Writing the Female Body in Alvarez's In the Time of the Butterflies
The Coastal Review · 2011
DOI: 10.20429/cr.2011.030102 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift The Coastal Review, 2011. Verfasst von Darren K. Broome.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Julia Alvarez in In the Time of the Butterflies utilizes the female body and sexuality to combat male dominated rhetoric. The use of the female body retrieves women’s forgotten role as subjects instead of objects as seen in male-oriented novel. Expressing sexuality in a way that is determined by women, she discovers new means of verbal or written expression. The female body emerges as a form of expression in Butterflies which at times is connected to one of the characters’ revolutionary participation. How does a "body" of literature relate to a physical body? There is an intimate association between women's bodies and their voices, both having for so long been repressed and controlled by male-dominated institutions. By "finding a voice," a woman may liberate her physical power and sexuality from her internal and external repression. In the same way, through expressing her sexuality in a way that is determined by her own body and her own desire, she may discover new means of verbal or written expression. In the works of numerous women writers and theorists, it is necessary to reclaim the body in order to establish a voice. We can say that through embodiment comes empowerment. The essence of the female body emerges as a form of expression in Butterflies which at times is connected to one of the character's revolutionary participation. In Alvarez's text, the potential for giving life and taking it away are apparent in the physical aspects of the female body, such as menstruation, pregnancy and sexuality, which will be topics of discussion. The bodily existence of the Mirabal sisters can be related to Michel Foucault's notion of the "body politic," which he defines as "a set of material elements and techniques that serve as weapons, relays, communication routes and supports for the power and knowledge that invest human bodies and subjugate them by turning them into objects of knowledge" (28). By way of the corporeal history of the Mirabal sisters, Alvarez demonstrates the active resistance of women revolutionaries. The way the author transforms the legacy of the Mirabals' female bodies into fictionalized dialogue on the body is connected to the idea of “écriture feminine." This aspect of French Feminism supports the notion that women see their bodies as the center of consciousness. In the case of the Mirabals, their bodies are the center of political "consciousness." Margarite Fernandez Olmos comments on this "consciousness": "Firmly rooted in the consciousness of contemporary Latina authors is the idea that what is personal is also political" (45). Helene Cixous' essay "The Laugh of Medusa" argues this philosophy as well. Cixous offers a way for women to see themselves as giving birth tolanguage. In other words, women writing has less to do with language itself and more to do with how women deploy their given language. Cixous asserts that women who "write their bodies" [1] express ideas in a very different way from men, stating, "Woman must put herself into the text—as into the world and into history—by her own way" (337). Alvarez retells the Mirabals' stories through the corporeal aspects of these women and 1 Broome: Writing the Female Body Published by Digital Commons@Georgia Southern, 2015 she connects their political consciousness to their bodies. Retelling the stories of these four sisters via the female body makes the narrative both private and personal. Obviously, it is extremely difficult to encapsulate neatly all of the theories of a "feminine writing." The theories themselves are often free-flowing and disruptive in their language, and each highlights the impossibility of definition. Such theories have been criticized as much as they have been celebrated. What becomes more problematic is that the majority of critical work on feminine studies has been conducted by French and North American critics. In Reading the Body Politic, Amy Kaminsky writes: The apparently politically neutral psychoanalytical and semiotic criticism that has been called French feminism is useful on only up to a point in creating a Latin American feminist analysis. The emphasis on being embodied, and even 'writing the body,' can be liberating for women as writers and readers, but what can happen to women's bodies in politically repressive regimes is hardly the jouissance that Helene Cixous had in mind. (23) Certainly Kaminsky's point is one that must be kept in mind, and the unquestioning applications of theories that are linguistically and historically foreign to Latin American texts is indeed a disservice. I am not arguing that such theories have no place in the critical strategies for the study of Latin American women writers. However, the incidents of violence in Latin America are extreme and singular cases. "Female writers in Latin America had to confront the problem of surviving as individuals in a society that has traditionally been among the most restrictive regarding appropriate social roles for women, where those who defied convention often suffered dire consequences" (Fernández Olmos, 23). Alvarez undoubtedly “defies convention” as she