Absolute Seduction: The Faustian Motif in Balzac and Valéry
The Coastal Review · 2008
DOI: 10.20429/cr.2008.020105 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift The Coastal Review, 2008. Verfasst von Scott Shinabargar.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This article analyzes ways in which the "quest for the absolute" is treated in two works: Balzac's novel, of the same name (La Recherche de l'absolu), and Valéry's Monsieur Teste. Both texts involve a paradoxical narrative device, by which the genius of the protagonist is communicated to the reader, not by the representation of his thoughts, but by a veiling of them--an impenetrable interiority that suggests communion with the absolute. This device is successful, to the degree that it plays upon our own desires for transcendent knowledge. Under closer scrutiny, however, we find that such texts must eventually involve a moment of violence; a disruption of the spell these "cerebral heroes" have cast. The Faust myth becomes especially pertinent in the modern era, as existing paradigms for thought are called into question. The hubris of the German scholar, daring to turn against God for the sake of absolute knowledge, resonates with the experience of freedom – the sense of both possible success and failure –as beliefs and institutions of the past are challenged by an increasingly rational, secular world. This character type becomes a prominent and often central figure of Balzac’s novels in particular. [1] Characters with an excessive passion, a desire to transcend the limitations of society and even life itself have the same effect as Milton’s Lucifer: while they are eventually resolved into the essentially Christian moral teleology of the work, they are essential to the dynamic structure of the text, and indeed, are often more attractive than their “good” counterparts (one thinks of Vautrin, in particular). [2] But beyond this reaction to the intellectual and spiritual crisis of the times –a gesture with which Balzac precedes Dostoyevsky, among others– the use of such characters, with their Promethean fate, corresponds to another, self-reflexive element of Balzac’s work. Like Flaubert, the novelist had come to reject certain Romantic tendencies embraced in his youth. The emotional excess and nostalgia for idealized, absolute states of being, are replaced by a world-view firmly rooted in the real, and a recognition of its limits. The eventual failure of the Faustian characters in his novels is thus not simply a result of the writer’s political and religious conservatism, but can be seen as deriving from his own experience as a creator. So that, in elaborating the narrative life of a character such as Balthazar Claës, with his excessive striving and ultimate failure, Balzac is addressing, or “working through,” in psychoanalytic terms, his own temptations as an artist. Paul Valéry will also explore the Faust figure later, at the turn of the 19 century, though from a more modern perspective, as one might expect. [3] Monsieur Teste does not strive to understand and manipulate some absolute principle of external reality, but the very source at which reality is perceived and conceptualized: the mind. But Teste also differs from Balzac’s protagonist, in that he would seem to have actually attained a 1 Shinabargar: Absolute Seduction: The Faustian Motif in Balzac and Valéry Published by Digital Commons@Georgia Southern, 2015 certain knowledge of the absolute in question. Admittedly, this absolute is hardly that aspired to by Balthazar Claës in his scientific experiments. Indeed, not only is Teste uninterested in striving after some absolute principle in the physical world, but the purely interior, intellectual absolute he is concerned with is attained, paradoxically, in not being attained. If he has achieved mastery of a certain truth, it is in continually moving beyond the reification of his own thought process--the sediment which only appears to be the Truth. An admiring narrator observes: Il était l’être absorbé dans son système, celui qui se livre tout entier à la discipline effrayante de l’esprit libre, et qui fait tuer ses joies par ses joies, la plus faible par la plus forte, — la plus douce, la temporelle, celle de l’instant et d‘heure commencé, par la fondamentale — par l’espoir de la fondamentale (21). And Teste himself claims: “Je n’apprécie en toute chose que la facilité ou la difficulté de la connaître, de les accomplir. Je mets un soin extrême à mesurer ces degrés, et à ne pas m’attacher” (22-3). If Valéry has recognized a certain modern (indeed Postmodern) truth, however --that there are in fact no stable truths-I would suggest that he nonetheless succumbs to the hubris of Faust, even if his protagonist does not appear to. For he needs to at least suggest, perhaps due to his own, narcissistic identification with this fantastic, idealized character, that such a being is possible; that the apparent limitations of reality could in fact be transcended. If Teste’s attainment of the absolute can never realistically be enacted or represented in the world of the text, it can nonetheless be validated indirectly, by the testament of other characters—those who attest to perceiving this greatness through their powerful, if vague feelings. Witnesses, that is to say, who are decidedly Romantic. Initially, the two texts share a number of elements in their interpretation of the Faust character. Most notably, that of excessive interiority and absorption in the Self, and a consequent separation and alienation from others. When we are first introduced to Balthazar Claës, for instance, his description functions less to create an image of his outward physical appearance, than to suggest what exists, otherwise invisible to others, beneath the surface: il regardait dans l’espace comme pour y trouver la réalisation de ses espérances [...]