The Constitutional Value of Fair Competition and the Organization and Functions of Fair Trade Commission
European Constitutional Law Association · 30.04.2026 · 50 · 33-72
DOI: 10.21592/eucj.2026.50.33 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift European Constitutional Law Association, online erschienen am 30.04.2026. Verfasst von Jong Hyun Hong.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This paper aims to clarify the constitutional meaning and value of “fair and free competition,” which serves as the core legislative purpose of the Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trade Act, and to systematically examine the constitutional requirements concerning the organization, composition, and operation of the Korea Fair Trade Commission (KFTC), against the backdrop of ongoing discussions regarding the expansion of its personnel and organizational structure. First, this paper confirms that competition is not merely confined to the economic order but constitutes a foundational principle underlying the entire democratic constitutional order. Even though competition is not explicitly stipulated in the Constitution, it is understood as an inherent constitutional principle embedded in freedom, equality, freedom of occupation, property rights, and the social market economic order. It is also closely linked to the functioning mechanisms of democracy, including the electoral system, freedom of expression, and local autonomy. Through an analysis of the Ordoliberalism of the Freiburg School and the Kantzenbach-Hoppmann debate in Germany, this paper demonstrates that “free and fair competition” transcends a mere economic policy objective and constitutes a concept with normative value in the narrow sense. Furthermore, by categorizing and analyzing the decisions of the Korean Constitutional Court, this paper establishes that “free and fair competition” can be invoked as an independent standard of constitutional review based on Article 119 of the Constitution, serves as a consideration in proportionality assessments, and holds the status of a fundamental right. This paper sequentially examines the constitutional requirements of independence, expertise, democratic legitimacy, and accountability as they pertain to the organization and composition of the KFTC. In particular, it points out that the current structure of the KFTC is burdened with a structural problem in which its quasi-judicial adjudicative function is entangled with its policy function as a central administrative agency under the executive branch. It further argues that the failure to separate the investigative function from the adjudicative function creates tension with the principle of due process of law. As remedial measures, the paper proposes strengthening accountability and expertise by converting all commissioner positions to full-time status, enhancing the democratic legitimacy of the appointment process, achieving a substantive separation between the investigative and adjudicative functions, ensuring compliance with the due process principle in administrative investigation procedures, and improving judicial remedy procedures. Finally, through an analysis of the German Federal Court of Justice's ruling in the Meta Platforms (Facebook) case and the judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), the paper demonstrates that the interface between competition law and fundamental rights — including the right to informational self-determination — is expanding in the era of digital platforms. It emphasizes that “fair and free competition” must evolve into a framework of comprehensive balancing of interests that considers not only the freedom of competition of business operators but also the freedom of choice and decision-making autonomy of consumers. This framework should serve as the starting point for a dynamic interpretation of the liberal democratic constitutional order and the restructuring of rational economic regulatory administration, functioning as a self-regulating mechanism of the constitutional order.
Zitieren
APA
Hong, J. H. (2026). The Constitutional Value of Fair Competition and the Organization and Functions of Fair Trade Commission. European Constitutional Law Association, 50, 33-72. https://doi.org/10.21592/eucj.2026.50.33
Vancouver
Hong JH. The Constitutional Value of Fair Competition and the Organization and Functions of Fair Trade Commission. European Constitutional Law Association. 2026;50:33-72. doi:10.21592/eucj.2026.50.33
BibTeX
@article{Hong2026,
author = {Hong, Jong Hyun},
title = {The Constitutional Value of Fair Competition and the Organization and Functions of Fair Trade Commission},
journal = {European Constitutional Law Association},
year = {2026},
volume = {50},
pages = {33--72},
doi = {10.21592/eucj.2026.50.33}
}
EUVIMED