“Conceived by the Holy Spirit and Born […]”: Filioque or Spirituque? A Study on the Interrelationship between the Son and the Holy Spirit
The Society of Theology and Thought · 30.06.2026 · 94 · 224-285
DOI: 10.21731/ctat.2026.94.224 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift The Society of Theology and Thought, online erschienen am 30.06.2026. Verfasst von Sunghun Ha.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The history of division between the Eastern and Western Churches, including the mutual anathemas that endured for one millennium, has not yet achieved full doctrinal unity despite numerous modern efforts toward reconciliation. In contemporary theology, many Eastern Orthodox theologians continue to sharply identify the Filioque doctrine as a doctrinal cause of division, and criticize Western theology as “christomonism.” In response to such criticism, the Second Vatican Council addressed the issue through numerous references to the Holy Spirit, and in the post-conciliar period many new studies on pneumatology emerged within the Roman Catholic Church. In particular, theologians such as Yves Congar, François-Xavier Durrwell, Louis Bouyer, Heribert Mühlen, Hans Urs von Balthasar, and Jürgen Moltmann have undertaken profound studies on the relationship between the Holy Spirit and Christ. In the East as well, eminent theologians including Vladimir Lossky, Sergei Bulgakov, John Zizioulas, Paul Evdokimov, and Dumitru Stăniloae have brought renewed attention to the Eastern Orthodox tradition and offered theological perspectives that had long been neglected in the West. This article aims to present in-depth the objections to the Filioque commonly raised by these Eastern theologians and, by introducing the corresponding or critical responses of Western theologians, to move toward a broader understanding of the “relationality” within the Trinity. Eastern Orthodox theologians argue that the Western Filioque represents a theological move that compromises the Father’s “unique sourcehood” (Monarchia) and that the unilateral alteration of the Creed by the West disrupted the unity of the Church. In pursuit of ecclesial unity, many Western theologians have largely acknowledged the unilateral character of the Filioque’s insertion and have made various efforts to seek a deeper common understanding with the East regarding the procession of the Holy Spirit. In particular, this study presents numerous theories developed on both sides concerning the “mutual relationality” of the divine persons of the Trinity. Rather than viewing the Filioque as expressing a one-directional relational flow from the Son to the Holy Spirit, it explores various proposals suggesting that the Holy Spirit also participates in or accompanies the Son’s generation, or even “enfolds” that generation as a womb enfolding a child. By examining such theories, this study investigates new possibilities for re- conciliation or unity with the East beyond the framework of the Filioque.
Zitieren
APA
Ha, S. (2026). “Conceived by the Holy Spirit and Born […]”: Filioque or Spirituque? A Study on the Interrelationship between the Son and the Holy Spirit. The Society of Theology and Thought, 94, 224-285. https://doi.org/10.21731/ctat.2026.94.224
Vancouver
Ha S. “Conceived by the Holy Spirit and Born […]”: Filioque or Spirituque? A Study on the Interrelationship between the Son and the Holy Spirit. The Society of Theology and Thought. 2026;94:224-285. doi:10.21731/ctat.2026.94.224
BibTeX
@article{Ha2026,
author = {Ha, Sunghun},
title = {“Conceived by the Holy Spirit and Born […]”: Filioque or Spirituque? A Study on the Interrelationship between the Son and the Holy Spirit},
journal = {The Society of Theology and Thought},
year = {2026},
volume = {94},
pages = {224--285},
doi = {10.21731/ctat.2026.94.224}
}
EUVIMED