 · e100531-e100531
DOI: 10.2196/100531 ↗Kurz gefasst
Mixed-Methods-Studie in der Zeitschrift Journal of Medical Internet Research, online erschienen am 27.10.2026. Verfasst von Erik Cornelisse und 39 weiteren Autor:innen. Beteiligte Einrichtung: College of Medicine and Public Health, Flinders Health and Medical Research Institute, Flinders University, Flinders University Health and Medical Re…. Hauptthemen laut MEDLINE: Delivery of Health Care, Artificial Intelligence. Die Arbeit nennt 105 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei in PubMed Central verfügbar.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Background
The rapid adoption of generative AI in the community and health care necessitates reliable, human-led evaluation.
Objective
This study aimed to develop a standardized rubric to support health care professionals, administrators, and researchers in evaluating generative AI outputs in health contexts.
Methods
A rubric was developed through a 4-stage mixed methods study: literature synthesis, expert refinement, pilot application, and post-pilot feedback. The rubric was informed by 69 publications and refined through iterative feedback from a multidisciplinary expert panel (n=23). The pilot rubric was applied to 4 health care scenarios: responses to health-related Reddit questions, generation of health-related images and videos, responses to health professional continuing education questions, and automated physician-to-physician clinical documentation generation. Via these scenarios, 15 clinicians (medical practitioners, pharmacists, and medical oncologists) evaluated 250 input-output pairs using domain-level ratings and qualitative comments. The evaluated outputs included 200 AI-generated responses across the 4 health care scenarios and 50 physician-tagged replies in the health-related Reddit questions scenario.
Results
The final rubric, OMNI, comprised 10 evaluation domains (Accuracy, Safety, Recognizes Uncertainty, Completeness, Communicates Clearly, Empathetic, Context Aware, Referencing, Follows Instructions, and Avoids Coerciveness) assessed on 4-point Likert scales, supported by detailed instructional and example materials. Via the 4 pilot scenarios, assessors generated 9600 domain-level ratings and 4010 qualitative comments. The mean pairwise agreement for the 4-point Likert groups ranged from 30.8% to 53.4%, increasing to 59.3% to 79.6% when collapsed into broad agreement categories; Gwet’s AC2 ranged from 0.49 to 0.80. OMNI differentiated strengths and weaknesses between models within scenarios, while recurrent limitations in Referencing, Recognizes Uncertainty, Completeness, Empathetic, and Accuracy were identified across scenarios. Multimodal image and video outputs had the highest occurrence of negative rating domains. Assessors reported OMNI was usable and indicated they would reuse it.
Conclusions
OMNI is a standardized, accessible rubric for expert-led evaluation of generative AI outputs in health contexts. Pilot application demonstrated that OMNI could differentiate AI performance across models and domains while generating structured feedback. Further work is needed to assess its applicability to purpose-built health AI tools, agentic systems, and organizational evaluation settings.
Schlagwörter
MeSH-Schlagwörter (MEDLINE)
Stichwörter der Autor:innen
Autor:innen und Institutionen
- College of Medicine and Public Health, Flinders Health and Medical Research Institute, Flinders University, Flinders University Health and Medical Research Building, Sports Rd, Bedford Park, Adelaide, South Australia, 5…
- Science to People, Inc, Lexington, MA, United States.
- Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY, United States.
- Schulich School of Medicine and Dentistry, Western University, London, ON, Canada.
- Cancer Council South Australia, Adelaide, South Australia, Australia.
- Caring Futures Institute, College of Health and Enablement, Flinders University, Adelaide, South Australia, Australia.
Zitieren
APA
Cornelisse, E., Kousa, D., Menz, B. D., Murphy-Reuter, B., Shahnam, A., Chin-Yee, B., Calabro, R., Li, L. X., Ramsey, I., Abuhelwa, A. Y., Logan, J. M., Ng, H. S., Aravinthan, M., Goonan, J., Carthew, H., Molyneux, P., Tang, J., Hitchen, N., Hong, M., …, & Hopkins, A. M. (2026). Development and Pilot Evaluation of a Standardized and Accessible Rubric (OMNI) for Assessing Generative AI in Health Care Contexts: Four-Stage Mixed Methods Study. Journal of Medical Internet Research, 28, e100531-e100531. https://doi.org/10.2196/100531
Vancouver
Cornelisse E, Kousa D, Menz BD, Murphy-Reuter B, Shahnam A, Chin-Yee B, et al. Development and Pilot Evaluation of a Standardized and Accessible Rubric (OMNI) for Assessing Generative AI in Health Care Contexts: Four-Stage Mixed Methods Study. Journal of Medical Internet Research. 2026;28:e100531-e100531. doi:10.2196/100531
BibTeX
@article{Cornelisse2026,
author = {Cornelisse, Erik and Kousa, Dib and Menz, Bradley D and Murphy-Reuter, Brinleigh and Shahnam, Adel and Chin-Yee, Benjamin and Calabro, Ryan and Li, Lee X and Ramsey, Imogen and Abuhelwa, Ahmad Y and Logan, Jessica M and Ng, Huah Shin and Aravinthan, Mythily and Goonan, James and Carthew, Hannah and Molyneux, Paul and Tang, Joanne and Hitchen, Nadia and Hong, Martin and Gandhi, Jimit and Fontanarosa, Stephanie and Scarfo, Nicholas L and Daniel, Kezia and Marotti, Sally B and Mariadas, Joy and van Diermen, Bianca and Susai Manickam, Divya Joyce and Ruanglertboon, Warit and Postma, David and McCradden, Melissa D and Reddy, Sandeep and Bacchi, Stephen and Mangoni, Arduino A and McKinnon, Ross A and Kichenadasse, Ganessan and Lyman, Gary H and Kuderer, Nicole M and Sorich, Michael J and Rowland, Andrew and Hopkins, Ashley M},
title = {Development and Pilot Evaluation of a Standardized and Accessible Rubric (OMNI) for Assessing Generative AI in Health Care Contexts: Four-Stage Mixed Methods Study},
journal = {Journal of Medical Internet Research},
year = {2026},
volume = {28},
pages = {e100531--e100531},
doi = {10.2196/100531}
}
EUVIMED