Editorial: Information Technology for Development, Volume 32, Issue 2
Information Technology for Development · 2026 · 32 (2) · 91-97
DOI: 10.17705/1itd.032204 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Information Technology for Development, 2026. Verfasst von Silvia Masiero.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This editorial comes in the aftermath of IFIP 9.4, one of the key conferences of the ICT for Development (ICT4D) field, held at Kathmandu University in May 2026. At a time of pervasive data harm, where the technologies we study are largely used towards detrimental rather than uplifting purposes (e.g. Reichert, 2025), I was heartened to see the works presented in the conference. Topics spanning from digital community participation to social movements, climate technologies and upland development, found a shared undertone: that of rekindling with the positivity of development technologies, finding, beyond risks of harm, the beneficial purposes that information systems can yield. Presentations from many parts of the world, again celebrating the rich diversity of ICT4D, pointed to technology challenging threats such as climate change, violence and authoritarianism, while recognising – rather than silencing – the data harm scenario that we are immersed in. Keywords: ICT4D. This manuscript underwent editorial review. 1 The Possibility of Positive Development This editorial comes in the aftermath of IFIP 9.4, one of the key conferences of the ICT for Development (ICT4D) field, held at Kathmandu University in May 2026. At a time of pervasive data harm, where the technologies we study are largely used towards detrimental rather than uplifting purposes (e.g. Reichert, 2025), I was heartened to see the works presented in the conference. Topics spanning from digital community participation to social movements, climate technologies and upland development, found a shared undertone: that of rekindling with the positivity of development technologies, finding, beyond risks of harm, the beneficial purposes that information systems can yield. Presentations from many parts of the world, again celebrating the rich diversity of ICT4D, pointed to technology challenging threats such as climate change, violence and authoritarianism, while recognising – rather than silencing – the data harm scenario that we are immersed in. I find that the notion of positive development studies, recently articulated in Heeks (2025), captures powerfully the spirit of the conference. The approach of positive development studies does not ignore the fundamental contradictions, power imbalances and harm that development studies contemplate: it chooses, however, to focus on the positives, exploring “what works, what inspires, and what uplifts” (ibid., 2025). Arora (2024) had presented tech-induced despair as a privilege of communities that can afford to disengage: applied to ICT4D, a positive development vision does not silence data harm, but focuses on exploring routes that empower and uplift, overcoming systemic data injustice. Again with Heeks (2025), the approach can mean deep listening to community aspirations: aspirations that the IFIP 9.4 conference presentations have articulated in propositive ways, acknowledging data violence and proactively proposing routes to overcome it. This editorial in written in the spirit of positive development studies. With Ganapathy (2025), it leverages Glăveanu (2023) in contemplating the idea of possibility studies grounded in "the human capacity to hope, imagine, and envision new futures" (ibid., 2025). It retrieves central features of positive development in articles published in Issue 32(2), and leverages them as means to advance the ICT4D responsibility (Masiero, 2026) of recognising data harm and countering it. 2 An Epistemic Shift Again with Heeks (2025), embracing positive development studies involves rebalancing, rather than denying, the core epistemological stance of development research. While the development studies field centers on systemic problems, identifies and challenges dominating power structures, positive development leverages that knowledge to ask “not only what is wrong? but also what is right—and how can it be strengthened, shared, or scaled?» (ibid., 2025). It can be argued, with Akbari (2026), that a condition of uneven datafication sustains colonial capitalism through “differentiated dispossession and dependency across populations, spaces and classes” (ibid., 2026: 1). Seen in this light, positive development can be understood to seek to identify the drivers of uneven datafication, shifting the gaze to what counters systematic disempowering structures rather than reinforcing them. The epistemic shift from a gaze on problems to the exploration of “what works” is mirrored in the papers published in 32(2). In “Do Financial Literacy and Social Networks Enhance Inclusion Through the Use of Financial Technology?”, Wamba-Taguimdje, Kamdjoug and Bashengezi (2026) explore how financial literacy and social networks reinforce the impact of financial technology, especially mobile money, on financial inclusion. They draw on social network theory to develop what is, at its core, a “what works” paper: a model that presents the positive connections of mobile money adoption to financial inclusion, without neglecting the roadblocks that can hamper the same links. In a world where the platform surveillance risks of mobile money are well conceptualised (Martin, 2019), the article does not bypass these, but focuses on propositive connections that a positive development gaze affords to consider. A similar approach is taken in in "The Effect of Information and Communication Technologies in Decision-making on Farming Operations by Farmers: Evidence from Haryana, India". Here, Sharma, Ilavarasan, Chetri, Mioncha, Roy and Holker (2026) examine relations between farmers’ ICT use and decision-making regarding farming