Plural Values, United Conversations: Why Deliberative Democracy and Metaethical Value Pluralism Are Compatible
Phenomenology and Mind · 2026 · 30 · 1
DOI: 10.17454/pam-3001 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Phenomenology and Mind, 2026. Verfasst von Christian Blum.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Metaethical value pluralism is the claim that there are many equally fundamental values that matter for normative choice, rather than one fundamental value. Deliberative democracy is an ideal from political theory stating that respectful, reasoned communicative contestations between free and equal citizens about the relative merits of policies is preferable to mere majoritarian voting. At first glance, both claims go together well. However, several theorists argue that they are incompatible: Value pluralists cannot be deliberative democrats, and deliberative democrats cannot be value pluralists. The argument rests on the supposition that plural fundamental values preclude a common standard of comparison that allows for weighing off different values, thereby rendering deliberation about value conflicts pointless. I argue that this supposition is implausible: Plural fundamental values can be rationally compared. The key is to conceive of the relevant standard as less fundamental than the values at stake. I conclude that value pluralists can remain neutral on the issue of deliberative democracy and that deliberative democrats can and should be value pluralists.
Zitieren
APA
Blum, C. (2026). Plural Values, United Conversations: Why Deliberative Democracy and Metaethical Value Pluralism Are Compatible. Phenomenology and Mind, 30, 1. https://doi.org/10.17454/pam-3001
Vancouver
Blum C. Plural Values, United Conversations: Why Deliberative Democracy and Metaethical Value Pluralism Are Compatible. Phenomenology and Mind. 2026;30:1. doi:10.17454/pam-3001
BibTeX
@article{Blum2026,
author = {Blum, Christian},
title = {Plural Values, United Conversations: Why Deliberative Democracy and Metaethical Value Pluralism Are Compatible},
journal = {Phenomenology and Mind},
year = {2026},
volume = {30},
pages = {1},
doi = {10.17454/pam-3001}
}
EUVIMED