The Antisthenean Aporia in Aristotle’s Metaphysics H 3
Aristotelica · 2026 · 9 · 3
DOI: 10.17454/arist09.01 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Aristotelica, 2026. Verfasst von Luigi Ferrari.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
R&S Facebook Instagram Home Chi siamo Collane Biblioteca di Attualità Lacaniana Biblioteca di Studi Francesi CORONA PATRVM ERASMIANA Diritto al presente Filosofie dell'arte Filosofia e letteratura Gemme Impact Housing Studies I saggi di Eranos La critica sociale Le Scienze. Storia-teoria-metodo-etica Orizzonti del pensiero Orizzonti geopolitici Parole d'artista / In the Words of the Artist Phýsis Psicoanalisi contemporanea Questioni di genere Quaderni della Valle dell’Eden Ritratti. Collana di etnografie Rivista di Estetica. I Quaderni. Le arti contemporanee Scienza nuova Scuola di Alta Formazione Filosofica Spiriti del nostro tempo Sviluppo e territori Terreni di confronto Riviste Ardeth Aristotelica Attualità Lacaniana Historia Magistra La Valle dell'Eden Magazzini Mechrí Phenomenology and Mind Quaderni di Comunicazione Scientifica Quaderni di Sociologia Rivista di Estetica Studi Francesi Studi Tanatologici Teoria politica Catalogo Antropologia Architettura e design Economia e diritto Filosofia Francofonia Linguistica Politica Psicologia e psicoanalisi Questioni di genere Religioni e spiritualità Sociologia Storia Contatti ENG Aristotelica n. 9 n. 9/2026 a cura di Silvia Fazzo anno di pubblicazione 2026 pp. 178 ISBN pdf 9791259934673 bio indice articoli Editorial pdf 44.8 KB aristotelica09_01 0,00 € download Ferrari,The Antisthenean Aporia in Aristotle’s Metaphysics H 3 ORCID ↗ pdf 964 KB ABSTRACT ↗ DOI 10.17454/ARIST09.01 aristotelica09_02 0,00 € download Baudroux, Time and Soul: Physics IV 14.223a21-29 in Neoplatonism from Plotinus to Simplicius ORCID ↗ pdf 151.2 KB ABSTRACT ↗ DOI 10.17454/ARIST09.02 aristotelica09_03 0,00 € download Trostyanskiy, Simplicius on Aristotle’s Paradox of the Now ORCID ↗ pdf 337.2 KB ABSTRACT ↗ DOI 10.17454/ARIST09.03 aristotelica09_04 0,00 € download Aslanyan, Aristotle as the Basis of Neoplatonic Instruction in the Armenian Tradition ORCID ↗ pdf 204.1 KB ABSTRACT ↗ DOI 10.17454/ARIST09.04 aristotelica09_05 0,00 € download Zambiasi-Fazzo, The Discovery of a New Witness to William of Moerbeke’s Translation of Aristotle’s De animalibus in Vercelli, Museo Leone ORCID ↗ pdf 2.8 MB ABSTRACT ↗ DOI 10.17454/ARIST09.05 aristotelica09_06 0,00 € download Ghione, Il libro Epsilon della Metaphysica Nova arabo-latina nell’edizione apud Junctas (1562) / The Book Epsilon of the Arabic-Latin Metaphysica Nova in the apud Junctas Edition (1562) ORCID ↗ pdf 557.6 KB ABSTRACT ↗ DOI 10.17454/ARIST09.06 aristotelica09_07 0,00 € download Ugaglia, Potenza e atto: l’infinito in Aristotele e Leibniz / Potentiality and Actuality: The Infinite in Aristotle and Leibniz ORCID ↗ pdf 255.1 KB ABSTRACT ↗ DOI 10.17454/ARIST09.07 aristotelica09_08 0,00 € download LEXIS Compagnia Editoriale in Torino srl Via Carlo Alberto 55 10123 Torino p.iva IT07603910014 www.lexis.srl Info Informazioni generali e FAQ Modalità e costi di spedizione Codice etico Cookies Policy Privacy Policy Seguici Facebook Instagram In Metaphysics H 3 (1043b4-32), Aristotle develops a unified account of definition that culminates in the so-called “Aporia of the Antistheneans.” This article offers a new interpretation of the role of that aporia within the overall argument of the chapter. It argues that Aristotle first criticizes two different conceptions of definition: on the one hand, materialist compositional theories, represented by the epistemological model known from Plato’s Theaetetus as the “Dream Theory”; on the other, certain Academic attempts to define substance through genus and differentia. According to Aristotle, both approaches ultimately fail to account for the unity of substance and, consequently, for the unity of its definition. Against this background, the introduction of the Aporia of the Antistheneans acquires a precise philosophical function. Rather than constituting an isolated digression or an independent refutation of Antisthenes, it serves as a dialectical step that exposes the limitations of a non-essentialist epistemology while preparing Aristotle’s own hylomorphic account of definition. A close analysis of the structure of the passage shows how the different philosophical positions brought into the discussion progressively converge toward Aristotle’s solution, according to which the unity of matter and form is the necessary condition of scientific definition. The article thus proposes an integrated reading of Metaphysics H 3 in which the Aporia of the Antistheneans is not an isolated textual difficulty but a central moment in Aristotle’s argumentative strategy for reformulating, through critical engagement, the principal theories of definition current in the philosophical debates of his time.Close
Zitieren
APA
Ferrari, L. (2026). The Antisthenean Aporia in Aristotle’s Metaphysics H 3. Aristotelica, 9, 3. https://doi.org/10.17454/arist09.01
Vancouver
Ferrari L. The Antisthenean Aporia in Aristotle’s Metaphysics H 3. Aristotelica. 2026;9:3. doi:10.17454/arist09.01
BibTeX
@article{Ferrari2026,
author = {Ferrari, Luigi},
title = {The Antisthenean Aporia in Aristotle’s Metaphysics H 3},
journal = {Aristotelica},
year = {2026},
volume = {9},
pages = {3},
doi = {10.17454/arist09.01}
}
EUVIMED