EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

Chaos as Ecological and Autochthonous Expression: An Ecocritical Study of La vorágine

Danion L Doman

The Coastal Review · 2011

DOI: 10.20429/cr.2011.030305 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift The Coastal Review, 2011. Verfasst von Danion L Doman.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

This article utilizes principles of ecological criticism to provide new readings of both the role and presentation of nature in José Eustasio Rivera’s novel La vorágine. Whereas critics have heretofore focused on Rivera’s memorable subjective descriptions of the Amazon jungle, the present study foregrounds the rich diversity of the real organisms represented in these depictions. In addition, this essay explores the connections between the text’s core trope, chaos, and the current ecological and social scientific understanding of the ecology and the human history of the Amazon Basin. José Eustasio Rivera’s only novel, La vorágine [The Vortex] (1924), has much to offer the ecological critic, due to its interesting, varied, and contradictory perspectives on nature, ranging from the mimetic to the symbolic. Despite the fertile ground that Rivera’s text offers the ecocritic, to date only Jennifer L. French has produced an ecocritical analysis of the text. The perspectives provided by ecological approaches to literary studies can refresh the scholarship of well-known texts by both providing new insights and rejuvenating established interpretations. As a case in point, scholars have traditionally focused on Rivera’s striking subjective portrayals of nature in La vorágine. Lydia de León Hazera, for example, in her foundational study of the text, argues that the reason for the novel’s warm reception among an international readership is its combination of social denunciation and “una descripción subjetiva de la región selvática sudamericana” (121). This fixation on the subjective aspects of nature in the novel has obscured the text’s remarkable display of the ecological realities of Amazonia. One of the main purposes of this study is to foreground the neglected objective aspects of the Neotropical forest described in La vorágine. In addition, I will reframe the discussion of several of the novel’s themes that have interested readers since its publication, such as human and environmental degradation, and gendering the landscape, by employing several of the major standpoints within the field of environmental literary criticism. Finally, this essay will explore the ecological and social scientific ramifications of the novel’s central trope, dynamic chaos, symbolized by the vortex. The text’s subjective ‘ecology of chaos’ resonates with current attitudes and theories of ecology and also of the social sciences, with regard to nature in general and the Amazon in particular. La vorágine provides a clear early-twentieth century snapshot of the alteration of the forest for economic gain, with its accompanying social cost. However, rather than constituting an historical, social and ecological anomaly, at the time of the novel’s publication, rubber tapping in Amazonia was simply the latest picture in the broad historical panorama of a biogeographical region defined by kaleidoscopic change. Exploring the role of nature in a literary text, or analyzing images of ecological or biological processes in any text—be it literary or non-literary—is termed ecological 1 Doman: Chaos as Ecological and Autochthonous Expression Published by Digital Commons@Georgia Southern, 2015 criticism. Although it was initially seen as lacking theoretical rigor, and has experienced growing pains, ecocriticism is currently a burgeoning field within Anglo American literary studies, while it is a comparative seedling in the field of Hispanic literary studies. The publication of Cheryl Glotfelty and Harold Fromm’s 1996 anthology titled The Ecocriticism Reader represents a high-water mark in the history of ecological criticism. According to Glotfelty, “simply put, ecocriticism is the study of the relationship between literature and the physical environment” (xviii). She further states that “ecocriticism takes an earth-centered approach to literary studies” (xviii). Although Glotfelty’s definition remains viable today, many ecological critics subsequently expanded her initial statement, typically making it more inclusive, but in some cases narrowing its focus. As alluded to previously, ecocriticism is much less visible in Hispanic literature, despite a corpus of literary works that provides fertile ground for the ecological critic. However, ecological criticism of Hispanic literature has steadily increased in the last decade, and appears poised to enjoy wider acceptance. Two recently-published collections centering on ecocriticism in Hispanic literature evidence this growing validation. The Natural World in Latin American Literatures: Ecocritical Essays on Twentieth Century Writings (2010) traces the role of nature within Latin American literature, contextualizes ecocriticism within Spanish American fiction, and provides a compilation of ecocritical analyses of several canonical texts, including a study by Raymond L. Williams of nature in Cien años de soledad. Ecocríticas. Literatura y medio ambiente, also published in 2010, is a collection of theoretical essays, centering on ecofeminism. Ecocritics who work with Latin American literature typically apply the theoretical apparatus and