constructs the female body as a vehicle for empowerment, voice, and ultimately, change. One way Alvarez demonstrates the history of the Mirabals is by illustrating the gynecological changes of the sisters. Throughout the novel, changes in political events in the Dominican Republic seem to coincide with the changes occurring in the bodies of the Mirabal sisters. She illustrates that pregnancy and childbirth have several meanings. In her novel Alvarez shows the real potential of women through the material body enabling women to be seen as active revolutionaries. Due to the fact that all of the sisters except for Dede narrate in first person, they are allowed to speak candidly about their intimate thoughts. The political coming of age or consciousness of the next to oldest sister, Minerva, comes with the onset of menstruation occurring when her boarding school friend, Sinita, informs her that Trujillo had some of her family members murdered. Minerva states, "As I came fully awake, I felt the damp sheet under me. I lifted the covers, and for a moment, I couldn't make sense of the dark stains on the bottom sheet. Then I brought up my hand from checking myself. Sure enough, my complications had started" (20). Minerva's discharge represents the spilling of waste matter. We can correlate her menses with Trujillo murdering citizens who oppose his doctrines for Trujillo looks down at them as trash or 2 The Coastal Review: An Online Peer-reviewed Journal, Vol. 3 [2015], Iss. 1, Art. 2 https://digitalcommons.georgiasouthern.edu/thecoastalreview/vol3/iss1/2 DOI: 10.20429/cr.2011.030102 waste. Fernando Valerio Holguin supports the idea that the female body manifests itself as a form of political resistance in saying: "El acceso a la conciencia política coincide con la transformación de su cuerpo. La sangre de la menstruación deMinerva queda vinculada no solo con la violación sino también con la violencia como crítica feminista al patriarcado trujillista" (96). Menstruation does not ordinarily figure in either idealized or earthly erotic descriptions of the female body; it is usually one aspect of women's sexuality of no interest to men. In other words, the female body can be read as an allegory of political resistance and enacts a "writing the body" as an act of resistance to patriarchal law. Debra Walter King in her essay "Writing in Red Ink" writes about resistance and liberation as it appears in the fiction of black women writers. She points out that "This spilling of blood intensifies moments of liberation and is often its prerequisite" (57). Another reference to menstruation suggests both solidarity and resistance: Maria Teresa comments that while in prison, "almost everyone has stopped menstruating" (240). The political activity of the members of the movement has stopped since they are incarcerated, but one can understand the cessation of menstruation of the incarcerated women as a political act since it can be read as an allegory of the political situation of the underground movement. Shortly after Minerva and Maria Teresa are released from prison, Minerva visits Delia, a movement member, who is a gynecologist. Minerva makes this visit with the pretext of discussing her menstrual problems. Again, the female body becomes an allegory of the political situation. 'Delia is a female doctor and we have plenty of reason to see her. Neither Mate nor I had had a period for two months.' Delia was nervous as she let us into her small office, her eyes full of signals. 'We came about our cycles,' I began, searching the wall for the telltale rod. Whatever it was, all the SIM got at first was an earful about our women problems. Delia relaxed, thinking that was truly why we were here. Until I concluded a little too unmetaphorically, 'So is there any activity in our old cells?' 'A few of them are still active, to be sure. But more importantly, new cells are filling in all the time. You need to give your bodies a rest. You should see menstrual activity by the beginning of next year. (270) This conversation between Minerva and the gynecologist has both a metaphorical and literal meaning. Minerva has to speak in her code language about female problems even though she is there in the doctor's office to discuss the issue of "cells" which refer to revolutionary activists. Obviously the "cells" and "systems" refer to active participants of the underground movement which Minerva helped form. While at times the body politic functions at an unconscious level for the sisters, other times they will consciously utilize this body function as discourse for revolution. While visiting with the female doctor, Minerva and Maria Teresa use a disguised discourse about female problems to speak of revolutionary activities. This gynecological discourse-vaginal secretions, breast milk, and menstrual blood that emanate from a woman's body-
Zitieren
APA
Broome, D. K. (2011). Writing the Female Body in Alvarez's In the Time of the Butterflies. The Coastal Review. https://doi.org/10.20429/cr.2011.030102
Vancouver
Broome DK. Writing the Female Body in Alvarez's In the Time of the Butterflies. The Coastal Review. 2011. doi:10.20429/cr.2011.030102
BibTeX
@article{Broome2011,
author = {Broome, Darren K.},
title = {Writing the Female Body in Alvarez's In the Time of the Butterflies},
journal = {The Coastal Review},
year = {2011},
doi = {10.20429/cr.2011.030102}
}
EUVIMED