Retraction of the landmark glyphosate safety publication by Williams, Kroes and Munro (2000) should be reversed
EXCLI Journal · 14.07.2026 · 25 · 1107-1116
DOI: 10.17179/excli2026-9644 ↗Kurz gefasst
Leserbrief in der Zeitschrift EXCLI Journal, online erschienen am 14.07.2026. Verfasst von Christopher J Borgert und 59 weiteren Autor:innen. Beteiligte Einrichtung: Applied Pharmacology & Toxicology, Inc., Gainesville, FL, USA. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The decision by the co-Editor-in-Chief of Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology, Prof. Martin van den Berg, to retract the 2000 review article by Williams, Kroes, and Munro has elicited widespread criticism within the scientific community. Issued in late 2025, the retraction decision cites procedural concerns including potential ghostwriting, undisclosed conflicts of interest, and omission of certain unpublished studies, invoking Committee on Publication Ethics guidelines despite lacking evidence of fraud or scientific flaws. This editorial argues that the retraction decision involves editorial overreach and misapplication of the guidelines. The alleged omissions stemmed from proprietary data access limitations that were disclosed in the original paper. Subsequent reviews by several independent expert panels and regulatory authorities with access to all glyphosate data, including the studies cited by the retracting editor, reached similar conclusions. Claims of ghostwriting were previously investigated and found lacking, including a declaration by EFSA as to the clarity of the conflict disclosures. The retraction’s timing, reliance on litigation documents, and apparent biases that were not disclosed in the retraction notice raise questions of ideological interference. Absent substantive rebuttals based on scientific merit rather than speculative claims of inappropriate authorship and data access, this retraction decision sets a dangerous precedent for retroactive censorship, potentially chilling beneficial industry-academic collaborations and eroding trust in the integrity of scientific publishing. With the strongest conviction, we assert that retracting a paper without scientific flaws isn’t protection—it is censorship. We therefore call for the immediate reversal of this flawed and unjustified retraction to preserve trust in peer-reviewed literature.
Schlagwörter
Stichwörter der Autor:innen
Autor:innen und Institutionen
- Applied Pharmacology & Toxicology, Inc., Gainesville, FL, USA.
- Mohammad Abdollahi, Department of Toxicology and Pharmacology, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
- Jay M. Ansell, Principal, Bellevue Toxicology LLC, Alexandria VA, USA.
- Michael Aschner, Department of Molecular Pharmacology, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Bronx, NY, USA.
- Christopher A. Bates, H.B. Fuller, Saint Paul, MN, USA.
- Sir Colin Berry, Prof. (emeritus) of Pathology, Queen Mary, London, UK.
Zitieren
APA
Borgert, C. J., Abdollahi, M., Ansell, J. M., Aschner, M., Bates, C. A., Berry, S. C., Bolon, B., Boogaard, P. J., Budinksy, R. A., Burgoon, L. D., Burin, G., Bus, J. S., Clewell, H., Cohen, S. M., Colnot, T., Darby, P. S., Dekant, W., DeSesso, J., Dietrich, D. R., …, & Tsuji, J. (2026). Retraction of the landmark glyphosate safety publication by Williams, Kroes and Munro (2000) should be reversed. EXCLI Journal, 25, 1107-1116. https://doi.org/10.17179/excli2026-9644
Vancouver
Borgert CJ, Abdollahi M, Ansell JM, Aschner M, Bates CA, Berry SC, et al. Retraction of the landmark glyphosate safety publication by Williams, Kroes and Munro (2000) should be reversed. EXCLI Journal. 2026;25:1107-1116. doi:10.17179/excli2026-9644
BibTeX
@article{Borgert2026,
author = {Borgert, Christopher J and Abdollahi, Mohammad and Ansell, Jay M and Aschner, Michael and Bates, Christopher A and Berry, Sir Colin and Bolon, Brad and Boogaard, Peter J and Budinksy, Robert A and Burgoon, Lyle D and Burin, Gary and Bus, James S and Clewell, Harvey and Cohen, Samuel M and Colnot, Thomas and Darby, Paul S and Dekant, Wolfgang and DeSesso, John and Dietrich, Daniel R and Djukic, Mirjana and Docea, Anca Oana and Domingo, Jose L and Eaton, David L and Engelhardt, Jeffery A and Fairbrother, Anne and Felsot, Allan and Fenner-Crisp, Penelope A and Gentry, Robinan and Goodman, Jay I and Gori, Gio B and Greim, Helmut and Heslop-Harrison, J S and Hengstler, Jan G and Jaeschke, Hartmut and Kaminski, Norbert E and Kacew, Sam and Kim, James and Kiorpes, Anthony L and Klaassen, Curtis and Klaunig, James E and Loccisano, Anne and MacDonald, James S and Mally, Angela and Marquardt, Hans W J and Marty, M Sue and Matthews, John C and McClellan, Roger O and Meeks, Robert G and Millner, Glenn C and Pariza, Michael W and Paustenbach, Dennis and Pelkonen, Olavi and Sarvadi, David and Savolainen, Kai and Simon, Ted W and Smith, Carr J and Solomon, Keith R and Tarka, Stanley M and Tsatsakis, Aristidis M and Tsuji, Joyce},
title = {Retraction of the landmark glyphosate safety publication by Williams, Kroes and Munro (2000) should be reversed},
journal = {EXCLI Journal},
year = {2026},
volume = {25},
pages = {1107--1116},
doi = {10.17179/excli2026-9644}
}
EUVIMED