Utopia or a Thought Experiment? Rereading Plato’s Republic Through a Critique of Anachronism
Journal of Engineering and Philosophy · 12.03.2026 · 7 (14) · 12-23
DOI: 10.20897/isophos/18443 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Engineering and Philosophy, erschienen am 12.03.2026. Verfasst von Neslihan Köşger. Die Arbeit nennt 28 Literaturangaben.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This article examines whether Plato’s Republic can be properly interpreted as a utopia, arguing that such a reading involves a methodological anachronism. The concept of utopia, which emerged in early modern political thought, is often retrospectively applied to Plato’s ideal polis, leading to interpretations that overlook the philosophical function of the Republic. This study proposes that the Republic should instead be understood as an epistemological thought experiment aimed at clarifying the nature of justice rather than as a concrete political blueprint. By analysing the structural analogy between the soul and the city, as well as the role of the philosopher-king, the article demonstrates that Plato’s primary concern is not the construction of an ideal society but the conditions under which justice can be known and articulated. From this perspective, the ideal city functions as a normative and heuristic model rather than a utopian project. The article concludes that reading the Republic as a utopia risks obscuring its epistemological and ethical dimensions, and that a non-anachronistic interpretation allows for a more coherent understanding of Plato’s philosophical aims.
Zitieren
APA
Köşger, N. (2026). Utopia or a Thought Experiment? Rereading Plato’s Republic Through a Critique of Anachronism. Journal of Engineering and Philosophy, 7(14), 12-23. https://doi.org/10.20897/isophos/18443
Vancouver
Köşger N. Utopia or a Thought Experiment? Rereading Plato’s Republic Through a Critique of Anachronism. Journal of Engineering and Philosophy. 2026;7(14):12-23. doi:10.20897/isophos/18443
BibTeX
@article{Kger2026,
author = {Köşger, Neslihan},
title = {Utopia or a Thought Experiment? Rereading Plato’s Republic Through a Critique of Anachronism},
journal = {Journal of Engineering and Philosophy},
year = {2026},
volume = {7},
number = {14},
pages = {12--23},
doi = {10.20897/isophos/18443}
}
EUVIMED