operations. Focusing on Haryana, a large contributor of foodgrains to India’s central pool, it finds that high-quality farming decisions are not solely mediated through ICT access, but are mediated by the social ecosystems the farmers are part of, which only partially leverage ICT in their making. In tracing positive links between access and high-quality decisions, the paper does not neglect detrimental effects, noting that ICT can amplify existing socio-economic inequalities in ways that do not benefit farmers that are in less than resourceful situations. Qualitative research from the issue shows a similar gaze. In “Responsible Digital Citizen Participation in Youth Sexual Reproductive Health Rights in Southern Africa”, Zhou, Khene and Sieborger (2026) propose key parameters to examine the nature of responsible data in digital engagement with sexual and reproductive health and rights (SRHR). Drawing on Contextual Integrity theory, the paper proposes a framework for ethical data governance in youth SRHR digital initiatives, applied to Southern Africa’s context of persisting SRH challenges. The paper’s starting point are the challenges themselves, and their persistence in spite of years of digital engagement: notwithstanding the surveillance affordances of the digital (Roberts & Oosterom, 2025), the paper centers on routes to build awareness, and protect people’s rights to SRH in a space of systemic threat. None of these papers silences the threats its core objects – mobile money, digital platforms, digital engagement technologies – can bring to recipients. But all three embrace the epistemic shift of positive development, focusing on routes through which the same objects uplift their participants, rather than disempowering them. Whether the mechanisms identified in the papers are extensible across contexts, is a different question: but the very identification of such routes, and the undertone of hope behind them, reflects the aspirational view that the notion of positive development brings. 3 Embracing Resonance In further exploring the knowledge bases of positive development, Heeks (2025) notes how such a lens would center resonance: that is seen as “connections between people, nature, and institutions that feel responsive, empowering, and life-enhancing” (ibid. 2025). By way of contrast, much development literature focuses on grasping what we could refer to as lack of resonance: institutions that do not respond, or meet the needs of people, corrupt dynamics, and outcomes that harm people and the environment (ITD has seen a spike in submissions that center the environment in their research). Research with a focus on resonance embraces, instead, how technology participates in greater connections between humans, the environment and institutions: IFIP 9.4 has seen multiple presentations on climate health projects, where data on the environment are put in relation to health and food security outcomes for people. Studying resonance does not mean presupposing its existence, but investigating the conditions for it and what needs to happen for its possible replication. Papers published in Issue 32(2) do not openly mention the concept of resonance, and yet, notions of connective rather than degenerative outcomes are present in several of the published works. In “Governing Data, Governing Power: A Framework for Participatory Data Governance in the Global South”, Wijne (2026) proposes the Participatory Data Governance (PDG) framework, which operationalises data governance into four key elements: data collection, data processing, data sharing and data use. Data governance, she argues, stems from the multiple connections across such elements: it is their connection, she continues, that shows how power relations can and do materialise into data (in)justices. It can be argued that, in Wijne’s paper, the core is how dimensions resonate with each other: data governance takes the shape of an ecosystem whose diverse parts interact, developing a shared picture of the governance phenomenon. Another paper on civic engagement sustains this lens. In “Civic Engagement in the Digital Era: The Role of E-Participation in Anti-Corruption Efforts”, Elbahnasawy and Razavi (2026) investigate the role of e-participation in anti-corruption efforts, conceptualising e-participation as an addition to the global anti-corruption toolkit. In the paper, e-participation and e-government are found to have a complementary relationship: this means that e-government enables active, integrated feedback channels of e-participation, ultimately found to produce better governance outcomes. It is once again the resonance of e-government and e-participation, rather than their dissonance, that matters to producing anti-corruption outcomes. Finally, the notion of interoperability invites reflection on the outcome of connections between different datasets. In “Bridging the Gaps: An In-depth Examination of e-Government Interoperability for Public Service Enhancement – A Case Study on Family Health Data in Yogyakarta”, Suardi, Nurmandi, Purwaningsih and Zulkifli (2026) focus on some of the core challenges posed by interoperability in the public health sector. With a case study of the family health system (KESGA) in Yogyakarta, Indonesia, they show that effective interoperability between government information systems supports improvement public service delivery: the core of the paper is however on the hows of pursuing effective interoperability, which depends on the lived experience of collaboration among stakeholders. Once again is the connective, rather than disruptive, aspect that motivates the paper, and that forms its core in understanding best practices through which interoperability can work. As many concepts, interoperability can be programmed into systems to generate detrimental outcomes. Works on digital identity (see for example Weitzberg, 2025) show how making data interoperable can support results as negative as the denial of a national ID card to entitled users, or the impossibility for them to access key provisions offered in refugee camps. A resonance lens does not deny such outcomes, but centers what can be achieved when systems are made interoperable in ways that support, rather than counter, the preservation of human rights. Digital identity research, some of which is featured in Issue 32(2) (Maharjan, 2026), can benefit from combating the degenerative outcomes that previous instantiations have illustrated (e.g. Masiero & Arvidsson, 2021). 