School Library Collection Policies Lack Transparency and Need Stronger Diversity Messaging
Evidence Based Library and Information Practice · 12.06.2026 · 21 (2) · 172-174
DOI: 10.18438/eblip31068 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Evidence Based Library and Information Practice, online erschienen am 12.06.2026. Verfasst von Collin Stephenson. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
A Review of: Jamison, A., & McNamara, E. (2025). Let’s talk about diversity: A content analysis of school library collection development policies. Children & Libraries, 23(1), 17. https://doi.org/10.5860/cal.23.1.17 Objective – To evaluate the public accessibility of school library collection development policies and to gauge the extent to which diversity messaging is present in those policies. Design – Mixed-methods research design using a checklist-based content analysis of school library collection development policies and inductive coding. Researchers analyzed quantitative data regarding policy availability, content analysis data of the checklist, and anecdotal data based on individual researchers’ note-taking. Setting – Public schools in McClean County and 8 bordering counties in north central Illinois. Subjects – 77 school districts, accounting for 244 public schools – 145 elementary schools, 48 junior high schools, and 51 high schools. From this pool, 16 collection policies were analyzed, representing the policies enacted at 53 schools. Methods – The researchers developed a checklist based on the Library Bill of Rights’ Interpretations for Diverse and Inclusive Collections (2006), which established a controlled vocabulary for identifying words related to diversity within the sampled collection policies. Both researchers independently analyzed the collection policies, annotating for instances of language corresponding to diversity. These independent analyses were measured for inter-rater reliability by simple percent agreement. The data from each analysis was used to identify the frequency at which a collection policy was publicly available, categorize the policies based on presence and frequency of diverse language, and finally to identify themes as they relate to the use of diversity in these policies. Main Results – Of the sampled schools, only 21% were represented by a public-facing collection development policy. These 16 policies reflected 15 district-wide policies and one individual school policy, leading the researchers to conclude a general lack of transparency regarding library collection policies in this geographic region. Within these policies, 14 were marked by a low presence of “diversity” or adjacent terms, with one policy showing a high presence, and one having no presence. The researchers found that only the high presence policy defined diversity for collection development, which suggests ineffective practices in other districts or schools. In addition to the prominence of district-wide policies, the researchers also discovered that nine of the sampled policies were identical across different districts, further contributing to a lack of specificity in diverse collections practices. The district-wide policies had not been updated for 5 years. Only 4 policies directly used the word “diversity,” and only 2 of those 4 referred to the American Library Association’s (ALA) Library Bill of Rights (2006). These findings lead the authors to additionally conclude that where policies are available, there is a lack of specificity in addressing diversity in school library collection development practices. Conclusion – Given the lack of accessibility and lack of specific, consistent inclusion of diversity terminology in this sample, the authors identify four policy implications. The researchers contend that policies should incorporate higher instances of well-defined diversity language; policies should be readily available where users are likely to find them; policies should directly incorporate language from current ALA documentation; and policies should have clear commitments to diversity and pluralistic curation practices.
Zitieren
APA
Stephenson, C. (2026). School Library Collection Policies Lack Transparency and Need Stronger Diversity Messaging. Evidence Based Library and Information Practice, 21(2), 172-174. https://doi.org/10.18438/eblip31068
Vancouver
Stephenson C. School Library Collection Policies Lack Transparency and Need Stronger Diversity Messaging. Evidence Based Library and Information Practice. 2026;21(2):172-174. doi:10.18438/eblip31068
BibTeX
@article{Stephenson2026,
author = {Stephenson, Collin},
title = {School Library Collection Policies Lack Transparency and Need Stronger Diversity Messaging},
journal = {Evidence Based Library and Information Practice},
year = {2026},
volume = {21},
number = {2},
pages = {172--174},
doi = {10.18438/eblip31068}
}
EUVIMED