The Digital Transformation of Human Dignity and Data Personality Rights
European Constitutional Law Association · 30.04.2026 · 50 · 103-129
DOI: 10.21592/eucj.2026.50.103 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift European Constitutional Law Association, online erschienen am 30.04.2026. Verfasst von heuiok Lee.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
In the era of Artificial Intelligence (AI), data concerning individuals is no longer merely objective information decoupled from the subject. Data reprocessed through continuous collection and manipulation by AI constitutes a so-called “Digital Persona,” projecting an individual’s intimate psychological, social, and relational attributes, as well as future behavioral patterns. While the traditional right to informational self-determination focused on security and defense—namely, preventing the leakage and misuse of personal information—the AI environment necessitates an evolution toward “Data Personality Rights.” These rights serve as a response to “predictive privacy harm,” wherein an individual’s life is predefined by the technological power of the state or corporations. Data personality rights should be defined as substantive rights—specifically, the right to choose or intervene in AI-generated outcomes—to ensure that the algorithmic environment defining the individual does not distort or manipulate their personality. This shift is fundamentally supported by the “free manifestation of personality” guaranteed under the human dignity clause of Article 10 of the Constitution of the Republic of Korea. Since the Roman era, “dignity” has been employed as rhetoric to justify individual political decisions; today, courts invoke dignity either to protect individual autonomy or to limit it in favor of communal interests. Consequently, despite its constitutional and international stature, dignity is sometimes criticized as an “empty shell” that can be weaponized to sacrifice the individual to the logic of the state community. Nevertheless, dignity remains a vital concept through which humanity shares absolute intrinsic value, autonomy, and community values. Among these, “intrinsic value” and “autonomy” serve as core indices of self-determination in response to AI-driven decisions and fall within the protected ambit of human dignity. The right to self-determination can only become a substantive right when it is established as a constitutional fundamental right—the final bulwark against machine-led decision-making—rather than a mere legislative favor. To this end, human dignity in the AI era must perform a dual function: strengthening individual self-determination while simultaneously checking the pervasive paternalism of the state. While traditional informational self-determination remained a passive defense for controlling information flow, the contemporary right to self-determination regarding AI outcomes requires elements of “positive liberty.” Furthermore, the principle of proportionality used for balancing human dignity against specific fundamental rights requires supplementation. Legislatively, this may include: prohibiting automated classification that stigmatizes individuals(such as social scoring) or algorithmic processing that objectifies humans; restricting indiscriminate real-time data processing; and integrating Fundamental Rights Impact Assessments(FRIA), independent prior controls, and the rights to explanation, objection, and compensation into AI service terms, contracts, and operating policies for both public and private sectors.
Zitieren
APA
Lee, H. (2026). The Digital Transformation of Human Dignity and Data Personality Rights. European Constitutional Law Association, 50, 103-129. https://doi.org/10.21592/eucj.2026.50.103
Vancouver
Lee H. The Digital Transformation of Human Dignity and Data Personality Rights. European Constitutional Law Association. 2026;50:103-129. doi:10.21592/eucj.2026.50.103
BibTeX
@article{Lee2026,
author = {Lee, heuiok},
title = {The Digital Transformation of Human Dignity and Data Personality Rights},
journal = {European Constitutional Law Association},
year = {2026},
volume = {50},
pages = {103--129},
doi = {10.21592/eucj.2026.50.103}
}
EUVIMED