A QUESTÃO DO CASTIGO E DA JUSTIÇA EM NIETZSCHE E PAUL RÉE
Instante · 27.07.2026 · 8 (1)
DOI: 10.18391/ri.v8i1.5203 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Instante, online erschienen am 27.07.2026. Verfasst von Leovan RODRIGUES NETO. Die Arbeit nennt 20 Literaturangaben.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Our aim is to analyze Nietzsche's opposition to Paul Rée regarding the origin of punishment and justice. We suspect that the divergence between the two authors occurs primarily at a methodological level, especially with respect to the use of history. More specifically, we maintain that this opposition takes place in two complementary aspects: on the one hand, in relation to the genetic character of Rée's interpretation of punishment; on the other, in relation to the absence of social asymmetry of forces in his account of the development of justice. To develop this hypothesis, the article is divided into three parts. First, we examine how the themes of punishment and justice appear in The Origins of Moral Feelings, reconstructing Rée’s argument in order to demonstrate both his conception of the original function of punishment as intimidation and his understanding of justice, as legal punishment, as a continuation of this original meaning. Second, we analyze On the Genealogy of Morals, with particular emphasis on the second essay, in which Nietzsche develops his reflection on punishment and justice more thoroughly. In addition, we consider the aphorism revisited by Nietzsche in this work and related to these themes. especially Human, all too human (92), The Wanderer and his shadow (22, 26, 36) and Daybreak (112). Finally, we return to the main aspects discussed by both authors, highlighting the fundamental differences between their interpretations as well as the meaning of Nietzsche’s critique of Rée’s historical approach.
Zitieren
APA
NETO, L. R. (2026). A QUESTÃO DO CASTIGO E DA JUSTIÇA EM NIETZSCHE E PAUL RÉE. Instante, 8(1). https://doi.org/10.18391/ri.v8i1.5203
Vancouver
NETO LR. A QUESTÃO DO CASTIGO E DA JUSTIÇA EM NIETZSCHE E PAUL RÉE. Instante. 2026;8(1). doi:10.18391/ri.v8i1.5203
BibTeX
@article{NETO2026,
author = {NETO, Leovan RODRIGUES},
title = {A QUESTÃO DO CASTIGO E DA JUSTIÇA EM NIETZSCHE E PAUL RÉE},
journal = {Instante},
year = {2026},
volume = {8},
number = {1},
doi = {10.18391/ri.v8i1.5203}
}
EUVIMED