. Les sentiments profonds qui animent les grands hommes respiraient dans ce pâle visage fortement sillonné de rides [...] maissurtout dans ces yeux étincelants dont le feu semblait également accru par la chasteté que donne la tyrannie des idées, et par le foyer intérieur d’une vaste intelligence (43). 2 The Coastal Review: An Online Peer-reviewed Journal, Vol. 2 [2015], Iss. 1, Art. 5 https://digitalcommons.georgiasouthern.edu/thecoastalreview/vol2/iss1/5 DOI: 10.20429/cr.2008.020105 This interiorizing of the subject is even more extreme in the case of Valéry’s protagonist. And what is significant, as we shall soon see, the more the subject is confined to this inner world of ideas, the more the nature of his superhuman character becomes vague, if not incomprehensible [...] and at the same time, hyperbolized. As Mme Teste explains to the narrator: “il ne lit presque rien de ses yeux, dont il fait un usage étrange et comme intérieur. Je me trompe, je veuxdire: un usage particulier. Mais ce n’est pas cela du tout. Je ne sais pas comment m’exprimer; mettons à la fois intérieur, particulier [...] et universel!!!” (38). Christiane Vogel identifies this extreme interiority as a defining trait in a series of "héros cérébrales," originating in the work of Poe and continuing through that of French Symbolists, Villiers de L'Isle-d'Adam, Huysmans and Rémy de Gourmont, among others. In such texts she locates "un schème essentiel qui veut que la présentation de notre héros l'éloigne du lecteur, que l'on estompe son visage alors qu'on prétend le dessiner. A cet égard, le premier point quiretienne l'attention est la présentation indirecte du héros" (253-4). While this lack of access to such characters' thoughts and feelings is to a certain degree determined by their nature in the world of the text --the Faustian "orgueil" andonanistic "délices," of the following passage [4]-it is also determined, to a great extent, by the reality of the text--the limitations, that is to say, which are imposed upon representation in the face of the absolute: le héros cérébral [...] est essentiellement celui qui se retranche avec orgueil et délices dans son univers mental. Pour lui, le monde n'existe que réfléchi par le miroir unique de son esprit. Ses pouvoirs demeurentcachés et même virtuels par une sorte de nécessité; son action, qu'une pente fatale change en passion, reste éminemment intérieure" (252, emphasis mine); "(un) héros surhumain dont la nature exige qu'il serende invisible" (261). In the perspective of the present study, however, the "necessity" imposed upon the text by historical circumstances (the convergence of a pre-modern, fantastical character, and the emergence of Realism following the Enlightenment) is less significant than the potential effect/affect that accompanies such a device. It is important to note the second part of the above observation: "le premier point qui retienne l'attention est la présentation indirecte du héros." For the veiled nature of such characters is not merely one curious attribute among many, imposed by the logic of and within the text, but a "fundamental structure" (253) that is highly motivated by the writer's desire to orient the reader's reception of such characters. In the Cahiers of André Walter, for example, Vogel observes: "les images du repli progressif de ce héros cérébral, bien loin de désigner négativement un être ineffable et de défier un regard étranger, doivent au contraireamener le lecteur à ce «sympathein» qui est [...] une note fondamentale des Cahiers" (263). This suggestive veiling, with its affective draw, is all the more complex in that it takes place indirectly, affecting the reader vicariously, so to speak. As mentioned above, it 3 Shinabargar: Absolute Seduction: The Faustian Motif in Balzac and Valéry Published by Digital Commons@Georgia Southern, 2015 is important to note that the greatness of these "heroes" is communicated, not by an omniscient narrator, as fact, but by an admiring character within the text: if we are not allowed to witness the workings of such great minds, we nonetheless have the sense of doing so, through the affective response of characters who are able to perceive them [...] almost. Joyce Loubère identifies this as a crucial link between Valéry's text and another of Balzac's novels, Louis Lambert, as “le principe de l’étonnement causé d
Zitieren
APA
Shinabargar, S. (2008). Absolute Seduction: The Faustian Motif in Balzac and Valéry. The Coastal Review. https://doi.org/10.20429/cr.2008.020105
Vancouver
Shinabargar S. Absolute Seduction: The Faustian Motif in Balzac and Valéry. The Coastal Review. 2008. doi:10.20429/cr.2008.020105
BibTeX
@article{Shinabargar2008,
author = {Shinabargar, Scott},
title = {Absolute Seduction: The Faustian Motif in Balzac and Valéry},
journal = {The Coastal Review},
year = {2008},
doi = {10.20429/cr.2008.020105}
}
EUVIMED