4 Critique Encompassing Hope and Aspiration Ganapathy (2025) makes an important reflection on positive (digital) development. She shares the concern that positive and hopeful approaches can be dismissed as naïve and uncritical, especially in fields of science that are predicated on critical enquiry. So what is the “right” route to a mature, critical conceptualisation that also encompasses positivity? Papers in Issue 32(2) are critical in nature, and yet leverage core elements of critique to build positive understandings of artefacts at the core of development. An example is the paper by Maharajan (2026). In “ID Support: Digital Capitalism and the Digital National Identification Development Project in Nepal”, he introduces the concept of ID support to capture the promises and risks of interventions that contribute to the rapid expansion of digital ID systems. Using Nepal as its core case enables the author to present an ecosystem view of digital ID: one that involves a multilateral donor (from which Nepal received two grants), as well as a multinational big tech company which set up the ID system infrastructure. The paper sees digital capitalism, in the form of the power and politics of foreign aid and capital accumulation by multinational tech companies, as integral to ID support, and explores the dangers implicit in the multiple facets of that integration. At the same time, it proactively conceptualises the implications of overcoming the ID capitalist logic, suggesting routes that support human rights rather than the big tech centered conceptualisation of digital ID. Another instantiation of a similar view is “Digital Dawn in the Countryside: E-Commerce as a Catalyst for Entrepreneurship in Rural China”. In this paper, Cao and Li (2026) frame entrepreneurship as a critical engine for China’s rural revitalisation. The paper problematises the effectiveness of market linkage mechanisms as catalysts for entrepreneurial development, and finds that the presence of e-commerce distribution stations on the one hand, enhances entrepreneurial activity at the village level. On the other, the question on the effectiveness of “development” spurred by entrepreneurial activity remains an open question, which the authors contemplate in relation to the expected role of entrepreneurship. While a “digital dawn” does not necessarily uplift villages in China, authors present possible ways through which it can do so. Ganapathy, Heeks and Iazzolino (2026) also contributed a similar conceptualisation. In “Analyzing Inclusion and Inequalities in ICT4D: A Critical Literature Review of Themes and Gaps”, they conduct a critical literature review of the relationship between ICTs, inclusion, and inequalities, comprising of 77 articles on the topic. They find, on the one hand, that digital inclusion theorisations have moved on from access-only, technodeterministic approaches: at the same time, they see how the literature continues to predominantly engage with how to maximise the development benefits of ICTs, not always contemplating more complex and politicised dynamics. Their theorisation of a “paradigm lag” in this space does not relinquish ideas of positive development: it does, however, flag the need for addressing that lag, through theorisation that is more present to socially embedded approaches to ICT4D and its dynamics. The papers mentioned here mirror Ganapathy’s (2025) point, that positive and hopeful approaches do not need be naïve, much less dismissive of critical views of reality. These are papers that on the one hand, show awareness of systemic contradiction and power imbalances in their studied realities: and on the other, they place emphasis on what can be done about injustices, highlighting routes to overcoming them rather than choosing passive acceptance. Again with Heeks (2025), these are papers that show “what is right—and how can it be strengthened, shared, or scaled?”, and put that into clear antithesis to the injustices that IT artefacts can produce. A positive development view alone does not resolve the systemic issues ICT4D research is confronted with. Nor does it absolve the mission of countering data harm, responsibility that a previous editorial (Masiero, 2026) has ascribed to ICT4D research. It does, however, support a collective effort in which harm is diagnosed, accounted for, and – in many ways – countered, for the possibility of a better world with data to become more real. And it is in that respect that this editorial, on the wave of the IFIP 9.4 conference 2026, invites the exploration of the possibility of positive development, for ICT4D research to confront its responsibility and be nourished by the aspiration of positive approaches.
Zitieren
APA
Masiero, S. (2026). Editorial: Information Technology for Development, Volume 32, Issue 2. Information Technology for Development, 32(2), 91-97. https://doi.org/10.17705/1itd.032204
Vancouver
Masiero S. Editorial: Information Technology for Development, Volume 32, Issue 2. Information Technology for Development. 2026;32(2):91-97. doi:10.17705/1itd.032204
BibTeX
@article{Masiero2026,
author = {Masiero, Silvia},
title = {Editorial: Information Technology for Development, Volume 32, Issue 2},
journal = {Information Technology for Development},
year = {2026},
volume = {32},
number = {2},
pages = {91--97},
doi = {10.17705/1itd.032204}
}
EUVIMED