The legal system of real estate and its components
Pravovedenie · 2026 · 70 (1) · 40-66
DOI: 10.21638/spbu25.2026.103 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Pravovedenie, 2026. Verfasst von Irina A. Emelkina.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Real estate occupies a central place in the system of civil rights objects in most legal systems. Since the revival of real estate in Russian civil legislation, efforts have been constantly underway to improve this legal category, and the issues related to the legal system of real estate are discussed in doctrine. A number of controversial aspects require analysis. The use of a comparative method, analysis, synthesis, and communication allowed us to formulate a number of new provisions that develop the doctrine of real estate law and justify the need to amend current legislation. The approach that understands real estate as a special legal system of things is supported, and the advantages of this approach compared to the concept of real estate as a corporeal thing are substantiated. It is argued that considering real estate as a legal system of things creates additional guarantees for the development of the principle of contribution in relation to real estate and also helps prevent attempts by public sectors to use real estate regulations for public purposes (including taxation) without considering the specifics of civil law regulation. It is argued that the concept of real estate as a legal regime will allow for the establishment of legal conditions for the introduction of a “single real estate object” regime — a land plot and objects firmly connected to it, physically and legally, which should be recognized as its constituent parts when the owner of the land plot and the building or structure constructed on it coincide. The issue of “construction on someone else’s land” is examined, and it is proposed that, in the event of a discrepancy between the owner of the plot and the owner of the building, the right of development should be secured according to the model of superficies. It is argued that in such a situation, buildings on someone else’s land become an integral part of a unified development right and, as such, possess a common property-law regime, become objects of civil transactions, and can be subject to mortgages. It is demonstrated that the right of ownership of residential premises (apartments and rooms within an apartment) and non-residential premises, due to the specific nature of the property (premises) as a separate part of a building, has a complex structure and, in turn, consists of an inseparable triad of property rights held by the owner of the apartment and other premises: a share in the common ownership of the land plot; a share in the common property of the building, including an apartment building; and the right to the premises as a space physically separate from other premises.
Zitieren
APA
Emelkina, I. A. (2026). The legal system of real estate and its components. Pravovedenie, 70(1), 40-66. https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu25.2026.103
Vancouver
Emelkina IA. The legal system of real estate and its components. Pravovedenie. 2026;70(1):40-66. doi:10.21638/spbu25.2026.103
BibTeX
@article{Emelkina2026,
author = {Emelkina, Irina A.},
title = {The legal system of real estate and its components},
journal = {Pravovedenie},
year = {2026},
volume = {70},
number = {1},
pages = {40--66},
doi = {10.21638/spbu25.2026.103}
}
EUVIMED