terminology of ecocritical studies in English to literature in Spanish and Portuguese that has an ecological bent. However, ecocriticism will come of age in Latin American literature as we develop more autochthonous theoretical approaches, tailored to fit the socio-cultural and ecological realities of Latin America and Spain. Three statements in La vorágine reflect current mainstream environmental attitudes, making them of interest to the ecological critic. While they may not appear revelatory in isolation, when we consider that the text was published in the 1920s, these comments are noteworthy because of how accurately they reflect a contemporary rhetoric of environmentalism. ‘Environmentalists’ can be defined as “the very broad range of people who are concerned about environmental issues such as global warming and pollution, but who wish to maintain or improve their standard of living as conventionally defined, and who would not welcome radical social change” (Garrard 23). The text’s first geocentric message is expressed by Clemente Silva, a rubbertapper in the novel whose symbolic last name conveys his closeness to ‘la selva.’ When Arturo Cova, the protagonist, and his party encounter Silva, whose legs are full of leech-induced sores, his simultaneous personification of the jungle and characterization of its exploiters as “executioners” neatly summarizes the novel’s thesis and foreshadows the text’s famous concluding line: “la selva se defiende de sus verdugos, y al fin el hombre resulta vencido” (244). Fittingly, Silva’s pronouncement comes from the perspective of the forest. Later in the novel, upon the death of El Cayeno, the narrator condemns the despotic forces of greed and capitalism, that “foreign invaders” like El Cayeno symbolize, with this proto-environmental critique of 2 The Coastal Review: An Online Peer-reviewed Journal, Vol. 3 [2015], Iss. 3, Art. 5 https://digitalcommons.georgiasouthern.edu/thecoastalreview/vol3/iss3/5 DOI: 10.20429/cr.2011.030305 the destruction of both native vegetation and native cultures: “¡Así murió aquel extranjero, aquel invasor, que en los lindes patrios taló las selvas, mató los indios, esclavizó a mis compatriotas!” (379) Due to an overt ‘save-the-rainforest’ message, the third statement appears anachronistic. The statement is the concluding thought of a contradictory passage that both praises and denounces ‘civilized man’, whom the narrator dubs ‘the hero of destruction’ (297) as he leaves his mark on the jungle: “Y es de verse en algunos lugares cómo sus huellas son semejantes a los aludes: los caucheros que hay en Colombia destruyen anualmente millones de árboles. En los territorios de Venezuela el balatá desapareció. De esta suerte ejercen el fraude contra las generaciones del porvenir” (298). Revealing a conservation mentality that wouldn’t appear until decades later, this clairvoyant statement combines a three-pronged critique of erosion due to deforestation, the extinction of a species of rubber tree, and mismanagement of resources, with its accompanying negative impact on future generations. The conservationist message articulated through the combination of these three scattered environmentalist moments in the novel would find full expression decades later in the personage of Chico Mendes, the Brazilian rubber-tapper turned environmental activist. In addition to these relatively few but obvious mainstream environmentalist passages in the novel, the text also evidences clearly discernible patterns of more radical environmentalism. Jennifer French has argued that the text resonates “with the most radical environmentalism of the early twenty-first century” (153). From an ecocritical perspective, Rivera’s novel can be described as a fictional treatise on the deleterious effects of capitalist-driven societal pressures on both northern Amazonia and its human inhabitants, focusing specifically on the rubber-tapping industry. Rivera himself vigorously pushed this interpretation of the novel after its publication, and his nonliterary writings clearly explain the ecological hazards presented by the rubber industry (French 148). Several strands of current ecocritical thought can be lifted from this reading of the novel, including deep ecology, ecofeminism, and social ecology. These three positions are viewed as ‘radical,’ on the broad continuum of environmental sensitivity, running from no awareness or concern to acute awareness and extreme concern, with environmentalism roughly occupying the middle ground. Underlying each of these stances is the implicit understanding, and in most cases the critique of, “the anthropocentric dualism humanity/nature as the ultimate source of anti-ecological beliefs and practices” (Garrard 23). Of the three previously mentioned radical positions, social ecology and ecofeminism are the most readily applicable

Zitieren

APA

Doman, D. L. (2011). Chaos as Ecological and Autochthonous Expression: An Ecocritical Study of La vorágine. The Coastal Review. https://doi.org/10.20429/cr.2011.030305

Vancouver

Doman DL. Chaos as Ecological and Autochthonous Expression: An Ecocritical Study of La vorágine. The Coastal Review. 2011. doi:10.20429/cr.2011.030305

BibTeX
@article{Doman2011,
  author = {Doman, Danion L},
  title = {Chaos as Ecological and Autochthonous Expression: An Ecocritical Study of La vorágine},
  journal = {The Coastal Review},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.20429/cr.2011.030305}
}
Kostenlos starten →